23 Best American Restaurants near Shelbyville

“The Shelbyville Tavern has some of the best food around. It's just a small bar and grill in Shelbyville with very good service and very nice people. They have the best potato skins around and you can get them with ground beef on them which is something I've never seen before and it's delicious. They have a huge variety of deep fried appetizers that are all delicious. The drinks are great too. Very strong and worth every penny!!!“

“Stop in for a great pizza or some lottery, and perhaps you might be the next lucky customer to purchase a winning Club Keno ticket worth $10,000 like some unknown customer did on February 3, 2020. Perhaps the bartender knows, hope the winner tipped good!“

“Orangeville Tavern is hands down the best place for pizza! Their wood-fired pizza is out of this world—crispy crust, amazing toppings, and so much flavor. The service is always great, and the staff are super friendly. If you haven’t been here yet, you’re missing out!“

“Beautiful place for a meal outside on the patio with live music, sunshine and great food!“

“The corned beef hash is too delicious. The staff are overly kind and the place is cleaner than my sister's house. For more complaints, let's meet for breakfast!“

“Great food and friendly service“

“Excellent! Five Stars! Shari was sociable, attentive and the best waitress that we have had in any restaurant in a very long time. She has a great personality and knack for leadership. Thank you Shari for such a great meal and experience! We hope to see you soon!“

“Never a bad time at the Applebees here in Plainwell. Service is timely and always nice, I feel like I never have any trouble here. It’s a comfortable place to eat and meet up with friends. Shout out to Sofie as our server tonight. I genuinely enjoy coming here to dine.“

“My daughter loves this place“

“Always love coming here for mid-day dates with the hubby!“

“please be sure u have 10 people reservations for bible group. Hard of hearing. maybe a curtain to separate us from others. 4 pm on July 30. one check payable to pastor august. please confirm or maybe outside if quieter. august“

“I have a sister-in-law from Otsego that brought down the wonderful incredibly phenomenal blueberry cinnamon buns and I would highly recommend those best cinnamon roll I’ve ever had and now coming from Paw Paw to head to Otsego just to go there and experience more of their food. I can’t imagine if you pass this one up don’t and any opportunity you have be sure to go there ,You will not regret it.“

“Best restaurant in Otsego. Great food and everyone is very friendly.“

“They are open until 11PM ON Fridays and Saturdys“

“10/10 recommend ! I’m 9 months pregnant and my one request was extra ranch 😅& they went above and beyond to make sure we got all the ranch ! The food was always amazing! My toddler loves their burger & the chicken tenders are delicious & def hand battered“

“This place happens to be halfway between where my brother and I live. We met up here for the first time today and it was delicious! I have a gluten allergy and I was pleased with the amount of options for me. I had a salad and it was delicious. I can’t wait to go back! I want to try their fish and the gluten free carrot cake that was sold out. The service was also very good!“

“Great food , friendly people,“

“I grabbed breakfast here the other day with two of my kids. Of course, the kids spilled a whole glass of orange juice right after seating. The staff was helpful and accommodating. The food was awesome (I got the Eggs Benedict). Will be back.“

“McDuff’s is our absolute go-to!! Whenever we see Kiley and Heidi behind the bar, we know it’s going to be a fun and lighthearted experience ❤️ Honestly, we’ve never met a grumpy bartender here but the dynamic duo are our favorites!! If you’re looking for a bar that caters to you and makes you feel taken care of? Go to McDuff’s 🥰“

“When we lived in Plain well we loved this place! We came there tonight with friends and it was terrible l Food was called and when we complained the manager argued with us about how long we waited (We had reservations for 5:15) we didn't get our food until after 6! The manager said we had only been waiting an hour! Plus she made no attempt to warm up our food and just walked away! We drove 30 miles to get there and was treated terrible! Also there was an employee back in the kitchen that should of had his hair pulled back with hair down past his shoulders. We definitely will not be back!!“

“Great experience at the party room for a baby shower! Working with Keli was amazing. She was so accomidating and very helpful. Our server Casey was friendly and did a great job keeping the demanding ladies happy. The food was hot and delicious. Served was a buffet of appetizers, wings, meatballs, dunkers, spinich and artichoke dip, and brushette no one left hungry, and a good time was had by all!!“

“Great food and great service..macie the waitress was wonderful. Will stop again when up in your area.“

“Although I do agree of the overall rating of the buffet being 3.7 stars, I do think some of the reviews were a bit extreme. Come to this buffet with the expectation for buffet food and I think you’ll enjoy the experience more. My boyfriend and I came after experiencing a Vegas buffet and wanted something like this in area. This was the closest to where we live. Considering the market price of prime rib and crab legs, we felt the price was fair.
The service was excellent.
Food wise, the crab legs needed little forks , it was difficult to dig the meat out but the overall taste was good - it was just messy and work.
My bf said the prime rib - although medium rare -was a bit dry.
The pizza despite being from a pizza oven was not good but I didn’t expect much, the cheese bread however was perfectly cheesy and gooey.
We skipped the salad bar but I did breeze past it and it looked fresh.
The Asian section and Italian sections disappointed the most. The Alfredo wasn’t good and was the only vegetarian option and the Asian could have benefited from sushi rolls.
We overall enjoyed the American/Chefs/Mexican sections.
The guacamole and beans were flavorful. My boyfriend enjoyed the chimichangas and we both loved the mashed potatoes (wish I had gotten a plate of them) there was also a baked potato with a build your toppings section that looked good. The Mac and cheese disappointed me though. Too dry.
Desserts - I truly saved the best for last. We filled a plate up of one of everything so we could sample it all. The strawberry mousse was so light and fluffy, the espresso cupcake (which was my fav) was rich and flavorful, and my boyfriend devoured the strawberry cheesecake. Every bite we had of the desserts was enjoyable though.

I’m not sure if we would come back, maybe on a non crab leg day, but I did truly overall enjoy the experience.“