50 Best American Restaurants near New Market

“I don’t normally leave reviews, but I have to this time! I only found out about it because a friend was raving about how good it is on Facebook and I am so glad she did! If I could give more than 5 stars, I would. From the moment you walk in, you get that clean, welcoming hometown atmosphere that instantly makes you feel comfortable. But the best part is the food! This was our third time there and everything we’ve tried has been absolutely delicious! My personal favorite is the homemade butternut squash soup. I’m very particular about butternut squash soup, and this is hands down the best I’ve ever had! You can truly taste the care and quality in every bite. Highly recommend!“

“excellent service and professional staff definitely be back“

“We had the most amazing Brunch at Vintage. Would highly recommend. Best Brunch in Frederick by far for price & quality.“

“Love the food and drinks and the entertainment. HOWEVER- we were there for Cliff Cody and it was a very hot day. Sat under the sail shade and still it was terribly hot. The management could really boost its comfort level for customers by simply installing either a misting fan system or a few fans on stands around the patio. It was so hot we could hardly concentrate on the entertainment and even though we had planned on staying longer and eating and drinking more, we had to leave long before we had planned, simply because of the heat.“

“Food was great. Atmosphere was cozy. We were a party of 8. Our waiter Barry was very attentive. He added greatly to the whole experience with his jokes and demeanor.“

“Amazing food and drinks! Great service especially from our server Frankie! Fabulous in every way“

“We used to frequent this restaurant often when we lived in Frederick. We returned for my 70th birthday dinner. As usual, Rich did an outstanding job, not only with our meals but also with meals designed for our vegan/vegetarian children. Trish, our server , was also excellent. Just sorry that we didn’t get to see Kelly. You must go to this restaurant!! Pam Keipper“

“Had dinner here for the first time the other evening, Jason was a great server, very attentive and polite! Food was amazing and happy hours specials are great. Will definitely go back again! Very cozy and nicely decorated inside too!“

“Highly recommended! The customer service is top notch and so is the food. I’ve tried the soups and rotating food items and all are absolutely delicious! This is one of my go-tos in Frederick. The Chicken Salad Caesar Wrap is SO good 😊“

“Long post ahead, warning! I walked in around 9 pm and the hostess didn't bat an eye at my dining alone, and didn't say anything about it, which I appreciate. I was seated right away with no problems and immediately got a chance to look over the menu. I will admit, it took a little bit longer than expected for my waiter to come over, but as a lone diner I sort of expected that. I looked like I was waiting for someone, I'm sure. The look and feel of the place was very upscale, but they didn't have any problems with me walking in wearing a nerdy t-shirt. I was seated in this cute little booth for 2 with curtains on the side so, if I wanted a more private dinner, I could have it. It was a cute touch! The restaurant also offered patio dining and since it's by the creek, that would have been a downright charming experience were it not the usual Maryland summer. Despite having a bar, the restaurant was respectably quiet and low-key, making it an easy dining experience. I wasn't in the mood for something wild, and this place really hit the nail on the head. My first waiter Kevin, however, was the picture of polite helpfulness. He answered all of my questions, made some wonderful suggestions, and was incredibly pleasant to talk to. I was delighted to find out that this place takes part in DC restaurant week, so I was able to take part in that promotion. Under a suggestion from Kevin, I ordered a glass of their moscato (I wanted something light and sweet), and the wine was so good I brought home a whole bottle. Not really on them, but it does reflect their excellent selection. Dinner itself was delicious. The red pepper soup was refreshing and flavorful, without being too filling. The steak I ordered was cooked to perfection and was flavored in the perfect way to make the actual flavor of the meat shine. The potatoes were both light and fluffy, but also had the little chunks of potato that I prefer in my mashed. The best part was desert. About halfway through my appetizer, Kevin introduced my other waiter, Maddy, who took over after he went home. She was as much of a delight as he was, and made possibly the best recommendation of the night. Desert was this blackberry tart that I did not have room for but could not put down. Gooey and crumbly all at once, with a warm center that was almost caramel-y even though it was fruit based. Topped with a light cream to balance it all out, it was absolutely delicious. I will be thinking of that tart all day tomorrow. The prices on the menu were a little high, but I wouldn't go so far to say they were unreasonable. If I had wanted a cheaper option, I could have gone to any chain restaurant ever. In the grand scheme of downtown Frederick, with it's many small businesses and one of a kind dining experiences, I think this was reasonable. For reference, a lot of meals were between $20 and $30, but a good steak is almost always $30+. Despite the price, I had an exceptional dining experience, and would 100% recommend this place to anyone looking for upscale dining, without the upscale requirements.“

