33 Best Pizza Restaurants near Waterloo

“Rodger did an amazing job! He knew the menu and gave us great advice. I’m a picky guy when it comes to steak but I can tell you the 16 oz ribeye doesn’t disappoint. Cooked perfectly and seasoned to perfection! Will definitely recommend it to everyone. I’ll ask for Rodger every time we eat at the Salted Edge! Thank you for an amazing anniversary dinner.“

“Sooooo goood!!! Always delicious 😋“

“Decent food at a fair price but the vibe is a bit overstimulating and the chairs are not the most comfortable if you're planning on hanging out for a bit. There isn't table service for ordering and you have to gather your own cutlery which is fine if they remember to tell you or you're already familiar w/the place.“

“Highly recommended! Nice staff, excellent pizza, reasonable price. Loved the crust!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️!“

“We enjoyed the pizza and chop salad. Our daughter just had a liver transplant and they discounted our bill 50%. Very kind people.“

“Williamsburg Pizza is true authentic New York Style Pizza in Nebraska. There are many wonderful pizza establishments in the Omaha area, but for a slice of East Coast flavor I'd take this one. The crust, sauce and cheese are superb. These owners know pizza.“

“We love Oscar's! Great food and great staff. We especially love the Thai Bourbon char buff wings and their amazing lasagna, but everything else we've tried is equally good. We've never had a bad experience or a bad meal. One of our favorite places. Highly recommend!“

“The customer service and appreciation here is second to none! My family is newer to Nebraska and we called yesterday to ask if they do a family size pasta portion. We were transferred to Brian who said they don't typically but he had enough time to whip it up for us and was more than happy to do so. Our special made order of alfedo was amazing!! They are so kind and warm here- customers for life!“

“A newbie & loved this great pub with tasty food. A pizza place but much more. Taco Tuesday, perfectly crisped soft shell choice of 2, beef, chix or shrimp. We ordered the chips & salsa...the queso was the hidden gem. This place, very attentive and customer focused, food A+, prices very affordable, atmosphere was cozy & quaint. Can't wait to enjoy the large summer patio.“

“The best pizza joint! Delicious food and the owners are always so friendly when we come in. We’ve celebrated multiple occasions in their party room and love takeout, too. 10/10“

“On 8/29, we decided to try the Pizza Pie Guys. I ordered over the phone and went to pick it up. The woman who handed me our order was super nice & very friendly. Got home and we took our first bite together. My mom had the Mac & Beer Cheese Pizza, my husband had the Italian Danwich and I had the Pancetta White Pizza. No joke, we all moaned at our first bites. Best first impression EVER. Don't hesitate to give this place a try. Just one order and we're hooked!!! Thank you.“

“Great quality, friendly and dedicated owners and staff. They never disappoint!!“

“If you’re looking for a family friendly Sunday brunch spot in West Omaha this is it! There’s a wide variety of yummy menu items or you can pick from a variety of fresh and flavorful dishes on the brunch buffet. The omelet station is where it’s at! Their chorizo will not disappoint. Most importantly the experience from the moment you step in the door is unlike most restaurants. The staff treats you like family and goes above and beyond! They even have a magician/balloon artist that stops by to entertain. To top it all off having an arcade and movie theatre all in one. For those on a budget it’s very inexpensive for what you get and they have a Loyalty program to save on your next visit. My girls and I look forward to our Sunday funday coming to this magical gem after church!“

“Stopped by for the lunch buffet, food was decent, but staff were not too excited to be there. Cherry Pepsi was inop, I mentioned it and was told she would take care of it, but never did. Chit chatting with coworkers seemed to be the focus. Salad bar is pretty dinky.“

“I know Godfather’s pizza. Whether or not the Godfather himself knows it, not all Godfather’s locations are the same. Some are better than others. I THOUGHT I knew the best location. This location is making me reconsider. I judge based on 2 pies: straight-up cheese and the beloved taco pizza. The crust, the sauce, the cheese…exactly as they should be. My only gripe with the taco pizza is that I did not order a large, but that’s on me. Pricey? Yeah, but when it’s this good, it’s worth every penny. I give you the Schwarzenegger - I’ll be back.“

“We’ve been ordering from this location weekly for a while now. The same guys always make our order and are so friendly. We really appreciate the deals from the app and the quick pickup!

