50 Best American Restaurants near Atlantic Highlands

1 Emilio’s Kitchen

4.9 Superb 412 Reviews

77 Center Avenue, Atlantic Highlands

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’ve been about 5 times so far and LOVE Emelio’s! The food is fresh and delicious and the portions generous. Even their simple side salad is something special - delicious, light dressing. And the service is great, which is hard to come by these days. It’s clearly a family-run place where Everyone cares about the quality. Also impeccably clean!”

2 On the Deck

4.6 Superb 277 Reviews

10 Simon Lake Dr, Atlantic Highlands

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Most amazing views you could ask for on the water. \nWatch the boats come in and the ferry go out. \n\nThe sangria comes by the picture and is exceptionally good. \nThe service was very good and bar scene was vibrant. \nThe food is very good too. \nYou go here for the view and get good eats to top it off!”

3 Sissy's At the Harbor

4.5 Superb 196 Reviews

8 Simon Lake Drive, Atlantic Highlands

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good for breakfast and lunch - cash only. The patio is lovely in warm weather and the location is tops - very picturesque. Weekends during the summer is crunch time! Food is good, not great but thats ok as you dont go to Sissy's for a gourmet experience. Like to bring visitors as the location can't be beat”

4 Navesink Fishery

4.5 Superb 166 Reviews

1004 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“always fresh seafood feels like a good home cooked meal”

5 The Wine Bar and Restaurant

4.2 Good 147 Reviews

40 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Crashed a private event and it was just my style. Might be stuffy in comparison to the bar around the corner, but otherwise seems like first class classical music and comfy couches for a celebratory drink. Can't comment on the food. Bartender was nice about walking in to the event.”

6 Harborside Grill

3.9 Good 221 Reviews

40 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great place to grab a drink and and a quick bite to eat. the food is very good , and they have the greatest bartender . MR SCOTT WOLFE!! THE WOLF!! very fun place”

7 Jillaney's Luncheonette

4.9 Superb 193 Reviews

220 Main Street, Keansburg · 5.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just a damn good down home restaurant with good food good prices and good people .”

8 JBJ Soul Kitchen

4.9 Superb 174 Reviews

207 Monmouth St, Red Bank · 4.65 miles

• Delivery

“Soul Kitchen is amazing! Our students love working with the great staff and always feel welcome and learn great skills and life lessons. The student favorite part of the soul Kitchen experience is of course the delicious food made by Chef Emily and her staff. The Matawan Regional staff and students want to thank Bon Jovi and all his supporters for a great experience and relationship!”

9 d'jeet

4.4 Superb 309 Reviews

637 Broad Street, Shrewsbury · 5.54 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had an amazing dinner last night, picked one of the seasonal menu options— the halibut and it was FANTASTIC! I couldn’t get enough of it, every bite was so flavorful and delicious!! I’d love for you guys to keep this on the menu. Can’t wait to go back and have it again!”

10 26 West On The Navesink

4.4 Superb 300 Reviews

26 West Front Street, Red Bank · 4.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Visited this excellent restaurant for the first time today. Our experience was terrific. The food was delicious, great presentation and the service from our waiter David was outstanding.”

11 Fresh

4.8 Superb 146 Reviews

144 Bay Avenue, Highlands · 2.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Tonight we had dinner at Fresh in Atlantic Highlands, and all I can say is… wow. This was, without question, one of the best dining experiences we’ve had in a very long time. Everything was incredibly fresh, beautifully prepared, and absolutely delicious. We enjoyed the beet salad, octopus, shrimp appetizer, steak, sea bass, espresso, a latte, and yes… five desserts! Every single dish was outstanding. But here’s what really amazed me. Ladies, you know that feeling when you’re halfway through dinner at most restaurants and suddenly your rings are tight, your feet start to swell, your rings get snug, your clothes feel uncomfortable, and you leave feeling bloated and miserable? That never happened. Even after an incredible multi-course meal and dessert, we walked out feeling satisfied—not stuffed, bloated, or uncomfortable. To me, that’s a testament to the freshness and quality of the ingredients and the care that goes into every dish. The service was just as impressive as the food. This isn’t the kind of restaurant where one server takes care of your table while everyone else walks by. Every member of the staff works together seamlessly. Someone is always checking on you, clearing plates, refilling water, delivering food, or making sure you have everything you need. You can tell they genuinely function as a team, and it creates such a warm, effortless dining experience. They also have an incredible staff, yet the atmosphere remains relaxed and welcoming. It’s a BYOB, which makes the value even better. Considering the quality of the food, the level of service, and the overall experience, I honestly couldn’t believe how reasonable the prices were. Fresh is truly a hidden gem in Atlantic Highlands. In my opinion, it deserves to be recognized by the Michelin Guide. The food, the service, the attention to detail, and the overall experience were simply exceptional. If you haven’t been yet, make a reservation. You won’t be disappointed. We will absolutely be back!”

