14 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mount Olive

“Hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had! I’ve been out of the area for over a year and was just checking to see about getting some shipped to Florida, but it doesn’t seem so! I’m a Grahamsterdam and Chocolate Cake girl. Must try this place if you’re in North Jersey — so, so good!“

“Absolutely the best ice cream place I’ve ever had in my life…“

“PEANUT ALLERGY FAMILY!! Let me start off by saying I love love loved the ice cream here from day 1. The staff is wonderful and super attentive, but last night was above and beyond. I went for dessert with my oldest son and wanted to bring some back for my 8 month old to share with me. We just discovered my 8 month old has a peanut allergy and we aren’t sure what other nuts he might be allergic to yet. I told the staff all of this. The gentleman who made my order went ABOVE AND BEYOND to make sure that ice cream was safe to share with him (of course I know there are no guarantees when you are eating out). I can’t tell you how much that meant to me since allergies like this are new to my family and I. I cannot thank them enough!! They gained a customer for life.“

“Have been a customer for 40 years. Great owner and staff, good food, friendly atmosphere. What else is there to say?“

“If you’re looking for the best ice cream in Morris County, look no further! Sundaes ice cream is delicious, and there is a flavor for everyone! The owners are super nice and generous, too!“

“Rita's Ice Cream is a delightful treat that truly hits the spot on a hot summer day! The selection of flavors is fantastic, and each one is packed with creamy goodness. I particularly loved their unique Italian ice, which offered a refreshing burst of fruity flavors. The service was friendly and efficient, making the overall experience even better. Whether you're a fan of classic favorites or adventurous tastes, Rita's Ice Cream is a must-visit for any ice cream lover. Highly recommended! ??“

“Very nice staff and great ice cream. They made some changes to the parking area which definitely helped with flow of traffic. Love going here on the odd weekday night when I get a craving for ice cream. The ice cream cakes are great! They will Also add a message to them for free.“

“I LOVE this place. The atmosphere is amazing, people are super nice, and the food is amazing. I've had both sweet and savory crepes made by them. Highly recommend.“

“Our go to for ice cream! Always wonderful service“

“Delicious beignets and great selection of drinks. Love the atmosphere“

“My favorite place to stop at on the lake for an ice-cream. We usually paddle up to the docks on our SUPs (stand up paddleboard). Grab a cone of real (Jefferson Dairy I believe) ice-cream and then back on the lack for some awesome paddling.
Highly recommended for a quick bite, all kinds of tchotchkes, signs, toys, games and a bunch of other stuff that I believe are locally made. It's a must visit, especially for those that want to revisit simpler times.“

“Great food , great service“

“I always stop when I'm in the area. Owners are truly grateful for their customers, and the servings are what you'd expect if not more. Only problem is the road noise if you want to sit at the tables.... but not much they can do about that“

“Last review posted is a lie! I was there! The doors were locked because it was after hours and the employees were serving the 2 parties (of 8ppl) that walked in while the store was open! Next time check the hours before hand, and know hours vary on holidays! You should be ashamed of yourself for lying!“