50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Highlands

“We ate at Franny’s yesterday after attending a scouting merit badge class nearby. Everything was amazing. We communicated ahead of time to ensure they could accommodate our party of 16 and were able to place our order ahead of time too. Everything was seamless as we walked in with a table ready and the pizza immediately arrived fresh from the oven. The pizza was a perfect crispy thin crust and thoroughly enjoyed by everyone. The staff was friendly and attentive. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“We ate here today. It was our first time. We loved the food and the atmosphere. It has an interesting history. Definitely worth the drive.“

“Great food! Lunch portion had me stuffed! I'll be back again!“

“Loved it! Best subs around. I'll be back for sure! Can't wait to try the pizza.“

“🔥🔥🔥🔥 Great vibes, staff was on point!
- Food: 🍴 Amazing flavors, really good stuff!
- Atmosphere: ✨ Top-notch, made our experience 🤩

Overall: 😍 Would def recommend and come back! Bring friends! 👫“

“Awesome Food, very friendly people“

“Definitely a hidden gem. The ingredients are so fresh and high quality. Everything on the menu is good!“

“Amazing food will go back“

“Great food. Nice people. The best!“

“That’s is amazing pizza,very delicious! Thank you guys!!!“

“Had a Stromboli that was great ! Great service & the staff was great ! Looking forward to going to there new place in eatontown next to earth treasures !“

“The food in Sal's is absolutely delicious! I think the secrets in the sauce...or something lol bcz I've never tasted sauce like his!!! All the food is delicious there and I won't eat Italian food anywhere else! Sal your food is the 💣(bomb) 😂“

“Got a pepperoni slice and a coke for $6. Slice was pretty big, alot of cheese and a lot of pepperoni which made it too heavy for the crust so I had to fold it. Very greasy but that's from all the pepperoni so id rather it be greasy with a lot of meat then not as much. Definitely will go back“

“Our favorite…The Sauce! The most delish pizza. My daughter absolutely loves (and she is a picky eater with everything). There is no pie that they can’t make for you. And for me being gluten free, they always take care of me and my tummy! Prices are great, ingredients are fabulous. Most importantly…they give back to the community and take care of everyone. They are family to us all!“

“Delicious Authentic Pizza, Reminds me of NYC pizza in the 80’s. I will drive an hour again to have another slice of Heaven !“

“Best pizza and service!!! Amazing wings, salad, everything!!!“

“I got the steak hero, was quite good, my wife got the salad with grilled chicken..another visit I tried the pizza too,, was excellent everything is fresh and big portions.“

“That’s is amazing pizza,very delicious! Thank you guys!!!“

“Incredibly delicious pizza. I’ve tried many around here over the years. Your pizza is by far the best. Crispy pepperoni, flavorful cheese and sauce. 10/10! That chicken parm pizza 🤤 wow. The appetizers weren’t always great but the pizza is sooooooooo good.“

“Definitely the best cheesesteak I've had, since moving to the area from Philly. The only thing I would change is putting the meat and cheese against the roll instead of rhe tomato and lettuce against the roll and then the meat and cheese on too as it tends to fall out instead of fitting snuggly. But it was delicious! All the ingredients were fresh and yummy! Will definitely order from Peel again!“

“I grew up in Brooklyn so very few pizza shops in NJ can compare. Except this pizza shop! If you love a good pizza you must try their Grandma or Rustica. My wife is crazy about their gluten free white pie with broccoli and mushrooms. All their pies are made well done. Crispy crust and delicious toppings. I work nearby and my coworkers rave when we order lunch here. Special: 2 slices and a drink for $6!! You gotta try Luigi’s Square!!“

“This is the best pizza in town ! Fast friendly service !“

“We spent the day at Capelli Sports complex for a lacrosse showcase. At the end of the event we had a long drive ahead. We ordered 3 pizzas to take with us on our drive. Everyone was so accommodating and made sure our delicious pizza was ready as soon as we we heading out! Thankful for the wonderful folks that work there and the great pizza!“

“Great food! Friendly and quick service!“

“first week Enzo opened I ordered a cali cheese steak. it was so full of meat the lady gave me a fork. after that when the owner made the subs he barely put meat .“

“Overall amazing“

“Went over to see the new and improved slices in the new location, brand new , clean, and the food is always delicious. Saw the owner wished him good luck on the new location. Shook my hand and said thank you back. Let’s not forget his years of service to raising the bar for the Jersey shore area. The manger Ron , the pizza chef Israel have always done whatever I ask for. Totally accommodating my family for 25 plus years. Always with a smile! No reason to look elsewhere ever again!! Thanks again and good luck 🍀!!!“

“My husband and I ate here last night. Great food and service.“

“Amazing amazing amazing amazing food! I am doing a happy dance“

“UPDATE! As of May almost June 2026-

THIS IS STILL MY FAVORITE PIZZA SPOT!💪🏽 THEIR PIZZA SAUCE IS JUST UNMATCHED! 😍THE CHEESE IS MY FAVORITE EVEN THOUGH THE PEPPERONI IS BOMB TOO! PLUS THEIR OTHER DISHES ARE AMAZING TOO! NO NEED TO LOOK AROUND, ORDER ASAP!!!

