32 Best Ice Cream Shops near Eatontown

Shake Shack Eatontown Mall Fast Food • $
180 NJ-35 S Space, Eatontown

Customers` Favorites

Shake Stack & Avocado Bacon Chicken
Korean Style Fried Chicken Sandwich
Smokeshack Burger with Cheese Fries
Bacon Cheese Fries and Burger
Shackburger w Bacon & Fries
Chocolate Shake
Mushroom Burger
Chicken Shack
Regular Fries
Chick'n Shack

“This spot is THE SPOT for great burgers, fries, shakes, dogs, and chicken!! Suuuuch good customer service and INCREDIBLE FOOD!! I’m always satisfied! Clean, organized, good prices. Shake Shack is OUR In&Out burger ♥️♥️♥️♥️“

3.8 Good81 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
76C NJ-35, Eatontown

“Rita's is always good, the quality of their product is inline with what you'd expect. Being a chain there's not much difference between different locations. This location specifically has very friendly staff though and the place was clean.“

3.5 Good11 Reviews
Fable Creamery Vegan Ice Cream & Confections Ice Cream Shop •
14 Monmouth St, Red Bank - 3.79 miles

“The best vegan ice cream in New Jersey! This creamery is truly one-of-a-kind with their vegan and gluten-free creations. In addition to their ice cream, their cookies and olive oil brownie are must-try items. I love how they have seasonal and holiday specials as well. So lucky to have such a great local spot that fits my dietary needs!“

5 Superb69 Reviews
Nicholas Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
84 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands - 8.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Sauce
Cheesecake Peanut Butter
Brown Sugar Cookie Dough
Death by Chocolate
Oreo

“Was in the Atlantic highlands area and decided to stop for some ice cream.... so happy we did. The ice cream was to die for. Nicholas's creamy had so many options and you could definitely tell that the quality of the ice cream was top notch. The service was excellent and the location couldn't have been better. They even had some seating available, cute little ice cream shop. Thanks for making this night one to remember.“

4.7 Superb58 Reviews
Mrbrainfreez Ice Cream Shop •
755 River Rd, Fair Haven - 4.78 miles

“Mr. Brain Freeze is the best. You can text him to come and he’ll let you know when he’s near so you don’t have to hope for the ice cream truck. We’ve also used him for parties and PTO school events. He is always on time for events and very kind. His prices are fair and his selection is amazing.“

5 Superb34 Reviews
Cookman Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
711 Cookman Ave, Asbury Park - 5.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salted Chocolate
Vegan Flavors
Whipped Cream
PB Crunch
Nutella

“By far my favorite creamery! They have a great selection of both traditional dairy a and vegan choices. The vegan ice cream is so creamy and full of flavor- many uniquely delicious. Today I tried a beet, maple and rosemary flavor that surprised me and one called the lake, with royal spirulina andbgolden sea moss- had a fresh clean upfront flavor that ended with cake batter- yummm. The coffee hazelnut was my favorite though. I always grab a pint to go also.“

4.7 Superb85 Reviews
Amici Gelato & Caffé Cafe • $
630 Mattison Ave, Asbury Park - 5.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Italian Cookies
Sorbet and Gelato

“My husband and I drove up from Toms River for the Cannoli kit after experiencing it at a party . It was a Sunday and the girl behind the counter was very rude and said we don’t have any they need to be ordered a head of time , thankfully RALPH walked in and saved the day he went above and beyond to get us what we came for ! If you don’t know the lay of the store you shouldn’t be working there ! Customer service should be a priority and she certainly wasn’t willing to try helping . I will be back but hopefully someone who wants to help the customer is working!“

4.8 Superb34 Reviews
Strollo's Lighthouse Ice Cream Shop • $
250 Ocean Ave N, Long Branch - 3.96 miles

“I'm not the biggest fan of strollo's because they don't serve hard ice-cream. But they have alot of great toppings for your soft ice-cream. I never tried their Italian ice, so I can't comment on that. The place is always packed though.“

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Sweet N Joe Ice Cream Shop •
1405 Wickapecko Dr, Ocean - 4.61 miles

“Had to write a review of this place, it was so good! I got mint chip, and my dad got s'mores. The s'mores was so good I nearly bought my own! And the mint chip is one of the best I've ever gotten. Absolutely recommend going here, I'll be going back for sure! I'd give it 10 stars if I could.“

4.9 Superb19 Reviews
Belle's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
300 Morris Ave, Spring Lake - 9.98 miles

“Simply delicious. There's not much more you can ask for then a ton of different ice cream flavors, especially when one tastes better than the other. Their friendly staff were great at pointing out selections that were not even on the menu. In a word, delicious.“

4.7 Superb32 Reviews
Bellalicious Ice Cream Shop • $
65 Monmouth Rd, Oakhurst - 2.59 miles
4.9 Superb15 Reviews
Hoffman's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
569 Church St, Spring Lake - 9.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip

