50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Eatontown

“food is always good , and Fresh and hot“

“The best vegan, gluten free ice cream and baked goods in NJ! It’s a safe space for a child or person with allergies to sit and eat a delicious treat. Every one will enjoy the ice cream!!! The owners are always friendly and welcoming.“

“I texted Mohammed (he is our neighborhood truck for many years) last minute to swing by the RBR tennis courts after practice to celebrate a bday. He was easy to work with and showed up on time. I highly recommend for anyone looking for a traditional ice cream truck experience.“

“The Apple Pie Ice Cream was the best ìce cream I have ever tasted.“

“We loved it. Perfect after a day at the beach 🏖 Try the Root beer…“

“We are never disappointed! Look forward to the seasonal flavor text messages.“

“We loved it. Perfect after a day at the beach 🏖 Try the Root beer…“

“Wow! Truly exceptional ice cream place. Do not bother with Coney ice cream chain. The flavor selection is dazzling, home-made and absolutely delicious.
Often ice cream can be underwhelming and very artificial tasting and I can’t even finish a serving. But at Callie’s we had nothing leftover.
We had mango coconut, biscoff cookie butter, coffee, peaches and cream, caramel Oreo and they were all great! The store is clean and cool. There’s also an outdoor area to run around a bit. Cannot recommend enough.“

“WATCH OUT !! This Ritas is addicting!! lol I love the Gelati thats my favorite...Vicky the owner is a very hard worker at keeping it clean and always serving with a huge smile..BRING THE ENTIRE FAMILY........Please check this location out ..“

“We loved our ice cream sandwiches! Everything was delicious, portions big and prices fair“

“Their homemade soft serve is amazing. I love the pumpkin and banana flavors!“

“5 ⭐️ Best ice cream.I loved strawberry and blackberry delicious 😋“

“CONE ZONE HAS BANGERS ONLY!

Cone Zones ice cream cakes are like Carvel on another level. When you cut into them, there are so many chocolate crunchies, they fall all over your plate like a piñata. Then that layer of yellow cake in between slaps every time.
They’ll create any type of decoration you want on an ice cream cake. You can email them any picture and they’ll print it out and put it on the ice cream cake for you. They even helped me celebrate twice when I almost got charged with third degree bicycle robbery, so they’ve been there for me for some key life moments.
On top of all that, if you’re too smacked to go pick up your ice cream, you can get it delivered! And don’t even get me started on their Peanut Butter Crunch ice cream flavor omg“

“we had a great time and recommend trying their ice cream“

“fresh fruits and great desserts“

“Overall, great ice cream. One of us had a brown sugar dough flavor that was great. The other had Peanut Butter Palooza (sp) mixed with plain chocolate. The plain chocolate was bland and not very chocolatey. Service at Tinton Falls was quick and friendly.“

“very clean attention to customers“

“Amazing tuna poke bowl! Will be back!“

“We are never disappointed! Look forward to the seasonal flavor text messages.“

“Overall, great ice cream. One of us had a brown sugar dough flavor that was great. The other had Peanut Butter Palooza (sp) mixed with plain chocolate. The plain chocolate was bland and not very chocolatey. Service at Tinton Falls was quick and friendly.“

“Their delicious Ice cream sundaes! 😋👍❤️“

“We are never disappointed! Look forward to the seasonal flavor text messages.“

“Highly recommend. Just finished a 3 day cleanse. first time ever doing a cleanse and it wasn't as hard as I thought it would be. Great product, very tasty.“

“Great ice cream and friendly atmosphere! 5 stars!“

“The Wayside students LOVED the Italian Ice from Bellalicious on Field Day! The staff was amazing, quick to respond and made the kids day extra special. Thanks so much!!“

“Good ice cream. Went on a sunny Saturday in June, and there were 2 people working the shop; definitely not enough. The wait was unbelievably long despite the line being not that long. We waited at least 20 minutes with only 6-8 people in front of us.“

“We loved it. Perfect after a day at the beach 🏖 Try the Root beer…“

“I take my sons there once a week. The staff are very thoughtful when it comes to my sons. My sons order their own choice and the staff is very attentive to what they order“

“Our server, Sharon, was amazing and attentive. It isn't a place I would usually consider because they don't have much in the way of vegan options (and the pretzels I got were definitely not, to be fair I also didn't ask), but my partner wanted a burger and he raves about it all night. Said that the meat was fresh and it was seasoned perfectly. He was exceptionally happy. I had a couple of his fries and they were really good as well. I'd definitely go back for the service alone and the lovely outdoor seating if I was with someone who wanted a burger. Cheers!“