We get 2 medium pizzas for 6.99 each which feeds our family of 5 for less than $15. It’s not very cheap to eat out with 5 people even at fast food so we appreciate this yummy affordable option!“

“Ordered online tonight for the 1st time from Valley. I think they are having a soft opening because they only had pizza, apps, desert and calazones. No sandwiches. I haven't had Gambinos since high school in Kansas and I'm 51 now and I've never had their pizza. It was delicious and look forward to more especially their sandwiches.“

“Excellent selection of delicious beers. Great food. Great atmosphere.“

“This is a family favorite. The pizza is always good. It is almost always ready when they said it would be (or we wait less than 5 minutes). The site is easy to customize our favorites and add deals. The only thing that would be better is if they had taco pizza.“

“This was the 1st location I visited a couple weeks ago for the 1st time. I was referred to this spot from a client, bec I mentioned to them I was from Brooklyn. I was craving for a good slice or 2, and sadly when I got there I saw that slices are only sold betw 11A and 2P??? I ended up ordering a salad and garlic knots. Salad was ok. Garlic Knots delicious. Very disappointed you don’t offer slices any time of operating hours. It doesn’t matter that this is not in NYC, cause this isn’t how NYC does it. Be authentic and offer slices any time. Not sure how the pizza tastes at this location. I’ll consider going back. And it was much cleaner than the other location, and even had the authentic pizza parlor smell when I walked in. The other spot didn’t. Do better!“

“Very good food! Yum Will come back.“

“Me an my son love their pizza and the cookie dough is great as well.
Our favorite pizza is the Chicago stuffed.
An I always get an extra thing of cookie dough an freeze it for later it thaws out quick an cooks up just as good.“

“Super experience this weekend. We sat at the bar- great service.Delicious recommendation from the bartender and great ambiance. We had an excellent experience from the moment we were greeted until we left.. The menu was tempting to try everything but I settled for the short rib buritto breakfast, artichoke and bacon soup. next time I will try the stuffed popadews.“

“Our campground was without power and Casey's not only gave me a deal on breakfast pizza's but they got them done in a hurry!! Top notch customer service! Shout out to the two employees holding the whole place down after the storm!!“

“Just a FYI your wings are so much better than Oscars ???“

“Our food was hot and freshly cooked. The pizza was perfect. Definitely get the wings charred and double dipped.
Just a heads up the BBQ sauce is a bit spicy. I like heat, but you may want to ask if they have a mild version for the kiddos. 😊“

“Had an issue with DoorDash and the store. DoorDash picked up what the store provided. The store forgot to make our wings and DoorDash refunded us. Jake the manager called me personally, apologized, made the wings and personally delivered them to my house. That's hospitality!! Great work Jake.....I'd hire you tomorrow.“

“Brittany is an exceptional employee of Casey’s. We messed up our pizza order but she made things right with exceptional care and service. Thanks to her outstanding service this will be our go to place for all needs (gas, snacks, pizza). Thank you Brittany. Casey’s is lucky to have your talent.“

“I had an issue with my order at the Bennington, NE Papa John’s, but Angel, the manager, went above and beyond to make it right. She was professional, kind, and immediately arranged a refund and replacement.

As someone who manages IT for over 120 Arby’s locations, I really appreciate seeing that level of customer care and accountability. Angel turned a bad experience into a great one — she deserves recognition! 🍕👏“

“Called this Godfather's Express and told them I grew up in Omaha. Let them know that the Phoenix Franchises, where I have lived since 1987, should be shut down, as they do NOT make a REAL Godfather's Pizza like I remember. Asked them to build me a large Supreme, that would make Willie Thiessen PROUD! THEY DELIVERED! GREAT PIZZA.....perfect like the old days!!“

“I order take out from here every so often, and it’s always a quick wait time and they always have it ready. Great place to stop and eat. They have multiple high chairs, making it baby friendly. Also has all of the desserts that some godfathers don’t have.“

“We ordered 7 pizzas and 4 orders of garlic knots to be delivered for a birthday party at 6...doorbell rings at noon....pizza is here...oh no! I called and spoke with the manager...he apologized, said keep the food and we will redeliver at 6 for your party!! No argument, no hemming and hawing, just took care of the problem and saved the day!! This happened 1-2-2026..Day manager...I wish I knew your name...you are awesome!! Thankyou again!!“

“The BBQ chicken pizza was delicious! Service was fast and friendly. And the gelato for dessert was yummy!“