Wish I can give more stars but I can’t. There food is the BOMB! Always fresh & delicious! They tell you 35-40 mins BUT they always come to our house within 20 mins. Love this place!!!! Our favorite pizza place from Michele & Victoria!“

“Been coming to the brothers for their amazing pizza for close to 30 years now. Hands down THE BEST Sicilian style pie in the area. IMO it can compete with famous big dogs like L&B. Vinnie and Ralph are local legends. You cannot go wrong with this Oakhurst crew.“

“Stopped at Val's Tavern because we had a 2 hour gap between a wedding and reception. Service was excellent and so was the food. Our server, Gabby, went above and beyond when we needed some Tylenol. HIGHLY recommend Val's!“

“Amazing amazing amazing amazing food! I am doing a happy dance“

“Best food and pizza in moms County hands-down. The service is at 10. The pizza is incredible.“

“Clean friendly and fun! Great for the family“

“Mangia was amazing!! I called at 11am this Sunday morning and they were able to accommodate 6 large pizzas to our house by 12:30!! The gaggle of cheerleaders were so very happy to have pizza after their game!! Thank you Mangia! 10 out of 10!!“

“Rosies has turned a 1 star review into a 5 star review!

I can not believe how they did a full 180 and are now offering the best pizza in Middletown. The crust is like sourdough. Ingredients are fresh. Curled pepperoni.

The meatballs are amazing standalone and on a pie.

Staff greet you when you walk in. This has turned into a staple in our household“

“Just got my favorite, pizza, and it is the BEST!!“

“You've got to have Anthony cater your next event! Delicious!���“

“YESSSS! Ordered from this new location tonight and it was excellent. Toppings were generous and well cooked. Crust was really garlicky and totally bomb. Best crust I've ever had from Domino's. So glad to have you in the neighborhood! Bravo Robert! ????“

“Old world Delicious Pizza. Home made Dough not processed. Highly recommended. Sooo good !“

“The food here is beyond delicious, every bite is packed with flavor and made with obvious care! But what really sets this place apart is the warm, welcoming family vibes the moment you walk in. Alice, Susie, Awilda, and the rest of the incredible crew treat you like one of their own, with genuine smiles and top-notch service that makes every visit feel special. This has quickly become my absolute top spot to dine in the area—highly recommend to anyone looking for amazing Italian eats in a cozy, family-like setting. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Absolutely LOVE this place! Been going since I was a student at brookdale and now that I live in Lincroft I order here at least once a week. The entire staff is so nice. If you like good pizza and a family atmosphere, this is a great spot for you!“

“Ordered 2 large trays of Chicken Parmigiana and Chicken Francese last week for my husband’s birthday party. Both trays were plentiful and delicious. Leftovers were frozen in individual packs that we enjoyed all week. Delivery was free Par excellence for Naples in Belford“

“Great menu selection, delicious and fresh pizza, they use the best of ingredients on everything - staff is always friendly, best pizza spot out there“

“I love this pizza!! it reminds me of pizza I would get from a shop called Pizza Coloré that was on Rt. 1 South quite a few years ago. is there any relation?? would love to know! regardless this pizza is the kind I crave because the sauce and the cheese is so delicious! the crust is unbeatable as well thank you so much! you are my new favorite pizza place!“

“Lezama's Special Pizza and Lisa's Salad were excellent and my parents were exceedingly pleased with their Take Out choices. Well done“

“Great food had the veal a la casa excellent“

“So, we’re from boston and are visiting my son. Not too much to choose from around here in terms of restaurants. But suddenly I see a sign Minas Grill and went in just because of the word grill. It’s Brazilian! My heart is singing! Great coffee, the food is like home cooked. Loved the cheese bread and you can shop here too! Lovely warm people and so helpful! So we’ll be back while we’re here.“

“Fratelli’s fan since they were next to the A&P. 🍕 Thank you!!“