12 Crown Chicken & Gyro

4.6 Superb 283 Reviews

274 NJ-36, Keansburg · 6.09 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I just had the BEST beef gyro! Beef was so tender and tasty and the tzatziki sauce was delicious! I will be back again!”

13 My Kitchen Witch

4.6 Superb 263 Reviews

29 Beach Road, Monmouth Beach · 6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I am leaving a production catering review. My Kitchen Witch provided catering to a large production crew and security where I work (a large historical building on Wall Street). I couldn't believe how quick and professional that My Kitchen Witch was in set-up, the meals, and the breakdown of their service. The food was excellent, especially the pork carnitas and Mexican street corn! I definitely highly recommend and would love to head to their cafe in Monmouth Beach, New Jersey!”

14 Charlie's of Lincroft

4.3 Superb 235 Reviews

700 Newman Springs Road, Lincroft · 7.02 miles

• Delivery

“All Around 5 stars this place is what other restaurants strive to be like. They have it all going on. Atmosphere, Service, Food Quality just everything was Simply Fantastic! Pictures I took are of their private banquet room that I may plan my Daughter's High School Graduation party at. There is an amazing wine conference style room downstairs that I didn't photograph. This place is very VERY nice.”

15 River Pointe Inn

4.6 Superb 71 Reviews

132 East River Road, Rumson · 3.06 miles

“Loved, loved, loved the cheeseburger and their moules frites. We also enjoyed the bread service. On our last visit we tried the caviar donut app and the escargot which were good but the escargot were on the saltier side. Fries are to die for!!”

16 Hoagitos

4.6 Superb 118 Reviews

2005 NJ-35 Suite 06, Oakhurst · 9.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“breakfast, lunch, or dinner... they have the best sandwiches at the most reasonable prices around”

17 Belford Bistro

4.8 Superb 66 Reviews

870 Main St, Belford · 3.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Everything was fantastic as usual. Love going there and love the BYOB.”

18 Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar

4.4 Superb 314 Reviews

1 NJ-36, Highlands · 2.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Go there every time we are at sandy hook great food snd service”

19 Amy's Omelette House - Long Branch

4.4 Superb 301 Reviews

444 Ocean Boulevard North, Long Branch · 6.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The breakfast there was amazing and the bacon pancakes are to die for. That’s how good they were. That was the breakfast my family had”

20 Mule Barn Tavern Restaurant - Highlands

4.4 Superb 297 Reviews

36 Kearney Road, Highlands · 4.26 miles

“We ate here today. It was our first time. We loved the food and the atmosphere. It has an interesting history. Definitely worth the drive.”

21 Elli’s Backyard

4.4 Superb 213 Reviews

45 Broad Street, Red Bank · 4.27 miles

• Delivery

“Another amazing dinner at Elli’s! The staff is so friendly, the food amazing and the atmosphere is so cozy. Will be back again!”

22 Lana

4.4 Superb 204 Reviews

32 Laird Street, Long Branch · 7.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Very nice place!! Great staff and good food!!”

23 Semolina Restaurant

4.3 Superb 780 Reviews

13 White Street, Red Bank · 4.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“If I tell you how wonderful the place, the people, the plates are will you promise not to go? It’s hard enough snagging a reservation without hoards of people trying to book a table after reading justifiably rave reviews. OK, here goes. Agnolotti pasta and sweet potato hush puppies as appetizers to start and oh, what a start it was. Monk fish and a bacon-jam encrusted pork chop, both cooked to perfection, as entrees. Lemon tart and a you-gotta-try-it-once-in-your-life “budino,” for dessert. (Do you know stressed spelled backwards is desserts?) What’s a budino you ask? Adult pudding, whipped by angels, so addictive it must have been created by Satan. Farm to Table, fresh, sustainable, local, tucked away on a side street in Red Bank… and you get to bring your own favorite wine. Don’t go. Don’t tell your friends. Let this gem be all mine.”

24 Raven Tea Room

4.6 Superb 47 Reviews

740 River Road, Fair Haven · 3.03 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The new chef is magical creating absolutely delicious food and the service is outstanding! A wonderful restaurant, far superior then the old chef and waitstaff.”

25 Applebee's Grill + Bar

4.3 Superb 427 Reviews

1183 NJ-35, Middletown · 4.11 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We love coming to our local Applebees especially since we always get Sage our favorite waitress! She was absolutely fantastic and always gives us the best drink and food recommendations and always has such a kind demeanor and attitude and is always a pleasure.”