“Our expectations for a culinary arts program were medium to high; however, given that it was a learning experience for the kitchen and front-of-house staff, there would probably be some room for improvement. The menu offered a variety of entree choices, including pork chop, pasta primavera, chicken, and salmon. We were instructed by the hostess that each person at our table should order a different entree to make it easier for the kitchen staff. The server provided little explanation about the menu choices and preparation. When the entrees were delivered, however, confusion ensued when the servers presented the dishes to each diner incorrectly. Wine was ordered, and the pours were not consistent in each glass, probably about 4 oz. or less each. The entrees were expertly prepared with flavorful sauces and seasonings; however, the table received little attention during the meal. We all agreed that the food quality and tastiness of the food were excellent, but the dining experience would have been outstanding if the service had been at a higher level.“

“Mike L was our server and we had an absolute 10/10 experience. Mike was so attentive to our table, and was so personable. Our food was fantastic as well, from apps to entrees, to desert. I cannot wait to go back, and Mike needs a raise!!“

“Our expectations for a culinary arts program were medium to high; however, given that it was a learning experience for the kitchen and front-of-house staff, there would probably be some room for improvement. The menu offered a variety of entree choices, including pork chop, pasta primavera, chicken, and salmon. We were instructed by the hostess that each person at our table should order a different entree to make it easier for the kitchen staff. The server provided little explanation about the menu choices and preparation. When the entrees were delivered, however, confusion ensued when the servers presented the dishes to each diner incorrectly. Wine was ordered, and the pours were not consistent in each glass, probably about 4 oz. or less each. The entrees were expertly prepared with flavorful sauces and seasonings; however, the table received little attention during the meal. We all agreed that the food quality and tastiness of the food were excellent, but the dining experience would have been outstanding if the service had been at a higher level.“

“Our first time coming here and won’t be our last! They have the best burgers and shakes!“

“had dinner last night for the first time. oh my why did we wit so long to visit. food was outstanding we will be back for sure. food and service were awesome!!“

“Just ordered a late breakfast for carry out and it was my first time ever eating from El Rancho. My food was ready when they said and it was and still hot when I got it home and very delicious. I LOVE that they serve breakfast all day and my steak was perfect! I’d recommend this place to anyone!“

“everything was great and help was nice and food was awesome“

“Our 45th anniversary dinner was made memorable by some very good food, topped by fantastic service. Place was a bit noisy - hard to hold a conversation and to hear waitress, but tolerable. Ahi tuna was superb, as were the ribs. The big surprise was how good the wedge salad was - lots of blue cheese and the candied bacon was delicious. Wife said it was the best bite of bacon she ever had. The manager checked in on us, as did the head chef! This will become a go-to spot for us.“

“A friend of mine recommended I try this place out. So happy they did. I went in on a Saturday night and missed the trivia, but enjoyed karaoke! Food was great and the drinks were affordable compared to downtown. The staff was very friendly and we couldn’t stop laughing. This will definitely be added to the weekend visit list. Highly recommend“

“I have been a ZiPani customer for years. Their food and service are always exceptional. Today, I went to grab a bagel from their shop after an appointment but instead found the staff in the parking lot handing out free bagels. Apparently, they had a plumbing issue that was causing them to have to close the store for a week. Their first concern was not for themselves, but for their customers. They didn't want their customers to be disappointed that they were closed so there were giving away what little product they could offer to anyone who came by. While I've been a customer for years, this only increased my sense of loyalty. I look forward to supporting them and picking up even more delicious bagels as soon as they are back up and running.“

“Outstanding food. Excellent service. Reasonable prices. Best crab cakes in Frederick. If you haven't been, you are missing out.“

“We found this place while visiting in the area and looking for something nice. Our server was very knowledgeable and friendly. The food was nothing short of amazing.“

“Our server Gyu-won P was top notch. Attentive but not annoying.“

“Great food and service! The chicken pot pie fritters are AMAZING!! Highly recommend!!“

“I recently visited Hornets Nest Grille and it quickly became one of my favorite local spots. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere feels warm, casual, and genuinely welcoming — the kind of place where you can relax whether you’re meeting friends, bringing family, or just grabbing a great meal. The food was outstanding. Everything tasted fresh, well-prepared, and clearly made with care. Portions were generous without being overwhelming, and the menu offers a solid mix of comfort food classics and creative options. It’s the kind of place where you struggle to decide what to order because everything sounds good. Service was just as impressive. The staff were friendly, attentive, and made us feel right at home without being intrusive. Drinks came quickly, food arrived hot, and we never felt rushed — a perfect balance. What really sets Hornet’s Nest apart is that authentic “local gem” vibe. It doesn’t feel corporate or cookie-cutter; it feels like a true community restaurant where people know each other and take pride in what they do. If you’re in the Damascus area and looking for a dependable spot with great food, fair prices, and welcoming service, Hornet’s Nest Grille is absolutely worth a visit. I’ll definitely be coming back. Þór Jórmundurssón ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“excellent food, grilled chicken is tender juicy and flavorful...Great 1st time will be back.“

