5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Atlantic Highlands

Julio's Pizza Co. Pizza • $
75 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Pepper and Onion Sicilian Pizza
Sausage and Onion Sicilian Pizza
Joe Joe’S Pickle Pie
Classic White Pizza
New York Style Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pie
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Off-White Pie

“I would love to give him 4 stars cause you absolutely can't find a better cooked pizza anywhere in the area so the reasons I won't do 5 stars is simple, his pizza sauce needed salt and I get that he may be worried about the salt from the cheese... then the Sicilian was bitter so it was acidic and then personally too much cheese for me but omg the cooked pizza since I left Brooklyn and my hats off to this establishment!!! Best of luck and lots of success to him and his staff!!“

4.7 Superb43 Reviews
Chiafullo's Italian • $
1010 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Cannoli

“I usually pick up my orders due to the condition of my pizza when I order delivery but I ordered in tonight. I was pleasantly surprised to find my pizza not sloshed to one side, the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect! I don't usually write reviews but I had to let it be known that Chiafullos is on the up and up! I will definitely be ordering again!“

4.6 Superb41 Reviews
Amici Pizzeria Pizza • $
2387 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Pizza
Chicken Parm
Margherita
Italian
Sausage
Grandma
Garden
Wings

“Ordered takeout over the phone on a Sunday afternoon around 4:45pm. Quick and easy. When I picked up, order was all correct.(Large margherita pie. Large buffalo wings with Bleu cheese. Penne vodka with chicken)Easy drive to get here (right off route 36)Plenty of parking spots. They are a part of a small strip mall that includes a sushi spot, gym, dollar store, nail salon etc so parking is never an issue.Wings were the crispy and just the right amount of sauce. Pizza was perfect, melty cheese with the thin crust that was in between soft and firm.Pasta was huge.. it was packed full with chicken. Needed a little salt though.Hands down the best pizza for the price around the area.They also have a loyalty program. Just add your phone number and after you spend $100, you'll get 10% off your next order.“

4.3 Superb54 Reviews
Pomodoro Rosso Italian Grill & Pizzeria Italian • $$
5 Bayshore Plaza, Atlantic Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Napolitana Cheese Pizza
Broccoli Rabe Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Rigatoni Romano
Fried Calamari
Eggplant Parm
Sausage Pizza

“A family-owned restaurant. The owners are from Italy. So if you're thinking of going to Italy, save your money and go here instead. The scenery may be better over in Italy but the food here is the same. Everything on the menu is awesome..“

4 Good45 Reviews

5
STRADA

STRADA Italian • $$$
91 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Ricotta Crema Toast
Caesar Salad
Pepperoni
Cannoli
Peppers
Figs

“Really great food and atmosphere at this spot. Feels like a family, where the owner knows a ton of the customers and focuses on service and ambiance.Drinks were great. Bread with the ricotta was awesome and was cooked with some garlic and rosemary.Even sleeper pick items were good, like the trout dip.The Caesar salad was celery based, so maximum crunch. I thought it was interesting.The pizzas were excellent, wood fired. We also got a spinach ricotta, but felt a bit dry.On the service side, seemed they were backed up for a bit, but overall we didn't have any issues.Eggplant parm was really dense and multi layered. We enjoyed.Dessert was excellent.“

3.8 Good65 Reviews
Loading...
map Map