Bagels Restaurants near Colonia, NJ

“I love their bagels and sandwiches. I used to religiously go to Rahway Bagels until this place opened. Their bagels taste just as good without the long waits and doesn’t run out of the most popular choices. I’ve always had great service & good bagels from here. It’s my new go-to spot.“

“It’s so good We like it very much 👍🏻🌺👍🏻“

“We ordered breakfast for five online on Christmas Eve and everyone loved what they got!“

“great“

“This was my first time going to this establishment and I am glad I did. The staff was great. The heart felt kindness and professionalism was outstanding. The food was also amazing. It’s hard to find a gem of establishment like this. Definitely my new bagel spot. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Great food and friendly service!!!“

“Excellent bagels, great portions for reasonable prices. Ample seating inside with some groceries available for purchase. Friendly staff, too!“

“Fresh, happy workers, good coffee and fast service. What else can you ask for? OH and a community based business that helps the community“

“Took a dozen back with us on the plane to Florida. Best bagels I have had in at least 10 years!“

“Great service great food excellent customer service“

“Located on Millburn Avenue in Short Hills, New Jersey, Bagel Pantry offers breakfast sandwiches and approximately 15 types of bagels and a few other items. The plain bagel was fresh and the cream cheese very high quality. Take out is popular, while others take a break at the 8 or so small tables. The lighting is somewhat dreary, and the ceiling and walls perhaps worn, but the service was pleasant and the prices certainly reasonable.“

“We visited the place last Saturday. The cheese bread is fresh but not really the bagels we got. We waited so long ; we found out that my daughter’s order was given to someone else but they did not care to replace it at once. When we asked about our order, that’s the time they rushed to prepare it , in less than five minutes, the sandwich was handed to us. When we were in the car since we’re already late for our next appointment, my daughter found out that the replacement was wrong. She paid for plain bagel with double eggs, bacon, and cheese but she was given with plain bagel with cheese only. They asked for our phone number but did not initiate the call. I hope they will do better in their team work.“

“Everything is delicious.“

“This is our go to for fresh bagels anytime. On the weekend, you should get there early.
Is their bagel sandwiches and other food is very good quality.
The boss runs his business very well and services is top notch.
Highly recommended.“

“I moved from The Bronx to New Jersey four years ago I go to the gym across the street LA fitness .I came here one day and never looked back . They are truly amazing. !!!!!!Their customer service is outrageous. They greet you like your family, They are absolutely Amazing. The bagels are GREAT, Apple turnovers even better , their homemade oatmeal cookies nice and crunchy are perfect but most of all the avocado every time I ask for a sandwich it's ALWAYS ready to eat.“

“Perhaps the owner can reach out to me, this is now the 3rd time in the last several months I’ve placed an online pickup order and I’ve been shorted bagels. I keep coming back because I love your bagels, but you need to get it right.“

“Ok so being Google keeps asking me to review here I thought and nice Sunday morning coffee and bagel would be good. There is a big parking lot being it’s part of a shopping center. Walking in no confusion as to where to go to order. Everyone seemed very nice and helpful. I think it took me longer to make my coffee then it took to make and bag my bagel. Let me stop boring you with the BS stuff let’s talk bagel and coffee. I have been to a few bagel shops and I have to say Manhattan Bagel has the softest bagels. I did just get a buttered salt but wow the outside was mildly crunchy but like I said nice and soft in the middle. As far as coffee I tried their fall blend pumpkin spice and it tasted very deluded, not to much taste. They didn’t have French vanilla so I went with the pumpkin. Would I go back 100% the bagel was fantastic“

“Clean workers . And nice service“

“One of the best bagel places in town. Here for $10, I can actually get cream cheese and a good serving of lox on a bagel, and even add onion and tomato on it. Normally, I'd have to go to NYC or make it myself to get a good cream cheese and lox. Also, based on one of the other reviews, I tried the Fat Marlena. Great breakfast or brunch wrap if you want something filling and not greasy. If you want something lightly sweet to take home, their French Toast bagels are great toasted with butter. (we had them with some maple butter on hand from a farmers market, and it was a-maz-ing!) Not in the mood for a bagel today? They have tons of other great breakfast options all under $10!“

“I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a French toast bagel and it was the best sandwich I’ve ever had it brought back so many memories from when I was younger biting into that sandwich was astounding“

“Great breakfast sandwich options for less. Called ahead every time and without fail, my order was ready to go every time I walked in. We enjoyed the bacon, egg and cheese on a croissant as well as plain bagels with cream cheese. The coffee was also nothing to scoff at either. We definitely enjoyed our breakfast, so much so that we went back the next day. And for the price, you can't beat it. Definitely better than what you will get at the nearby hotels and for less.“

“The staff are always so friendly and the food is amazing. My only complaint is that you can’t order the baklava online which may be better for me to not order every single day- it’s their best dish!“

“I'm so grateful that the original owners are back. I take the train to NY weekly, and get my morning breakfast and sometimes my lunch. Coffee is fresh, many choices for bagels and the fillings. The sandwiches are amazing. More so by the newest worker AJ. His sandwiches are the best and almost looks too good to eat. I was not happy with the previous owner, but I'm glad once again. Thank you Marty, Diana and AJ.“

“First time getting a famous NJ/NY bagel and it didn’t disappoint. My friends and I were blown away by the freshness and thiccness of every bagel. The shop owner and worker were both accommodating to all of my questions even though we walked in close to closing time. Definitely coming back next time we’re in town!“

“This place is awesome. Take it from someone who grew up in Brooklyn around the corner from Bell Bialy and Hot bagels. Heartland 2 are just as good and made the same old authentic way. 👍“

“Surprisingly, the room is bigger. Friendly staff. And the location is smack in the middle of where we need to go. Breakfast was included, and the staff asked what room we were staying in and welcomed us to a nice selection. As said on their site, if you used their parking service, it'll cost you 60. The garage next door offers 31 overnight. We loved the place and expect to come back“

“⭐️ Hidden Gem Alert: Bagel 1 in Old Bridge, NJ ⭐️

It’s amazing how some of the smallest, most unassuming spots turn out to have the most delicious food and Bagel 1 is absolutely one of them.