“Excellent contribution to my backyard party!!!“

“Since I was looking forward to visiting pier village again this year this is one spot I was looking forward to trying. Here you can mix and match cookies or brownie. They also offer good selection of ice cream flavors and toppings. They also offer indoor snd outdoor seating. I decided to try the combination of s brownie with a Nutella chocolate chunk cookie & ice flavor of caramel pretzel fudge. It was delicious, with so many possible combinations you really can't go wrong. During summer its a very popular spot so lines tend to build up but they move quickly. Prices are reasonable so it won't break the bank. If you're in the area definitely worth stopping by.“

“Really loved Betty's Icebox! I tried the pineapple CBD popsicle and it was packed with flavor, while my son was just as happy with his regular pineapple pop. On top of the pops, they carry a great mix of ice cream flavors and a fun selection of candies. We’ll definitely be back for more!“

“Best homemade ice cream ever! I had the coffee flavor and was not disappointed 🤤“

“Delicious, quality desserts & great service.“

“amoooooo este lugar 😩❤️ tan lindo para visitar con familia y amigos 😊 (also a cute date idea🤭)“

“Love coming here for the chocolate flavor. 🍨🍫“

“I don’t know how I’ve lasted this many years without ever going to Coney waffle. I went tonight for the first time and I met the owner Lorraine and she is absolutely the sweetest human being on the planet! I got cookie dough, ice cream, and I am very critical of cookie dough ice creams at most establishments and this one was delicious! I look forward to returning and trying all the other fun, sweet treats that they have to offer“

“On 2/7 I ordered A large ice cream sheet cake from my mom‘s 94th birthday. Molly and her coworkers did not have the large, but they had two mediums. They are both absolutely beautiful. They went above and beyond with the decorating and I love how they even put happy birthday to her on the bag that they came in. Thank you, Jessica and crew for always being consistent and going above and beyond.“

“Nagles is back! I used to come here often but it's been 8 horrible years after they closed. But it's back and it's beautiful. The place looks just as I remembered it. If they did a lot of renovations, they did a very good job keeping the charm. You'd never know. The staff is amazingly friendly and the place is nice and clean. I ordered a grilled chicken with a side of chips (im staying away from fries) and a coffee. Coffee was superb. Nice dose of chicken with lettuce and tomato. Chips were a wee stale and the chicken was a wee tough. Its not cheap either. All in all, not bad. Its worth the trip here though if only to experience the place. The location is perfect. Just a short walk from the beach and right by all the cool stores.“

“This is such a great Carvel! I come here in person with my little ones and also order via DoorDash. Every experience has been great and the staff is so nice. I have to give a special shout out to Devi who ALWAYS takes the best care of us and gets the orders exactly right!!!!! Truly above and beyond!“

“Updating my review based on the owner’s response. While our first visit on a Sunday morning was disappointing due to being overlooked while staff focused on prep, the management response was prompt, direct, and genuinely accountable. They acknowledged the mistake, explained the situation, and took full responsibility without making excuses. It’s clear they take hospitality and feedback seriously and want to make things right. We’re willing to give them another try based on how professionally this was handled.“

“delicious 😋 worth it. between my sun and I we had 4 separate items and they were all excellent.“

“Best Carvel around!“

“My husband and I had an amazing experience with this store, working directly with Taylor, who went above and beyond the typical service you would expect in this day and age. We had ordered pralines from Savannah to be used for wedding favors, but we discovered the day before the wedding that we were short...by a lot! We discovered this franchise and Taylor was not just willing to help but had an incredible attitude and problem-solving mentality as we worked through it together. Ultimately, within a few hours, Taylor had a large order of mini-pralines made, nicely wrapped (with a ribbon color of our choice!), and packaged for our arranged courier to NYC. River Street Sweets and Taylor saved the day -- and everyone raved about the pralines!“

“Tonight I ran across the sweetest young lady with a heart full of compassion. My apple pay was failing me and I couldn’t pay for my child’s ice cream; then Cheinha (our server who helped us with such eagerness from start to finish) payed my balance. While I plan on going back and gifting this young lady; I wanted to shout her out for her act of kindness because in the world we live in that type of “love for your fellow man” isn’t seen to often anymore and it was definitely appreciated . Thank you SO MUCH again Ms. Cheinha! God Bless!“

“Been a while since I've seen a Tom Carvel ad (I suspect he's dipping cones in hot fudge in the heaven location now), and maybe 15+ years since I've enjoyed the custard at Carvel. Have done lotsa DQing. It's okay. And I think the dense, dense thick custard at Rita's may be a richer take on the confection. But Tom's custard was great on a hot late summer day.“

“Amazing Espresso Martinis, friendly service, yummy gelato, and best of all, they're dog-friendly!🐶🩵“

“So many flavors to choose from. Change it up with each visit“

“Great place, Amazing Ice Cream, Staff is super friendly! You can tell they know what they are doing!!! Can’t wait to go back again!!!“