“The newest incarnation of the bar/restaurant that was last Firestones continues the same tradition of very good food and drinks as the legacy tavern did. Props for having a Brunch menu that includes enough Lunch options to satisfy. The Cuban sandwich was the standout with the very interesting bread choice and unusual pulled pork. The Reuben was a straight-forward version.“

“Came in Sunday afternoon. It was pretty busy. Someone that works there let us know they would be right with us. We were sat. Lisa was our server. Everything was great! Food was good and came out in timely manner. Will definitely return.“

“Drinks were awesome. service was great.“

“Delicious food and excellent service. I’m so glad we picked this place to stop in for lunch.“

“I have been going to Tom and Rays since the old location. What makes them stand out is the cost conscience menu, fresh tasting food, and a staff mostly local high school kids that are professional with can do attitude. Right now I’m raving about something as simple as stewed tomatoes as a complementary side dish. Their breakfast foods including creamed chipped beef fresh. Their lunch and dinner foods bring you back, especially the open faced beef sandwich with mash potatoes and gravy, to a simpler time. Check out their menu and ask them about their pies.“

“Don't lose your investment in forex trade/bitcoin. Go with a proven legitimate trader that allows your unrestricted access to your account. I recommend Mrs Craig Vanessa for anyone in need of a reliable account manager because she has really helped me and got me restored from previous losses and it's been cool all the way. Invest with her today and enjoy a profitable trading experience. Now I am making profit of $5,500 weekly. Contact her through Facebook: Mrs Craig Vanessa“

“As four guests visiting for the first time, we all thought the food was great. Service was slow to order a beer and desert was almost cancelled because of time and the glazing did not arrive with one of the deserts and getting a side cup never arrived. The waitress was new and very helpful and will get better with experience. The only disappointment was their Military Discount? They only allow 10% for "active" Military making one feel that veterans just don't qualify? And the 10% you receive is only on the members main meal. So for a $60.61 meal the discount was $1.49? I give the discount I receive back to the wait staff and left a $15.00 tip.“

“Recently discovered Cellar Door when traveling to Mount St. Mary Collage and the family needed a place to eat. Wow were we impressed. The food was amazing (Complements to the Chef) the floor staff and our waitress were on point and boy did she make us not only laugh and have a good time but she rocked the house to make us at home. I highly recommend the culinary and cultural experience. Bravo to everyone.“

“We just had the best burgers ever! What a wonderful treat!“

“Great crowd, drinks, and food!“

“Place to go after you eat at Avery’s. Great DJ and dancing.“

“My husband and I went to Longhorn Steakhouse yesterday. The food was really good, the prices are very reasonable, the atmosphere was nice. I’d like to shout out our waiter CT. He was awesome. He made sure we were attended to in a timely manner, he checked on us throughout our time there, and I loved that he had a kind and welcoming demeanor. I’m very big on customer service. We will definitely recommend this place.“

“Very slow And when I responded slow to the cashiers question of how was everything, she offered no response. And then ridiculed me when I was late informing her I was a rewards member. Perhaps more training when a negative critique is offered.“

“Always excellent! Creative and delicious menu with stunning views of Sugarloaf Mountain. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. Every brunch we’ve had here has been perfection! Highly recommend anything on the menu. Also, great beer, wine, and cocktail selection. Highly recommend the Bloody Mary.“

“Waitress was very friendly and food was excellent. Even my son who’s a picky eater loved his food.“

“Great food, cold beer, and friendly folks that serve them both.“

“What a great find. I was at the bar, it was a quiet night but from the food there was great, same thing for the restaurant has to be great too. Almost all plates are made on the property and so tasty. The desserts were great too. We'll be back when we are in the area in April.“

“Nothing pretentious about this place and the food is outstanding. We've had several dishes and all were excellent. There is also entertainment in checking out all of the flight memorabilia surrounding each room. You might even be able to check out the landings and takeoffs from your table. Well worth the trip.“

“Best sushi in Frederick. I truthfully go twice a week at minimum for lunch“

“Great place to go in downtown Frederick. The atmosphere was great. No wait to be seated. Our server Brandi’s was fantastic and very attentive. Her recommendations for our food and beverages were perfect. Loved the crab dip. I highly recommend this place.“

“I love this place! Highly recommended.“

“Magoos Tavern is the GOAT.“

“Had great experience at Mays, crabs were heavy and the drinks kept coming. Great food, Great service! We will definitely be coming back, Thanks Aleecia for making our night so enjoyable, we will be asking for you next time ?“

“Have lived all over the world. This is one of my love spots. All of the crew here are amazing. First of all I will mention the ladies out of respect. Jessica, Kim, Ali in particular, and the young gentleman josh! Some of the most amazing meat I have had anywhere on earth! This place is a gem and the crew including sir james! Absolutely amazing above and beyond. Thank you!“