16 Best Italian Restaurants near New Windsor

“My family just moved to the area, and Belisimos has kept us fed on multiple occasions when I didn't have the energy to cook. I wanted to leave a review because not only is the food good and the value excellent, but the customer service is wonderful. I just placed an order, and the gentleman I spoke to on the phone was incredibly kind. Then I realized that every time we have had an interaction with someone at Belisimos, it has been pleasant, so I might as well leave a review.“

“I was a guest at a birthday celebration today. Our server was Brandy and she was awesome. There were appoximately 40+ attendees and she handled the entire group with ease and professionalism. As a side note the food was great!!“

“We found this restaurant by accident, and we are glad we did. we got a veggie pizza and a chicken parmesan sub. The pizza is one of the best we have had - and we have had a lot! the crust is perfect, the cheese and toppings are fresh and very good and the sauce is perfect. The chicken parm was absolutely delicious. We will be trying more things on the menu now.“

“Great eggplant parm this evening. Wonderful staff and kind, attentive gracious owner. A nice family night out.“

“I will sometimes get the Wednesday pizza special. Never disappoints. I decided today I was going to also order a cheesesteak sub. I could only eat half of it because it was so big. I drove down from Taneytown and now I have my place for pizza and cheesesteak subs. You got me as a customer. Highly recommend“

“We visited Westminster last Thursday to meet up with my sister who recently moved to Frederick, Md from Hawaii. We stopped first at TownHall Mall and were very impressed with the stores that were open. Disappointed that many stores were only open on weekends. Stopped at Jeannie Bird Bakery for a late afternoon snack. Wow! What a great selection of baked items! We tried some scones which for late afternoon were incredibly fresh and tasty. Also tried a slice focaccia bread which was delicious. The staff was extremely friendly. Their iced tea was remarkable. So sorry that we live in Bel Air an hour away. Would make this bakery our #1 eatery.“

“I’ll be honest, I was both excited and skeptical about trying Wonder when it first opened. The whole concept seemed a little strange to me, and I wasn’t sure how it would actually work. Since they were offering 50% off for first time customers when I went, I figured it was worth a try.

We ordered a pizza from Alanza, a double cheeseburger from Burger Baby, and a Build Your Own Bowl from El Diez. Funny enough, the burger, which was the item I was least excited about based on how it looked, ended up being my favorite. It was honestly one of the best burgers I’ve had in a long time. The pizza was a little overdone, but I actually like my pizza that way, so no complaints there. The bowl was good too, though I felt like it was missing a little something. Maybe some extra lime or cilantro would have given it more of that fresh Mexican flavor.

I’d definitely come back and try some of the other restaurants they have. I also really liked the atmosphere. It was quiet, clean, and didn’t feel chaotic, which was nice. The kitchen area looked especially clean, which always leaves a good impression.

If you’ve been curious about Wonder and are looking to try something different, I’d say it’s worth checking out, especially while they’re offering 50% off for new customers. There’s a huge variety of food options, so it’s easy for everyone in your group to find something they’ll enjoy. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised and left more impressed than I expected to be.“

“Had not been to Olive Garden in years and was honestly surprised by the overall quality of the food. It was much better than expected. The Lasagna Fritta appetizer, basically deep fried pieces of lasagna served with marinara sauce, was surprisingly tasty and a great start to the meal. The soups were all very flavorful, though a bit on the salty side. The salad was the weak point for me since it barely had any dressing or seasoning. The famous breadsticks were also disappointing and tasted a little stale despite supposedly being fresh from the oven. The main dishes were decent overall, nothing particularly memorable, but certainly not bad. Service was very good though, and our waiter was friendly, attentive, and stayed on top of everything throughout the meal. One thing that really stood out was the $6 take-home meals, which ended up being a great value and made for an easy lunch the next day.“

“Everything was so delicious from our salads, main entrees to dessert! I absolutely loved the cheese filled tortellini with cream sauce and pancetta. The lemon cream cake was also very good as well as the incredible service.“

“My kids and I have become regulars at Tony's. I have a 1-year-old girl and a 3-year-old boy. We always order a large cheese pizza, which is absolutely delicious. Our regular waitress, Brandy, knows our order now and puts it in right as we're walking in, sometimes before we've even entered the building if she sees us in the parking lot. And last night she went above and beyond - she had a little stocking for each of my kids with little surprises tucked inside. Never have I ever had a waitress or waiter go out of their way like that. Brandy is fantastic. Now back to the pizza, it's delicious! And for $14.99, I can take my kids and I, and even one of their grandparents along with us, and we can all have dinner "on the cheap" , and give my kids a great experience of learning how to dine out.“

“We had dinner here last night and everything was incredibly delicious. I tried the Chicken Caesar Sub for the first time and I will definitely get it again. The sub roll was soft on the inside and lightly toasted crispy on the outside. The crab deviled eggs were amazing!!!! The bruschetta was tender and not chewy so the toppings never fell off as you took a bite. The cheese pizza was perfect and the Snake Dog IPA was ice cold. Denise was our server and she knew the menu in its entirety and provided impeccable service. The dining room was full and people were endlessly coming in to pick up their take out order. Can’t wait to go back!!!!! Highly recommend all the way around!!!! Thank you, Amante, for a fantastic experience!!!“

“Visiting from Texas craving pizza, seemed 4 out of 5 people recommended Ledos. Well the pepperoni pizza was just okay. Square shape is great but the crust and just overall was somewhat flavorless. Edible but no wow factor, if this is all your town has then is what it is. Even cold next day pizza was same, just no flavor. Mozzarella sticks were also pretty bland and marinara sauce was as sameSo go try it for yourself just manage your expectations.“

“I received my order that my mom had sent me money for (a treat for the kids because they had a good first week at school) I didn’t have enough for a tip and I’m a struggling mom of 4 so I didn’t have enough to put one. Delivery driver stood at my door , (I was doing my youngest hair for school tomorrow) and my oldest daughter took it from him and he asked my daughter if “your parents are home” which I replied, “oh I’m right here.” Then said “thank you!” Thinking he would walk away and leave. No. The guy practically came in my door and said “you good?” I said “yep” he goes “no tip? There was none on the card?!” I said “oh i, uh..” (still fumbling with daughter’s hair). Then he continued to just stand there and stare at me while he’s half way in my house, would not leave. So I had my daughter go get her jar she had saved money in and gave him the $3 they had in it telling them I’ll replace it as soon as I get paid. He left and I’m still in freaking tears. I understand there’s a thing of “if you don’t have it don’t order” but my mom was just trying to do something nice for my children and make them feel special. I am lost for words.“

“Love it.very Nice people“

“Let me start by saying I love Classico’s! Best pizza and subs! However the chicken tenders are frozen out of a bag, were over cooked and some burnt no taste. Not up to par with there other items. Over priced for overcooked Tyson chicken tenders 😞. Will stick to what I know is good.“

“Thank you to Tony and the J&P staff who went above and beyond to make sure everything ran smoothly over the weekend for my grandfather's celebration of life. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was just right, and having a private space made the event feel personal and comfortable. We’re so grateful for their kindness and care during such an important day.“