4.3
Superb
98 Reviews
415 Clifton Avenue, Lakewood · 3.91 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Chocolate Rugelach
- Chocolate Rugelah
- Chocolate Babka
- Custard Danish
“If you’re in Lakewood and you have even a drop of a sweet tooth, Gelbstein’s is basically a ניסיונות station. You walk in “just to look,” and two minutes later you’re leaving with a box, a bag, and a third thing you don’t remember agreeing to… because the smell of fresh pastry makes you sign away your free will. 😄 First of all, everything is fresh. Not “fresh-ish.” I mean fresh fresh — like the danishes are still warm and the crumbs are already following you home. The rugelach/danish vibe is top-tier, the pastries are flaky in a way that makes you whisper “וואו” without realizing, and the challah is the kind that turns a regular Shabbos table into a whole simcha. And it’s not just the classics — they’ve got fun stuff too (those cute cupcakes and seasonal things), so it’s perfect when you need: a quick treat for the car (aka: “for later”), something respectable to bring to a vort/Sheva Brachos, or a Shabbos dessert that looks like you put in effort (בלי עין הרע). Also, the place has a very heimish, local feel — you’ll bump into half of Lakewood in there, all pretending they’re “only buying one thing.” Sure. We all believe you. Bottom line: delicious, consistent, and dangerous in the best way. Highly recommend — just don’t come in hungry unless you’re okay with your wallet doing teshuvah afterward. 😄”