Andy's Frozen Custard

Dessert, Ice Cream, Pet Friendly

Hours today·

About Andy's Frozen Custard

Andy's Frozen Custard is a frozen custard shop in Crestwood. The store itself is simple, with a window to order from and a collection of benches and tables to eat at. There aren't a ton of sitting spots, so most people get their desserts to go. There is no inside area to hang out in, outside only if you do walk up or drive thru. The drive thru feature is a main reason why some prefer Andy's over Ted Drew's. The custard is consistently good, so tasty, and the customer service is super friendly. The service is always quick here, and the staff navigate the line well considering it's all made to order. The giant menu screen gives it a nostalgic custard shop vibe. The kids were THRILLED at the option that is "dirt" which means it has cookies and gummy worms. A strawberry shortcake was amazing. The James Brownie Funky Jackhammer is a perfect mix of custard, fudge, peanut butter sauce and crumble brownie pieces. A concrete with strawberry and cheesecake used fresh strawberries, but only a few, and the toppings were sparse. The drive through can take roughly 45 minutes with maybe 6 cars in line, and once you're in the drive through at this location you are STUCK in the line. The lemon bar concrete was exactly what was needed. A small with choc custard really was perfect, not too much.

Photos

Add a Photo
Andy's Frozen Custard
Andy's Frozen Custard
View All Photos

Andy's Frozen Custard Reviews

3.6
58 ratings
5
52%
4
9%
3
10%
2
10%
1
19%

Share your opinion about Andy's Frozen Custard

We love it here good Custard !
Way way better than DQ !
Any day
Been stopping at the Branson, MO location for years. During our visit to St. Louis we had to get our fix. Same great custard. I always get the James Brownie Funky Jackhammer. Perfect mix of custard, fudge, peanut butter sauce and crumble brownie pieces.
Fast, friendly service. Had an Ozark Turtle and it was delicious. Will definitely return to this location.

Read All Reviews(58)

Hours

Monday 11AM - 11PM
Tuesday 11AM - 11PM
Wednesday 11AM - 11PM
Thursday 11AM - 11PM
Friday 11AM - 11:30PM
Saturday 11AM - 11:30PM
Sunday 11AM - 11PM
Updated on: