9 Best American Restaurants in Keyport

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits American • $$
84 Broad St, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Giant Bavarian Pretzel with Spicy Mustard
Old Glory Mac & Cheese Dine in: Yes
Keyport Crab Cake Sandwich
Cheeseburger Eggrolls
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Mediterranean Pizza
The Old Glory Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Brick Oven Wings
Loaded Meatballs

“Coolest place ever - def check it out.“

4.1 Good165 Reviews
Drew's Bayshore Bistro Bistros • $$$
44 E Front St, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Scallops with Butternut Squash Risotto
French Quarter Chicken Cordon Blue
Topped with Chocolate Gelato
Seared Day-Boat Sea Scallops
Southwestern Caesar Salad
Canal Street Salad Salad
Voodoo Shrimp Appetizer
Crabmeat Hush Puppies
Apple Cider Beignets
Fried Green Tomatoes

“From the moment Drew opened his doors in his original location we quickly became fans. This creative Chef who works magic with food has turned Drew’s Bayshore Bistro into one of the most popular restaurants to eat at. People come from all over to enjoy and will take any time slot available to do so. We have eaten here more times than I can count and have had many group dinners and celebrations. Drew’s new location is beyond beautiful and only a stone’s throw from his prior place. We just love the feel of the new home and the beautiful ambiance. it’s absolutely gorgeous from street view and fits perfectly into Keyport’s historic vibe. The food is also over the top insanely incredible. Oh yes I have favorites. The scallops are perfectly sautéed, tender juicy and was served with pesto risotto. A true explosion of flavor. Broiled oysters are one of the most incredible thing I’ve ever tasted and honestly could eat two portions for my main, but haven’t done that yet as there are so many things to try. Pork chops, steaks, soft shell crabs, voodoo shrimp, homemade ice cream and all his special makes it hard to choose what to order. Incredible list of specials are always offered. Menu changes for seasonal favorites. I feel like a kid in a candy store when I look at the menu. We are very thankful to Drew for sharing his vision and providing all of us with a delectable dinning experience each time we eat here. Five stars are not enough!“

4.8 Superb121 Reviews
Keyport Fishery Seafood Markets • $$
150 W Front St, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Clam Sandwich Platter
칼라마리 튀김
Louisiana Crab Soup
Scallops Platter
Fried Scallops
Cocktail Sauce
Combination
Calamari
Flounder
Clams

“best fried shrimp in the state“

4.4 Superb265 Reviews
Yellow Rose Diner Diner • $
41 NJ-36, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Fried or Scrambled Eggs with Breakfast Meat
Eggs Benedict Florentine w Turkey Sausage
Scrambled Eggsand Bacon and Home Fries
Yellow Rose Buttermilk Pancakes 5
The Breakfast Grab Sandwich
Crock of French Onion Soup
Belgian Tropical Waffle
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Blueberry Pancakes
Sweet Potato Fries

“The French Toast one of the best we’ve had. The senior menu perfect amount of food, and great price. The service was wonderful and friendly. And I’m told the sometimes have scrapple, hoping to catch that next visit.“

4.2 Good89 Reviews
McDonagh’s Pub & Restaurant Irish Pub • $$
2 W Front St, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Guinness Stout Ireland Irish Dry Stout 4 2 ABV
Corned Beef and Cabbage
McDonagh's Burger
Loaded Pub Fries
Brick Oven Wings
Boneless Wings
Fried Pickles
Corned Beef
Tater Tots
Pub Sliders

“We just had a surprise dinner party for my son's 21st Birthday under the tent outside. I was so happy with how it all turned out. The manager & event planner were so helpful & accommodating. The service & food was great! Our guests had 4 choices of Entrees on the prefixed menu, which was more than many other places we looked into. We were very happy.“

3.8 Good152 Reviews
Up The Creek Tavern Bar & Grill • $
350 W Front St, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Smothered Ribeye Steak Sandwich
New England Clam Chowder
Flounder Platter
Burger

“We originally pulled up to the bar across the street to play pool but it was packed. I took a chance and was pleasantly surprised. I really enjoyed this place. The pool table takes $1 bills, the bar tender was EXCELLENT, the drinks were reasonably priced, the bar pie was good and the outdoor deck has a ton of potential- it overlooks the marina.

I lived here for 30 + years / never knew about this place. Needless to say; I'll be back for sure“

4 Good30 Reviews
Burlew's Seafood and Steak Seafood • $$
59 W Front St, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Sweet & Spicy Shrimp Calamari
Shrimp & Scallop Fra Diablo
Old Glory Chicken Sandwich
Blackened Swordfish Bites
Blackened Mahi Mahi Tacos
Manhattan Clam Chowder
Clams on the Half Shell
Fried Seafood Platter
Broiled Seafood Combo
Burlew's House Salad

“Outstanding vibe and great service. Our server was Christina and she was extremely pleasant, had a great personality and seemed very happy to be working there. They also had a guitar player who played wonderfully and wasn’t overpowering so you can still chat with your table. Very satisfied with the food so compliments to the back staff. It’s very obvious the management runs a well organized restaurant so 👍👍. Just an awesome experience and we all look forward to heading back. Thank you all!“

3.7 Good144 Reviews
Tony's Pizza & Restaurant Pizza • $
300 NJ-35, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Cheese Steak Slice
Sicilian Pizza
Sausage Pizza

“The pizza is some of the best around. They have very unique and very tasty choices which you can't get anywhere else.
I'm looking at a few reviews that are showing burnt crusts on the pizzas saying that they are overcooked, evidently those people are clueless on how pizza should be cooked.
Their Sicilian is probably the best around, airy and crispy, and their Italian sausage is fantastic. Try a variety of their shrimp pizzas with either jalapeño, Chipotle or avocado which are all available by the slice. They offer the largest variety of pies by the slice in the area so you can go in and select from a variety of choices without having to order the entire pie.
Do yourself a favor and give them a try.
My only objection is that it's not a place you can go for an evening out with the family but that could be fixed easily by partioning off the back half of the restaurant with either a divider or curtains where you can have a more intimate setting.
Otherwise, the pizzas awesome at a better price than most others pizzerias.“

3.5 Good41 Reviews
Town & Country Inn Diner • $
48 NJ-35, Keyport

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken in a Basket
Shrimp & Scallops Scampi
French Fries with Gravy
Strawberry Cheesecake
Chocolate Mocha Cake
Assorted Layer Cakes
Fried Chicken Dinner
Country Fried Steak
Maine Lobster Tail
Chicken Francaise

“Great service, great and pleasant server KRISTINA!!!!!“

3.4 Good141 Reviews