26 Sissy's Place

4.6 Superb 36 Reviews

868 Main St, Belford · 3.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Was in the mood for a cheeseburger and fries. Did not know what to expect, BUT I got the burger I ever had and the fries were to die for. Will go back and try the rest of the menu.”

27 Turning Point of Holmdel

4.7 Superb 254 Reviews

2132 NJ-35, Holmdel · 5.94 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have dined here multiple times. The food is always great as is the service. The restaurant has a cute vibe, however the last few times I have eaten here the restaurant has been extremely dirty. The silverware is not clean and the tables and floors are not clean. The tables nearby remain uncleared for the duration of our dining. I want to keep dining here, but it really needs to be better kept.”

28 Rooney's Oceanfront Restaurant

4.5 Superb 1,486 Reviews

100 Ocean Avenue North, Long Branch · 7.47 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing food, view and atmosphere! Darrel and his team are top notch. Highly recommend lunch, dinner or happy hour at this spot!”

29 Buffalo Wild Wings

4.6 Superb 421 Reviews

180 NJ-35 Suite 2004A, Eatontown · 8.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My friends and I stopped at this BWW location after a long beach day, and we had the most amazing time! The restaurant was more than accommodating for our group of 13 people, and all the staff were so friendly. Rosa was our server and she was the kindest, and most genuine person we have ever met. She checked in on us many times, and was so nice to chat with. She clearly loves her job, and you can't help but smile when talking to her. All the food was delicious, and they got every order perfect. We had the best time at this BWW and will definitely be back to visit Rosa!”

30 Jr's Red Bank

4.4 Superb 38 Reviews

17 W Front St, Red Bank · 4.2 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome food! My Maui Sliders were the BEST! Tater Tots with Cheese were so good as well!”

31 Beach Grille

4.3 Superb 38 Reviews

49 Atlantic Ave, Long Branch · 6.69 miles

• Take-Out

“Excellent service. Friendly atmosphere”

32 Porcini

4.7 Superb 209 Reviews

168 Bay Avenue, Highlands · 2.53 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Thank you for such a wonderful evening! We couldn’t have chosen a better place for Kelsey and Michael’s rehearsal dinner. Service was excellent, staff was so welcoming and accommodating ❤️ All of the food was delicious with beautiful presentation. Thanks so much!”

33 Victory Park Tavern

4.6 Superb 339 Reviews

21 West River Road, Rumson · 2.55 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“A real home town feel! This restaurant is a throwback to how customer service should be. Everyone is so nice. Service with a smile. Outstanding food! Chef Pete is a legend at his craft. Get the Mahi Mahi!”

34 Dish & Saucery

4.6 Superb 5 Reviews

471 Saint NJ-35, Red Bank · 3.59 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“if you want food that doesn't have junky additives, this is your store. Unlike other places that sell rotisserie chickens that are injected with sugary additives, the ones here are organic and have no unhealthy things added. Their bread is fresh. The choices in items are healthy. the only negatives about the store are 1) high prices and 2) some of the produce is old. We buy our produce at farms during seasonal bounty or else we buy it at Foodtown.”

35 JD's Tavern

4.3 Superb 24 Reviews

3932 Amboy Road, Staten Island · 11.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Cozy and fun great beers great jukebox music. And never overly crowded ever. Love the entire menu. Great homemade chips. Delicious burghers.”

36 Johnny B’s Cooking

5.0 Superb 1 Review

741 Pinebrook Rd, Eatontown · 8.19 miles

37 Market Plate

4.5 Superb 2 Reviews

471 St NJ-35, Red Bank · 3.59 miles

• Delivery

“if you want food that doesn't have junky additives, this is your store. Unlike other places that sell rotisserie chickens that are injected with sugary additives, the ones here are organic and have no unhealthy things added. Their bread is fresh. The choices in items are healthy. the only negatives about the store are 1) high prices and 2) some of the produce is old. We buy our produce at farms during seasonal bounty or else we buy it at Foodtown.”

38 The Miami Club Restaurant

4.2 Good 4 Reviews

307 Beachway Ave, Keansburg · 6.33 miles

“The food is fresh and authentic, it taste like what we find on the ��.”

