15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

Toscanella Village Cafe Pizza • $$
102 Kings Hwy, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

WH Specias Cheese Steak
Penne Bolognese
Chicken Marsala
Sicilian Pizza
Eggplant Parm
Penne Vodka
Greek Salad

“This place is really one of the best around. I’ve had a few different dinners here and everything has been delicious. The service is always excellent; they’re consistently one of the best. If you haven’t been, it’s worth checking out. We’ve become regulars.“

4.6 Superb60 Reviews
Zoni's Brooklyn Brick Coal Oven Pizzeria Pizza • $
287 NJ-35, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza
Coal Fired Wings
Pizza Margarita
Fried Calamari
Chicken Wings
Americana
Meatball
Personal
Sausage
Stefano

“This was our second time at Zoni’s and everything was delicious. We had the coal fired wings which come with a delicious homemade Gorgonzola cheese sauce and the Camilla pizza. The first time we had the Stefano pizza. The staff is so kind, the owner personally came to our table and insisted we try the Margherita pie, he gave us one on the house. Thank you guys! We know we will be coming back soon!“

4.6 Superb55 Reviews
Lubranos 36 Italian • $$
26 NJ-36, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry Field Green Salad
Eggplant Parmigiana
Shrimp Franchese
Margherita Pizza
Veal Saltimbocca
Fried Calamari

“This was our first time there. The place is nice and so was the staff. Our waitress was very good. They give you hot bread when you sit down. I had spaghetti and meatballs. It was good and I loved the meatballs. You get 2 good size ones. My boyfriend had the linguine with white clam sauce. He enjoyed it! We will definitely be going back there again!! Thanks!! Cathy“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese Pizza • $$
1107 NJ-35, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

A Topping to Your Large Pizza for
Large Cheese Pizza
French Fries

“It was Great!!! Cast Members are Nice to me. I gave my drawing that i drew for them and they loved it! It was about the location when they first opened with the Stage! Pizzas smells Great! And the 1 Stage was in better shape since my last visit. I'm hopeing I will return to this location soon again!“

4.3 Superb52 Reviews
Domino’s Pizza Pizza Delivery •
1670 NJ-35, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Pizza

“YESSSS! Ordered from this new location tonight and it was excellent. Toppings were generous and well cooked. Crust was really garlicky and totally bomb. Best crust I've ever had from Domino's. So glad to have you in the neighborhood! Bravo Robert! ????“

4.2 Good26 Reviews
Joyce's Subs & Pizza Pizza • $
655 Newman Springs Rd, Lincroft

Customers` Favorites

Ham Salami Capicolla & Provolone Cheese Sub
Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese

“Joyce's has been around in the same location for at least 55 years. They make the best sub sandwichs in the area. They are consistently a good value and a great sub sandwich. The standard foot long Italian sandwich with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, peppers, Italian deli meat with oil and vinegar is the model of what an Italian sub should be. Lincroft, NJ was my childhood hometown. Whenever I return, stoping off at Joyce's for an Italian sub sandwich is a must for me. It's a consistently a good sandwich.“

4.2 Good18 Reviews
MJ's Restaurant Bar & Grill American • $
1005 NJ-35, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Steamed Clams and Caesar Salad
Tortilla Chips and Salsa
Cheeseburger and Fries
French Onion Soup
Open Faced Turkey
Mashed Potatoes
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Sandwich
Fried Calamari
MJ’S Nachos

“The food here is great, I usually get the eggplant pizza and it's truly amazing, good sauce with nice fresh fries eggplant and mozzarella cheese and ricotta. Doesn't matter we dine I or take out the quality is always great and consistent. The staff is very and helpful with suggestions. It had a nice warm atmosphere that is very welcoming. Definitely one of my go to spots that never let's me down.Parking: Large lot with plenty of space .Kid-friendliness: Definitely a family style atmosphere even with a separate bar area with all localsWheelchair accessibility: Yes one floor with wide door ways“