“This is one of the great ice cream places in America. They always have fresh and great-tasting ice cream. The staff is always friendly and effective. The place is always clean. They are good with kids and senior citizens. In short, I've been a customer for about 35 years and have never had a problem. You can't reasonably ask for more.“

4.3 Superb72 Reviews
Strollo's Lighthouse (Red Bank) Ice Cream Shop • $
64 Bridge Ave, Red Bank - 4.15 miles

“I have been a Lighthouse Italian Ice fan for my entire life. I believe this Lighthouse location makes the most delicious ice and ice cream. Kevin uses fresh fruit when in season to make some of his ices and ice creams. I think it's the best Lighthouse there is!“

4.7 Superb25 Reviews
Crumbl - Ocean Dessert • $
2303 NJ-66, Ocean - 4.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Lucky Charms Cookie
Assorted Cookies
Apple Pie

“My sil brought the party box over and omg the oatmeal mallow sandwich was amazing!!! The crumbl by me was not a great experience because the cookies were dry and a bit sweet, this location and getting 12 cookies proved me wrong that even though it is a chain, certain stores execute better than other. Would reco this and the oatmeal cookie, it's soft and chewy and so yummy“

4.5 Superb77 Reviews
The Chocolate Bar of Little Silver Ice Cream •
78 Oceanport Ave, Little Silver - 2.06 miles

“I don’t believe this place is amazing ? better than any similar place for me.She’s a great person and ice cream is so delicious, creamy, tasty and the chocolates made like different earth! ?Thank you so much your service and please keep open forever. ?Perfect clean and decorating ?? gorgeous“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Hinlickity’s Ice Cream Parlor Cash Only Ice Cream Shop • $
120 Bay Ave, Highlands - 8.01 miles

“A combination of chic and retro. The decor and the ambience alone make you feel good. The creative and wide selection of ice cream possibilities make for a superb outing with friends or a soothing retreat if you're on your own like me. Today I'm having cookies and cream in seltzer, as I battle the humidity and delude myself about cutting calories. Bottom line: refreshing and fun!“

4.6 Superb32 Reviews
JJ Delicacies Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
21 W Front St, Red Bank - 3.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sushi Burrito
Banana Swirl
Rice Bowl
Mochi

“So everytime I go here I say suprise me and like it always smacks I don't even know what i have most of the but i could say when they do suprise me it hits different! Good vibes for like a date :3 I come here everytime I know it's a good day!“

4.6 Superb30 Reviews
Nicholas Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
1201 Sycamore Ave, Tinton Falls - 2.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tahitian Vanilla
Coffee Crunch

“Went here for the first time this weekend and it was well worth the trip ! I got the nachos ice cream box with Whoopie pie strawberries and cream and cookies n cream all flavors were amazing the hot fudge was so good ! Definitely will be coming back“

4.5 Superb54 Reviews
Nicholas Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
1500 NJ-35 unit 19, Middletown - 8.48 miles

“With several locations along the Jersey Shore, this Middletown location is the newest. Huge, bright, airy, and busy but no seating on the inside which is kinda sad because I wanted to enjoy my ice cream while looking at what other flavors I should get next. Your only option is either the two benches outside or your car. The servers looked tired but the young man who helped me was nice enough. I picked the Vegan Speculoos Cookie which was AMAZING! The texture was different but the flavor was all there! $5 and some change for a small. I scream, you cream...“

4.5 Superb45 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
673 Newman Springs Rd, Lincroft - 4.33 miles

“Best dairy queen ever! the blizzard that I had delivered was what i asked for. it Is to die for, they do not use syrup in their ice cream which makes it 100% original and the staff would stop what they are doing on the spot for the customers 10/10“

5 Superb9 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
865 NJ-36, Union Beach - 11.57 miles

“My second time here and despite not having coconut ice on the menu I was super impressed by the service again! I don't remember the name of the young man who helped me the first time but Michaela was an absolute gem, super polite had great energy and attitude even late in the day!“

4.7 Superb17 Reviews

22
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
1362 NJ-36, Hazlet - 11.64 miles

“Carvel of Hazlet went above and beyond with very short notice (less then 2 hours) to create a beautifully decorated birthday cake for my son. I sent a simple photo of what I hoped for and they did not disappoint. I highly recommend them for your next celebration.“

4.7 Superb16 Reviews
Fruta Loca Ice Cream Shop • $
547 Broadway, Long Branch - 2.66 miles

“The food is absolutely incredible! The King Crepe may be one of the best it jersey. Would totally recommend. Staff were friendly, service was quick. It's quite small inside but has a fantastic aroma from the kitchen in the back. I would come here every day if I could. Would totally recommend!“

