Amighetti’s at the Top of the Hill
$ • Sandwich Shops, ItalianAbout Amighetti’s at the Top of the Hill
Customers' Favorites
Italian Beef with Cheese and Gravy
Roast Beef Gravy Sandwich
Chicken Parmigiano - Half
Hank's Cheesecake Slice
Turkey Special - Half
Simple Italian Salad
Amighetti’S Special
Tiramisu Cheesecake
Spaghetti Amighetti
Amighetti's Special
Recent Reviews
188 ratings
Share your opinion about Amighetti’s at the Top of the Hill
We love their loaded sub! I raved about it so much that my husband decided to try it, which is completely out of the norm. Now, we travel from about 20 miles away just for these great sandwiches! I should tell you I'm not a huge sandwich fan, so this says a lot. The bagels are fantastic also, and I am a very particular about needing chewy bagels. The carrot cake cheesecake was also excellent, but it truly is not cheesecake. it is simply carrot cake but it's very good!
Great sandwiches and soups
We ordered the Loaded Special half sandwich. Loaded describes this sandwich really well. There was so much meat on the sandwich, that I had to smash it down to be able to take a bite. The bread was fresh and delicious. Ended up taking about a third of it home.
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 8PM |
Amighetti's at the Top of the Hill offers a welcoming dining experience with a clean and bright atmosphere and a large dining area. Their lunch and dinner options, including sandwiches and salads, are consistently outstanding and reasonably priced. The restaurant is renowned for its best sandwiches in town, featuring onions in the meatballs and the “Top of the hill” sandwich, which receives high praise. Customers often enjoy the cheesecake, describing it as "unreal," and the boiled bagels and a variety of pasta are also popular choices. Many consider it a landmark and an institution that should not be missed. The staff provides superb service, and the menu offers many items to choose from. Whether dining in or ordering for a family function, visitors find the food delicious, the order process easy, and the food accurate and timely. Even those who don't usually like cannolis may enjoy theirs, and the restaurant carries Hanks cheesecakes, often selected for special occasions. Some customers have appreciated the option to take sandwiches to go, with all the veggies and sauce on the side to keep the bread from getting soggy. Others have had positive experiences with delivery, with the staff sometimes offering a free cheesecake slice as a kind gesture. Many are excited to try the place for themselves after hearing about the quality of the food. Visitors returning after years find the Amighetti 's Special sandwich still amazing, and even if some items like lasagna may not appeal to everyone, the overall experience remains excellent. Despite some missing the old location, Amighetti's continues to be a reliable choice for a satisfying meal, even on Sundays.