12 Best Ice Cream Shops near Long Valley

“After sampling a couple of flavors, I had the miso ice cream with white chocolate and my goodness it was good! I appreciate the variety of traditional and funky flavors. They were also very nice. One scoop with tax and tip cost me $6. It is located in a large strip mall with ample parking. No seating inside but the strip mall had some benches outside in the courtyard area. I'll be back!Dietary restrictions: They had a separate case of vegan options.“

“The ice cream is amazing! I highly recommend their ice cream cakes, totally worth the price! Always a friendly staff. It's right out on the highway so there is a lot of noise from traffic going by but there's tables to sit at And when it's a summer night the place is always crowded because it's that good! If I have one complaint it would be that I wish they had a public restroom.“

“I recently experienced an incredible time at Taylor Ice Cream Parlor . The atmosphere was simply amazing, creating a perfect setting for a delightful evening. The service was top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff ensuring a seamless experience. And let's not forget the star of the show – the ice cream was beyond delicious, making it a memorable treat. Highly recommended for those seeking a combination of a fantastic ambiance, excellent service, and delightful ice cream.“

“We just got home with our vegan crepes (a veggie and a Suzette) - first time getting food from here. We inhaled them. They were absolutely delicious. The owner (I think) was very sweet and the restaurant was very clean. We already want to go back.Vegetarian options: Vegan crepes (sweet and savory) or delicious!“

“The prices are very fair, the ice cream is delicious, the establishment is very clean, the environment is always pleasant & today in particular the young lady serving MacKenzie is the absolute best. She was very friendly, patient, polite, respectful, and professional.“

“A perfect spot for a classic American breakfast! The POTM (pumpkin, was seriously outstanding. And let's talk about the coffee – it's the kind that makes you want a second cup before you've even finished the first. A perfect brunch spot for a cozy and yummy treat!“

“Rita's Ice Cream is a delightful treat that truly hits the spot on a hot summer day! The selection of flavors is fantastic, and each one is packed with creamy goodness. I particularly loved their unique Italian ice, which offered a refreshing burst of fruity flavors. The service was friendly and efficient, making the overall experience even better. Whether you're a fan of classic favorites or adventurous tastes, Rita's Ice Cream is a must-visit for any ice cream lover. Highly recommended! ??“

“Drove by this eatery dozens of times and never stopped. Finally, we decided to pull in and give it a try. Must say, some solid food here. The burgers are amazing and service perfect. Staff extremely great, a must try!! Should of tried much earlier.“

“I understand this is a local business here and I know I needed to try the Italian Ice! As soon as I spotted a location off the side of the road I exclaimed "STOP"! Rita's did not disappoint! I ordered a four-flavor sampler that they made for me in a cup. My flavor choices were black cherry, mango, strawberry, and peach and they surely didn't disappoint! I will be returning for a milkshake or sundae very soon!“

“I had a green tea with boba and it was tasty! I'm not sure if it's standard practice with boba tea shops to select the amount of sugar based on a percentage, but that seemed like a great and consistent way to do it. It would be great for this space to include tables and chairs and be more of a cafe setting. The only other suggestion would be a better gift card/certificate system. I wanted to purchase a gift certificate for a friend and I had to pick a drink off the menu for the drink price (instead of buying a cert. for $10 or $20), and it printed a receipt that said "GIFT RECEIPT" on the bottom and it expires in one month! Not a problem for her, but could be for others if your gift expires in one month. Anyway, overall, I like this spot and I'll be back!“

“Thank goodness for Ritas! This magical oasis is a must stop in the summer while we are out and about. Plenty of parking is available. The staff is always friendly and the store front is always clean. They have picnic benches available so one can enjoy their delicious treat outside. Plenty of flavors and topping to choice from. Watermelon and mango are my favorite flavors. Swedish Fish with Gummy Bears are my kids favorite. Make sure you stop by if your in the area. You will not be disappointed.“