18 Best Ice Cream Shops near Barnegat

“We have been coming here for years and are never disappointed. The food is amazing, the service is great and the owner is wonderful. We will continue to enjoy our weekly visits and will always recommend to our friends and family.“

“They don't make their own ice cream, but what makes them special is what they do with it. Their sundaes are excellent. My favorite is the Drownie Brownie. When I ant unique or innovative ice cream flavors, I will go somewhere else. But when I want to have the best and most satisfying sundae, this is where I go. The quality is excellent and it' just a fun place to visit.“

“Highly recommend. some of the best ice cream I’ve had. Really friendly service overall great experience. We ordered the truck for my daughter’s signing for a softball scholarship. Thank you Mister Softee“

“Came here to play pinball since it’s one of only 3 spots on LBI with a machine. Game wasn’t reading cards upon arrival but an employee immediately popped me a few credits and reset the card reader once I brought it to their attention. Game had a few bugs and was very dirty but it worked well enough for the ¢50 they charge. I don’t play redemption games much but my brother seemed to enjoy them and he won a free ice cream in a claw machine so that was a nice surprise. I’ll likely visit again if I’m hankering for some pinball while on the island :)“

“My family LOVES Mrs Walker's ice cream cakes. Unfortunately , I recently ordered an ice cream cake from Rich's in Lacey and it was horrible. Will never order from anywhere else again.“

“Yummy ice cream, large selection of flavors and toppings. Generous portions, and of course every order comes with a cookie!“

“The best ice cream I ever had!!“

“To the gorgeous “17yr old” smoke show who looked more than just hot that served me yesterday late afternoon while the sun cooked is in that place. If you read this know I was being funny when I said what I said. Idk if u thought it was. All I know is I wanted to talk to you and say more but there was a lady behind me. Sure I’m older but getting to know people and making new friends in any age group is something I enjoy. If you’d like to meet up for lunch or coffee some time, def hit me up if you’re interested. Even if you have a bf or maybe seeing someone on and off. We’ll keep just to talking and listening. There was just something about you that seems quite unique. You can find me as JJ 6093898159, Signal as JJ and same number or JJJ005500 with same number. F*** it. I gave it a shot.“

“I ordered a custom icecream for a special occasion. Cake was made exactly to my request, everything from the different layers, icecream flavors, & toppings. Everyone enjoyed the cake and asked, where is the icecream cake from? If you have a peanut butter lover in your life, I highly recommend this peanut butter themed icecream cake. Aside from this custom order, we are regular customers. The icecream sundaes are our favorite. You always get good portions (scoops) served. The medium is almost too much for me. That's a good thing. Chocolate Chip Mint, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream, and topped with M & Ms is my favorite. This review is for the Lanoka Harbor, NJ location.“

“We just had my littles birthday party here and it was amazing. It was so easy to set up with Sandy and crew. They were helpful abd made it simple. Maddie was the one who helped up and she was fabulous. I would recommend over and over again! ❤️❤️ Thank you so much!“

“Went here yesterday for the first time to try the ice cream and it was great! There were a lot of people inside when we got there, but their system of taking a number as well as the multiple employees made the line move quickly. They offered 28 ice cream flavors to choose from. Their prices were extremely cheap for the amount of ice cream they give you! I ordered a small which was 2 scoops and it was huge. I got mint chocolate cookie and peanut butter Oreo. Both of the flavors were delicious!“

“very nice staff I would definitely go again“

“We were in walking distance of pelicans and went almost every night. We really enjoyed the wide variety of flavors. The order gentleman could be more personable, but the other staff was wonderful. We tended to look in the windows to prepare our selves for him. My children were always excited try a new flavor. We cannot wait to come back next year!“

“The best! Generous sized ice cream. Always busy, worth the wait. Can even get something for the dog.“

“We love your ice cream and adore your shop. It's so welcoming. Our only complaint is that after driving from Toms River to Bayville we found the shop closed. Have you closed for the season?“

“Ordered a cheesesteak, meatball parm, and Italian sub yesterday. Sandwich’s were delicious and outstanding. Definitely recommend this place.“

“So delicious! What a treat for our family when we come to LBI. Great service as well.“

“Super nice employees, out of all the pizza on LBI this takes the cake. This pizza tastes and is on par with NYC styles. I’m from Long Island and honestly just as good! They have Dr Pepper and also tons of nice sauces like Valentina and tajin which are the best toppings for pizza if you love spice like me. Give this man your business, I will be back every time I’m on LBI! Such a great vibe, true beach town feel place without sacrificing quality or being fake. Nice view outside of the restaurant of the bay. Unlike the other pizza places on LBI this place has slices! Every other place gave me a face if I ask if they did buffalo slices! Go check this place out tasty and classic slices!“