4.7 Superb16 Reviews
Strollo’s Lighthouse Ice Cream Shop • $
69 Brighton Ave, Long Branch - 3.56 miles

“When I tell you that this is some of the best soft serve ice cream that I've ever tasted.. I'm just really glad that this place is about 35 mins from me, so that I'm not pressed to visit a couple of times a week. LOL. Came here after a day at the beautiful Seven Presidents Beach.. and it was the perfect way to cool off before ending our day. Very friendly and accommodating service. They were generous and understanding with our very indecisive girls who needed refills of sprinkles lol. Very clean areas to sit down and eat your delicious treats. I ordered the pistachio Italian ice which was very interesting.. non dairy but was tasty. But, it was the sample of the vanilla soft serve that took me over the top... but, I'd already placed my order and didn't want to be a greedy buzzard. Believe me, when I'm back at the shore.. I will beeline to get a full serving of it.“

4.6 Superb22 Reviews
Chocolate Works Red Bank Ice Cream • $
36 Broad St, Red Bank - 3.86 miles

“This is one of my favorite chocolatiers. Every time that I'm in Red Bank, I stock up on my raspberry truffles! The young staff members are ALWAYS courteous, beyond helpful, and patient. The shop has every item imaginable. From gift boxes, many types of sweets, and... of course... my world famous dark chocolate raspberry truffles. Go out of your way to stop into Chocolate Works. You'll enjoy everything inside and will be treated very well.“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $$
607 Newman Springs Rd, Lincroft - 4.29 miles

“I grew up with Ralph's Italian Ices on Staten Island back in the day. It has been 20yrs since I've last had the sweet delicious frozen treat that is Ralph's. I've been wanting to go back and get it for the longest time but haven't had the opportunity nor time or desire to make the trek back to SI. On a recent visit to my family living in the NJ area I saw that Ralph's has expanded. Went on a whim to try it to see if it is as good as I remembered. Spoiler: It is! I was so happy to see that it was still made and tasted the same. You will not find Italian ice like this anywhere but Ralph's.“

4.7 Superb15 Reviews
Frozen Explosion Ice Cream Shop •
379 Monmouth Rd Ste D, West Long Branch - 1.92 miles

“These Frozen delicases are clearly a quality product. They are refreshing, and full of flavor. There are many varieties to choose from; one is sure to hit the spot no matter what mood you're in. Treat yourself once; and you'll be back for more!“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Polar Bear Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
130 NJ-36, North Middletown - 10.27 miles

“Thank goodness I don't live very close to this ice cream parlor because I would be there every day. Six of us took a tour and decided to try the ice cream when we were done four of them had the black raspberry ice cream with black with chocolate chunks and I fudge over the top, it was delicious. I've tried the lemon bar with caramel. It was so good I've gone back twice. The owner and staff are extremely friendly. They explain everything and everything was wonderful.“

4.5 Superb29 Reviews
Cone Zone Ice Cream Shop • $
2040 NJ-33, Neptune City - 6.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice Cream Dog Treats
Ice Cream Cone
Strawberry

“So we moved to the area and i always passed by this place on the way home thinking “what a weird place for an ice cream place” and just sort of assumed it was no good. Boy was I wrong! Now, no other place compares. Coffee ice cream is my favorite - cream and delicious. And the prices are reasonable. My trick - get a pint to go. That way you get double the deliciousness“

4.4 Superb49 Reviews
Nicholas Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
444 Ocean Blvd N, Long Branch - 3.98 miles

“Love the various creations... PB&J, peach cobbler, watermelon chocolate chunk, apple cider...the list goes on. Every few weeks the flavors change. Homemade waffle bowls & cones. Really thick shakes. They have a few locations. I suggest visiting.“

4.4 Superb42 Reviews
Betty's Icebox Dessert • $
Boardwalk, Asbury Park - 5.71 miles

“Awesome little ice cream and shaved ice place in convention hall. Note- it's shaved ice- not Italian ice style. Both the small and large shaved ice are huge which is cool. Price is a bit high at $8 since it literally costs them next to nothing for ice and some juice mix but everything is out of control pricing nowadays. You can choose up to 3 flavors or just do one. Good selection of flavors. Ice cream is vegan and dairy free which is cool for those who can't do dairy or are vegan. Note if you want regular ice cream there's 2 places on the boardwalk that has that. Staff was friendly. Small tables to eat your ice cream at. Great way to cool off on a hot summer day.“

4.5 Superb20 Reviews

32
Crazees

Crazees Ice Cream Shop • $
2 W River Rd, Rumson - 5.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Midnight Jersey Shore Butter Pecan
Chocolate Thunder
Blueberry Pie
Banana Split

“Crazees is our favorite local ice cream place! In the summer its the best stop for a cool treat after the beach or after dinner. The amazing flavors of Thomas Sweet Ice Cream are delicious!Parking: Parking can get crowded during busy summer nights, but otherwise is usually never an issue.“

4.4 Superb35 Reviews
Loading...
map Map