25 Best American Restaurants in Stillwater

“Kristin was friendly, attentive, and efficient. Food was delicious and arrived faster than I would have expected.“

“There are a lot of fancy places to eat in Stillwater, Minnesota, but you're never going to get anything better than this meatloaf. And if you're lucky enough to have Mary wait on you, all the better. I'm seriously not kidding. Don't skip this Meatloaf.“

“Lisa G., Janae was our waitress, too. We were the “3-J’s”: Joe, Junna, and Janae. Janae was swift, attentive, beautiful, and cheerful. She was always right there to refill my water glass. I wonder if she ran track in high school; she was fast!“

“We came in for their amazing shamrock shake martini! The hostess and the waitress were lovely! We were in a hurry due to hockey practice and they were on their A game getting us in and out while still providing a fun experience! Cheers🍀🍀🍀🍀“

“Every single dish we had was phenomenal! We gave compliments to the chef on truly inspired creations. Our favorite may have been the Brussels sprouts, but we truly loved everything we tried. The service was great - friendly, quick, knowledgeable. Thank you to the whole team for making our 20th Anniversary celebration so wonderful.“

“FABULOUS! My husband and I rarely try new places but this time we decided to go out of the norm. Cannot say enough great things. We sat at the bar and Timmy took care of us. Chef’s kiss 😘 We will be back!“

“One of the best restaurants on the east side of the twin cities, if you love wine with awesome food,this owner along with the staff, which is key, know how to serve the two together to have an unforgettable dinner. The wine shop has some phenomenal choices of wines you will not find anywhere else. Stillwater’s Domacin is a destination ❤️🍷🥂❤️“

“Another successful event made sweeter by Keys Cafe and Bakery! Whether it’s the Hudson, Stillwater, or any other location, you’re always welcomed and taken care of. There is seriously no shortage of customer service and support, quality ingredients and execution, alongside beautifully crafted and delivered homemade goods. A huge shoutout to Abigail and Amy at the Stillwater location! They brought our vision of a mini dessert bar to life and people are still talking about how incredible everything was. Thank you so much and do not hesitate On Keys Cafe for your next catering/event needs.“

“Phenomenal food and service! 10/10!“

“great service, food was ready quickly, and the food was delicious. price point was definitely good as well.“

“Trout Benedict was amazing. Farm fresh eggs with golden yolks. Trout patty crisp on the outside. Homemade Hollandaise. Perfection.“

“Food is great and beer is cold. Staff is super friendly!“

“Why have we waited so long to come back here?! Food and service were impeccable. If you are craving some awesome Greek food and a cozy environment, Phil’s Tara Hideaway is the spot. We will be back very soon!“

“Great little get together spot. small and cozy. Great service! Great prices.“

“We came to Stillwater for a nighttime get away and stumbled upon Sal’s. We were seated immediately, greeted by our waitress, Penny with a smile and great conversation! The menus had great variety and was delicious! This place is worth the trip for us and we WILL be back! Thanks Penny for your awesome service that made our visit that much better!“

“I've picked up a few orders from the restaurant lately and dined in last night. It is always great to see the staff genuinely having a great time at work while treating others like they're part of the family lakes again and we love it and will come back!“

“What we ordered was ok. The “ceviche” was just boiled shrimp with chopped onions, the shrimp was obviously not cooked with citric acid. Also there’s a “banh mi bowl” on the menu but the ingredients are Korean bulgogi and kimchi, nothing Vietnamese about it. You can’t just call a dish something because it sounds vaguely Asian to you. Good beer selection, cheese curds authentic.“

“Very pleased with Danny’s. Have heard about it for years and finally tried it. Excellent food! Music outside every third Saturday. Great views of Stoneridge golf course.“

“Culver's is always good; polite, clean and consistent.
Admittedly, we only stopped for a bio-break because they always have clean restrooms. Alas, something must have been in the beef that night (or the air - there was an air quality alert) as all stalls were full of patrons crafting thier own Flavor of the Day.
After a few impatient minutes, we moved on.“

“PD Pappys is the jewel of the St Croix in downtown Stillwater 💫“

“Fabulous service, delicious food and great prices!!! I’m glad we found this place, we look forward to our next visit!“

“Let's not let minors drink and then boot them out at closing time without knowing if they are getting home safe.“

“Just got done with dinner. This was our second time here this month. I introduced my kids to this restaurant and we all rated it five stars. The kids meal was generous. The pies were delicious. I got my favorite, honey mustard chicken salad. My kids now beg to come eat here every time we’re in Stillwater.“

“I randomly chose this place during a google search for all day breakfast near Stillwater, my significant other got the banana bread French toast and I got the taco salad with chicken. Chicken wasn’t dried up, the bean to salad ratio was on point, and the salsa wasn’t overly spicy but still had a little bit of a kick. The banana bread French toast wasn’t entirely what we expected but it was delicious, had a bit of an unexpected crunch due to caramelization and it was amazing. Our waitress Kathy was amazing! Checking in on us when we didn’t have our mouths full of food and was great with our out of the ordinary requests for peanut butter and an extra bowl so I didn’t make a total mess of the taco salad. 10/10 service! Will definitely be coming back again Thank you Kathy for making our first experience here amazing!“

“If you go to No Neck Tony's in Stillwater, do yourself a favor and order the burnt sugar old fashioned — it is hands down the BEST one I’ve had in my life. The drinks all around were phenomenal, perfectly crafted, and worth raving about. The atmosphere was lively, fun, and made the whole experience even better. Definitely a spot we’ll keep coming back to!“