10 Best American Restaurants in Highlands

1

Fresh

Fresh American • $$$
144 Bay Avenue, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Asparagus with Lemon Thyme Vinaigrette
Roasted Brussel Sprouts with Pancetta
Shrimp and Sweet Pea Risotto
Chocolate Decadence Cake
House Made Carrot Cake
Whole Roasted Carrots
Peaches and Cream Pie
NY Style Cheesecake
Lobster Tagliatelle
Octopus on Grill

“If I could give 10 stars I would! I just had my daughter’s baptism lunch at Fresh and along with every single guest we had I could not be more happy with the food, service,hospitality and accommodations! The food was delicious! So fresh and made with passion. The chef knows what he’s doing. The 2 men that hosted for us were beyond professional, patient and friendly to us and our guests. Every step of the way from planning to finish they were amazing! After we got home I had so many people reaching out to me about how good this place is and how they will definitely be returning for dinner in the near future. Thank you all so much for helping make this day stress free and most importantly SPECIAL!“

4.8 Superb155 Reviews
Mule Barn Tavern Restaurant - Highlands Pizza • $$
36 Kearney Road, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Mule Salad with Grilled Chicken and a Pulled Pork Sandwich with Sweet Potato Fries
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Calamari and Tuna T
Bacon Cheese Burger
Lighthouse Burger
Industrial Burger
Side Caesar Salad
Margherita Pizza
Stuffed Pepper
Classic Burger

“We ate here today. It was our first time. We loved the food and the atmosphere. It has an interesting history. Definitely worth the drive.“

4.4 Superb292 Reviews
Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar American • $$
1 NJ-36, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Grouper Sandwich
Warm Buttered Lobster Roll
Voo Doo Shrimp & Scallops
Fried Flounder Sandwich
Lobster Salad Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak
Short Rib Sandwich
Ahi Tuna blt Wrap
Crab Cake Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich

“Go there every time we are at sandy hook great food snd service“

4.2 Good352 Reviews
Highlands on the Bay Condominium American •
16 Beach Boulevard, Highlands
4 Good1 Reviews
Porcini Italian
168 Bay Avenue, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Kale and Brussels Sprouts Salad
Butternut Squash Ravioli
German Chocolate Cake
Grilled Hanger Steak
Pan Seared Scallops
Sweet Corn Ravioli
Salad Mixed Greens
Potato Leek Soup
Homemade Gelato
Grouper Special

“Thank you for such a wonderful evening! We couldn’t have chosen a better place for Kelsey and Michael’s rehearsal dinner. Service was excellent, staff was so welcoming and accommodating ❤️ All of the food was delicious with beautiful presentation. Thanks so much!“

4.6 Superb221 Reviews
The Seafarer Bar • $$
1 Atlantic Street, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Pit Fries

“I can't say enough good things about this place, obviously a waterfront beach bar has an amazing view and cool atmosphere, they're constantly hosting events, live music, which attracts a great crowd as well. And by the way, in my opinion as far as bar food goes they're top tier. Not just burgers and chicken fingers but kabobs and short ribs and things you typically see as bar food. Awesome bar food, get a spot on a couch in front of a fire pit next to the water with live music... hard to beat that“

4.6 Superb154 Reviews
Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina Seafood • $$
2 Bay Avenue, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Steamers Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes
Fried Calamari with Zesty Marinara Sauce
Local Clams on the Half Shell
12 Oysters on the Half Shell
Hot Lobster Roll with Fries
Famous Seafood Restaurant
Fried Calamari Appetizer
Steamed Soft Shell Clams
Local Fried Strip Clams
Fried Flounder Sandwich

“Always a Good time and Great food Epic scenery“

4.2 Good984 Reviews
The Chubby Pickle Sports Bar • $$
23 Bay Avenue, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings with Choice of Buffalo Honey Chipotle or Thai Ginger Sauce
Deep Fried Dill Pickles
Avocado Toast Burger
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Chubby Sauce Wings
Seared Cajun Tuna
The Smash Burger
Triple B Burger
Hand Cut Fries
Chubby Burger

“The food is fantastic! I especially love the fried pickles. The nachos were great and the burgers were delicious. I had the pleasure of attending an open mic night and catching live music on another night, which made for a great place to hang out.
However, the pours in mixed drinks are inconsistent. I got the rum bucket one night, got pleasantly drunk off of just one, got the same thing the next time I got there and barely felt tipsy off of two of them :/ I had the same experience another time with a different cocktail--one of them I could taste the alcohol and I liked it, I ordered the same one again and it had very little alcohol in it.“

4.2 Good250 Reviews
Moby's Lobster Deck Seafood • $$
2 South Bay Avenue, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Fried Shrimp and French Fries
Sea Dog with Fries and Coleslaw
Twin 1 1 8 lb Steamed Lobster
Oysters on the Half Shell
Oyster on the Half Shell
Clams on the Half Shell
Cheeseburger and Fries
Fried Shrimp Platter
Fisherman's Platter
Full Lobster Roll

“Great place. A diamond in the rough for sure. Casual and relaxing.“

3.8 Good254 Reviews
Inlet Cafe Seafood • $$
3 Cornwall Street, Highlands

Customers` Favorites

Oysters Rockefeller
Grouper Filet
Cod Sandwich
Lobster Roll
Inlet Clams
Calamari
Chowder
Salad

“Great mussels! Dog friendly outdoor seating. Great location on the water.“

3.1 Average313 Reviews

You May Also Like