39 Turning Point of Little Silver

4.6 Superb 299 Reviews

496 Prospect Avenue, Little Silver · 4.79 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“THE BREAKFAST AND LUNCH (FOOD OVERALL) IS AMAZING!!! WOW, THE BEST I'VE HAD IN CENTRAL JERSEY. EVERYTHING IS COOKED TO PERFECTION. THIS WAS MY FIRST TIME HAVING THEIR BREAKFAST AND LUNCH AND THIS PLACE HAS WON ME OVER. IM VERY PICKY WHEN IT COMES TO A GOOD BREAKFAST, THIS PLACE HAS FULFILLED MY NEEDS. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND AND WILL REVISIT TIME-TO-TIME. SO GLAD I FINALLY FOUND A PLACE I LIKE. 🙌”

40 Highlands on the Bay Condominium

4.0 Good 1 Review

16 Beach Boulevard, Highlands · 2.09 miles

41 2nd Jetty Seafood

4.4 Superb 265 Reviews

140 Ocean Avenue, Sea Bright · 3.19 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Request for Review. We recently received a notification indicating that our page may have violated Facebook’s Community Standards. We respectfully request a review of this decision, as we believe it may have been the result of a misunderstanding. We take Facebook’s policies very seriously and are fully committed to complying with all applicable Community Standards. If any content on our page was found to be non-compliant unintentionally, we are more than willing to address the matter promptly and make any necessary corrections. We kindly request your guidance regarding the specific issue so we can ensure full compliance moving forward. Please check the comment box associated with this post for any additional information or clarification. Thank you for your time, support, and consideration. We appreciate your assistance and look forward to your response. Sincerely, Page Administrator”

42 Houlihan's

4.2 Good 249 Reviews

2136 NJ-35, Holmdel · 5.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Houlihan's is definitely one of my go to dinner or lunch places on a regular basis. I always ask for Colleen as her customer service skills are an A+++. She is pleasant, knowledgeable, and makes great recommendations. Besides the made to order food; the amazing french onion soup, yummy chicken wings, perfect salmon, prime rib sandwich, just like homemade pot roast, just to name a few good foods, Colleen is a main reason why I have been a regular for so many years. A shout out also to Al, one of the managers who is also a staple at the Holmdel Houlihan's. He is a true customer service person and he always greets you with a big smile. As a matter of fact I am going to Houlihan's tonight for dinner and have already requested my favorite waitress Colleen. Now what should I order tonight....mmmmm”

43 Grill 36

4.7 Superb 171 Reviews

127 Carr Avenue, Keansburg · 6.04 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I had a great casual lunch with friends here yesterday. First of all, the staff is very friendly and helped me understand the menu items when I had a few questions. This is the sort of spot that combines the menus of many different restaurants so everyone has something to choose from depending on their taste. The lamb gyro I ordered was made with fresh ingredients and they have the best kind of fries as a side (in my opinion 🫶). I was the only one that ate meat out of our group and my two vegan friends had plenty of options to choose from. There is a wheel chair ramp. There is limited indoor seating from what I saw.”

44 The Robinson Ale House

4.2 Good 572 Reviews

26 Broad Street, Red Bank · 4.24 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Staff and management are great! highly recommend”

45 Drifthouse Restaurant, Lounge and Bar

4.2 Good 747 Reviews

1485 Ocean Avenue, Sea Bright · 5.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“It was Awesome! Best Branzino fish I ever had in NJ, the Riesling wine was also good, dessert was excellent and the staff was delightful and attentive, great job guys I give you 5 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️”

46 Cobalt Cafe & Lounge

4.0 Good 24 Reviews

700 Hope Road, Tinton Falls · 8.77 miles

“Stayed overnight for a one day work trip. After a 51/2 hour drive the last thing I wanted to do was drive anywhere for dinner ( didn’t want food in take out containers either) sat at the bar, had a Caesar salad and pasta primavera, added salmon. The salmon was perfectly cooked as ordered ( medium rare) and it was excellent! A bit pricey, but excellent food and service!”

47 Apple Street Kitchen

4.4 Superb 207 Reviews

33 Apple Street, Tinton Falls · 5.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Apple Street Kitchen was the venue for my surprise birthday party this past weekend. Everything about this lovely place was amazing. It was the perfect size for our family and friends, the food was outstanding, each dish delicious, the service was wonderful, the evening was perfect. Many thanks to the wait staff and the chef for a very special and memorable evening, I couldn’t have loved it more.”

48 Rise N Shine Diner

4.8 Superb 107 Reviews

14 Main St, Eatontown · 7.25 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My husband and I had breakfast here yesterday. It was our first time at Rise n Shine and we loved it!!! Great food and service. Our new favorite restaurant.”

49 Barnacle Bill's

4.3 Superb 320 Reviews

1 1st Street, Rumson · 2.47 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Came here twice so far both times was amazing. Service was great food was great. Nice atmosphere decor is great it’s a great hidden gem.”

50 Edie's Luncheonette

4.7 Superb 131 Reviews

164 Rumson Road, Little Silver · 4.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food is great, served in a timely fashion, service very good. Lobster salad sandwiches are outstanding.”