4 Good65 Reviews
Vicci's Pizza & Restaurant Pizza • $
361 NJ-36, Port Monmouth

Customers` Favorites

Large Pizza Pie Half Meatball
Cugini's Cheesesteak Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Grilled Chicken
Hawaiian Pizza
Pepperoni Roll
Various Slices
Sicilian Slice
Buffalo Wings

“i was a little worried when they changed from Viccis to Cuginis, but the food is just as good, if not, better! Staff has always been friendly and professional, and the wings, best wings I've ever had, there sauce is thicker and creamery than I've ever had, and it's amazing, if you like buffalo wings, try these and it'll blow your mind“

4 Good35 Reviews
Naples Pizzeria Pizza • $
872 Main St, Belford

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana over Spaghetti
Grille Asparagus Salad Special
Stuffed Flounder
Buffalo Chicken
Coconut Shrimp
Vegetable Wrap
Grandma Pie

“Best pizza shop in Middletown. The pizza is very good. Been going there since I was a kid. The prices are also very affordable. It's BYOB for dine in. The staff is always friendly. Highly recommend.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible“

3.9 Good32 Reviews
Sisters Pizza and Grill Pizza Delivery •
147 Cherry Tree Farm Rd, Middletown

“I'm a New Yorker living in Jersey, so I've had my fair share of vegan pizza since going vegan in 2008. Pasquales III is hands down my #1 favorite spot for vegan pizza. Everything they have to offer is incredible. They have the best garlic knot crust of any I've tried. Typically pizza places don't have a great knot to pizza ratio, but with P3 you get plenty of pizza bites without the knots stealing the show.“

3.8 Good13 Reviews
Tre Colore Pizzeria Pizza • $
1207 NJ-35, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Sausage
Wings

“My regular stop before night school. Their steak burrito bowl is absolutely perfect. Comes with verde or red salsa, personally i like the verde it’s also a bit more mild. Pizza always looks delicious and fresh but haven’t tried yet. Super consistent. Highly recommend.“

3.8 Good24 Reviews
Pasquale's Pizzeria III Pizza • $
147 Cherry Tree Farm Rd, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots
Vegan Pizza

“We’ve been ordering take out and delivery from Pasquale’s for years. They have a vast and delicious vegan menu, ranging from pizzas to apps to dinners. Everything we’ve had from here, both vegan and not, is a winner. Easy to order online through the Toast app. Pick up is quick, although sometimes their quoted pick up times have been 15-20 min off. Delivery is always speedy!“

3.6 Good21 Reviews
Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria Pizza • $$
608 Newman Springs Rd, Lincroft

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Seafood Risotto
Pepperoni Pizza
White Pizza
Subs

“The pizza is par for the shore. The people are all locals, which I appreciate. Keeping the business local is important. The decor is fully Italian, old country. Small place, good atmosphere whether you're looking for quick pizza by the slice or in the back for a sit-down restaurant meal. Not the cheapest prices, but also not cheapest made.“

3.7 Good44 Reviews
Valentino's Restaurant Pizza • $
89 Leonardville Rd, Belford

Customers` Favorites

Special Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Peppers
Chicken Parm Sub
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Plain Slice

“That place in Campbell Junction in Belford is so dirty the floor is so dirty last time I was in there. There were small little begs frying around near tables.. honestly I don't think the pizza wasn't all that good anyway too. Never will I go there again.“

3.6 Good29 Reviews
Basille's Restaurant Pizza • $
1104 NJ-35, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Various Pizza Slices
Margherita Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Pie
Caesar Salad

“I was really excited to try this pizzeria. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked in and got the old school vibe. I was greeted and ordered the chicken pie. It was made fresh and came out in about 10 minutes. It looked good! When I dug in, I noticed it was a bit messy with the crust. I found out it was dipped Panko bread crumbs, which was super cool and made it more tasty. I really enjoyed my experience and time.“

3.7 Good56 Reviews
Loading...
map Map