From the outside, the place might not grab your attention, it may even seem like somewhere you wouldn't go, but don’t judge a book by it's cover! The food coming out of this kitchen is delicious, fresh, flavorful, and made with care. If you’re hunting for a legit bagel or breakfast sandwich, go here.

What really stood out during my visit was the service. Wael, the gentleman working the front counter, was exceptionally polite, attentive, and patient. His attention to detail and willingness to listen closely to my order, especially as someone who likes to customize their breakfast sandwiches, this was refreshing. In many bagel spots, staff can seem rushed or distracted, but Wael made the experience easy.

Whether you're a classic bacon-egg-and-cheese kind of person or someone who likes to get a little creative with your sandwich, Bagel 1 delivers quality without the chaos. The spot is low-key, but the flavor is next level.

Highly recommend swinging by if you’re in the area and want a breakfast that hits the spot. Old Bridge is lucky to have this place!“

“i went in today to check it out , i was rushing to work and tbh got it done in 5 minutes, first time checking this place out so amazing, everybody there is sweet and very friendly. i enjoyed my sandwich so much , it was so delicious 😋😋. i’ll be coming here again 100%“

“it's a cool treat for my colleagues“

“Mikey Bagels never disappoints! Bagels are fresh, chewy, and perfectly boiled — everything and sesame were both excellent. Cream cheese is generous and tasty. Service is lightning fast and super friendly, even at 7 AM. The place has that classic NYC bagel shop energy — love it. My go-to spot!“

“OMG, This was the best experience. Ordered breakfast for the office and clients. Food arrived hot and orders were correct and a few extras just in case.Just found our regular breakfast spot. Good portion size and great prices! We will definitely be using you again and again. Thank you, thank you, thank you.“

“Amazing! Young lady was so welcoming not sure if I got her name right! Amber? Very sweet and polite and food is amazing too!“

“They are open and ready to serve the community of Westfield.“

“The bagels are always fresh and coldcuts as well Nice clean bagel store . I wish they had more hours so I can go more often .“

“Bagel Cafe NJ just catered breakfast and lunch for my daughter's bridal party, wedding day preparations. Food was fresh and delicious, delivered on time, and they were super easy to work with. Highest recommendation 😍“

“I live in Austin, TX, and I love how I can have authentic New York bagels delivered to my front door. I am a new customer, and I love Just Bagels. I love their customer service, they answer their phone, and they answer my questions on Facebook. I will be using them again, and again. I love everything about them so far. My boyfriend is the bagel eater, and I ordered 2 dozen for him. The flavors we got were Everything, Sesame, Cinnamon Raisin, and Blueberry. He is in love with their blueberry bagels. Those are his favorite, but he loves them all. Thanks Just Babels for the wonderful bagels. We’ll be trying new flavors next time, but for sure blueberry again. :)“

“Best pocket friendly breakfast sandwich in town!! The coffee cake is like nothing you've ever had before! Moist and gooey and compliments perfectly with an iced coffee. Nice amount of seating, easy to find location and decent parking. Friendly staff and nice portion for your buck. ??“

“BEST SANDWICHES ! Delicious and fresh ingredients!“

“The day was always fresh and they gave you a lot of cream cheese on them. Nice people.“

“Good local spot. Tried the belly buster which was as advertised. Staff was courteous and friendly.“

“I don’t want to put bad review for you guys I come there for coffee and bagel all the time ,My family love this place you guys have good bagel but
I think you guys change Your bagel recipe it doesn’t taste right I had this morning sesame and chocolate bagel it taste like bread“

“The food is always delicious. Their bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich is my favorite. But, unfortunately, the service isn't so great. The girls in the kitchen are always very friendly, but the older woman at the cash register always seems to be in a bad mood and has a terrible attitude. I feel like I'm bothering her when I order my food or when I need to pay. She can't even manage to say hello or thank you.“

“Very welcoming and warm owner! It was my first time here, I was visiting my aunt in the area with my sister and randomly came across this bagel spot. We ordered a mini bagel with strawberry cream cheese… and guess what? Only $2!!! Honestly where can you even find that nowadays with inflation?
On top of that, he was incredibly kind and even gave us a huge bag of assorted bagels. Such a sweet gesture. Super nice experience overall🥰please please highly recommend this spot!“

“Wonderful owners and staff ! We all go here every day- it’s our “go to” store- a local family small business. Love this place.“

“Best bagel in the Summit area, my ONLY complaint is the music! Too loud and unnecessary. Let people relish their morning with quiet or at least less annoying music.“

“I Love FastBagel Always so Fresh and Delicious. Love getting Breakfast as well as Lunch The Staff Always sooo friendly. My total Favorite. Noelle“

“lox w/cc on a croissant and cup of coffee for years❤ best bagels and bialys!“

“love love love this place...my favorite bagel is the French toast ..so many other choices as well..great local place“