17 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Buffalo

“Order a large pizza pepperoni with light cheese for delivery in an hour later they came with a cold pizza. I called the restaurant back and spoke to I believe was a manager. He fixed the problem and sent out a hot one ASAP. Excellent service excellent delivery driver.“

“Excellent atmosphere inside and out! Excellent salads, with tender generous steak chunks and one with tender generous chicken, both with wonderful dressings! Bruschetta- amazing! Kristen and bar tender teammate were perfect! Highly recommend!“

“I have been going to The Stray Dog for years. I have never had a bad experience there. The food is great and the service is superb! Also, if any of the ladies out there need a "personal plumber", I am available to service your unfulfilled fantasies.“

“Such a cute spot with amazing pizza, fried pickles and cookies. Our family enjoyed an outing to Villa Nova. Coming back soon!“

“Crispy, crunchy, cheesy. Excellent recommendation on the sausage slice.“

“My absolute favorite pizza! Drive up once a month from Illinois to enjoy it!“

“This was our first visit to the Staymaker, which is the restaurant within the Journeyman Distillery. We are visiting from Chicago and this was recommended and we were not disappointed! Everything was really excellent! From our charming and attentive server Hailey, to the amazing smoked trout spread app to the Trout entree and the brisket meatloaf. It was all so delicious! We will be back!“

“This pizza was delicious!!! I would have to say that it was the best thin crust pizza that I have ever eaten! You can taste every topping individually because of the quality ingredients! I highly recommend their pizza with the olive oil! Healthy and delicious!“

“Pizza was just how I remembered it from the 80's tore the paper open and it was fantastic👍👍 but the cheese garlic bread was a white French roll cut in half with a slice of half melted cheese on it 👎👎 ill definitely be back for another pizza“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“It might be in a gas station but this pizza we ordered online and picked up was delicious! We bought the BBQ chicken with extra bacon and cheese. Definitely will buy again and grab some for lunch in between my jobs!*We bought an xl pizza with extra bacon and cheese and it was about 15! We had leftovers for a couple days!

Parking: It's a gas station, plenty of room to park!“

“Really good food, super nice people“

“Great place for meeting up with friends and enjoying wine time. The food is good… we ordered two flatbreads and both were good (Thai chili & jerk chicken). The burger was cool. However. We didn’t really care for the short rib sandwich.
The menu is small but I love that they use all types of flavors. The atmosphere is beautiful with nice views and they have outdoor pods you can rent for your group. Check it out! Nice spot :)“

“The best in town“

“Had a lovely meal tonight at Featherbone - Chef had a weekend special I saw online and he had one left tonight when I came in. Every bite was perfection! Thanks for the treat! Watch out folks- if you see the ribeye special again go for it!!!!“

“To be honest, this review may be biased... I was born in Michigan City in 1959 and grew up eating Albano's Pizza as a treat, and a treat it still is! I have lived in Florida for 41 years now, and still go to Albano's EVERY time I visit the area! So please, pay no attention to this review! It is completely one sided... God Bless the Albano's Pizza Family!“