10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rochester

“Friendly staff, great food and great portion sizes. Perfect for a last minute lunch! Definitely my new favorite go to place.“

“Excellent service from Hollie F!“

“I've been coming to Village Pizza for far too many years that I'd like to admit, but it's been over 20 years now. That alone should tell you how good this place is! There are plenty of options around here, but none of them can quite nail my ham sub the way Village does every time. Hands down you guys are the best!!

There's only one thing that I find to be a little annoying but definitely not a deal-breaker. It's very frustrating calling at 8:32 p.m. and trying to order a rather simple sub for pickup only to be no we're closed. I get how kitchens work for closing, but, c'mon. It takes very little to make a ham sub. I know this is my issue, but your subs are that good and when I'm deprived of one my dark side comes out“

“To start, I order a dinner box from here. Never had issues before and loved this location. I got my order delivered and upon ope ing my food notice the order was incorrect. Ok, no big deal, decided to eat it anyways. Got in two pieces of pizza and then discover a thick long black hair under my cheese!! I called the store and asked for a manager. The guy I spoke to said he was a manager and I informed him what happened and that I would like a refund. He then asked for order number and phone number. He said he couldn't find my order. I said well this is the order number I was given and even gave all the other info for the order. He then said he would find someone that could help me so he obviously wasn't the manager like he stated. Be put the phone down for about 2 minutes then hung up. I tried calling back and they won't answer my calls at all now. $30 down the drain. I want to vomit.“

“I tried Goodfellas one nite because the usual place I ordered from was closed & boy was I surprised! Im Italian from the Bronx, & I think this is the best pizza around. The brick oven taste, together w the sauce was exceptional!“

“Absolutely amazing food and service. Steve and Sarah are amazing people i give the a 10 star rating. If you haven't tried the food it is a must!“

“I've been in the restaurant industry forever. This place is a hidden gem! Disguised as a taproom and grill, this is the best fine dining I've had in awhile (minus the dress codeand stuffy ambience). We tried everything. The shrimp and pork belly fried rice, the dragon dumplings, the chicken wings, everything was ridiculous...the pizza was unreal and we just had cheese! The fish was amazing. Everything is quality. I could not believe this menu or our food. You must go! The prices were so reasonable. Regretting not taking a single picture. I think I was so wowed by the the history of the chef and the whole experience, that I forgot I had a cell phone w a camera! I live 2 hours away and will be back!“

“outstanding pizza !!highly recommend“

“Great service! Always polite and cheerful! One of my favorite places to go.“

“Cant say bout atmosphere wasnt in long. But girl who answer phone was nice an helpful an patient with me. Inside other girl was same an was ready when arrive. But pizza an onion rings...oh. my. God.....like wow! You want great pizza an onion ring for good price this place to go. Telling you dont pass it up!!“