6 Best Italian Restaurants in Shelby

“Toscanos Bistro in Shelby is one of those rare spots that makes you feel like you've stumbled onto something special. Their menu blends classic Greek and Italian dishes, and everything I've tried has been full of flavor and freshness.

The real standout for me, though, is their Chicken Ala Francesca. It is hands down my favorite dish. It's a creamy chicken and mushroom pasta that's rich without being heavy, perfectly seasoned, and cooked to perfection every time. The sauce is so flavorful that you'll want to savor every bite (and maybe even grab some bread to soak up what's left on the plate).

The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, whether you're dining in for a cozy night out or picking up takeout. The staff are friendly and attentive, and you can tell they care about the food and the experience.

If you love Greek flavors, creamy pastas, and locally owned restaurants that go the extra mile, Toscanos Bistro is absolutely worth a visit. Also - they do an amazing job catering!“

“We love the food at Verona. We have tried the lasagna spaghetti and the all seasoned grilled chicken dinners. Great ! Friendly staff and owner is very nice“

“Ordered Cheesesteaks because I miss Philly (Go Birds!) .. and was not disappointed.. they were delicious.. nice crusty flakey rolls, that you usually can’t find in this area .. fries were hot and yum .. but they offered us a few complimentary breadsticks in garlic butter - SO GOOD! .. EXCELLENT SERVICE!!“

“Enjoyed a Sunday lunch of baked spaghetti with meat sauce. Very attentive to customer, clean, I recommend and will be back.“

“Our waitress [ our receipt says cashier: Jackie} We paid at our table (10 in front dinning area...was AMAZING!!! Her mom was waiting on a large party in the back of the restaurant and she was assisting her mom as well as waiting tables in the front. Our ticket got lost in the kitchen.....our waitress quickly realized this and sincerely apologized. This mishap was clearly NOT her fault.....she handed the situation with professionalism and went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of. Her and her Mom are both assets to Italian Garden.. JOB WELL DONE LADIES...🥰“

“Pizza inn is GOOD! I haven’t had it in years I went for the first time in forever and I can’t stop going back! Just ate in yesterday and I’m going back today to get me a pizza and a salad. If they don’t have what you want they will always always always do whatever it is you request. You can get your own pizza box and fill it up with whatever from the bar or you can order and pick up either way it’s GOOD!“