Custom Cakes near Mahwah, NJ

“Stopped in here on a whim.... the owner was lovely. I needed nothing, but got an almond croissant, a chocolate croissant, and a French baguette. everything was off the charts delicious. wonderful experience. I recommend calling ahead.“

“Placing a cake order with The Modern Cakery was the best decision I could have made. They listened to what I was looking for and not only offered wonderful ideas, they executed these flawlessly. The cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious!!! The birthday girl and guests were still talking about it days later! Thank you to The Modern Cakery! This customer will be a repeat one for sure!!“

“Walter is amazing! He makes the most delicious pizzas, cookies, and cupcakes. His cakes are beautiful and taste just as good as they look. On top of that, his personality is so sweet and welcoming. He’s definitely someone you’d want to order from again and again!“

“I had the Baileys Irish Cream flavor. So good. Nice place. Nice owners. Can taste any flavor before you decide what you want.“

“Rispoli Bakery is my absolute go-to for ALL occasions! Their desserts and pastries are always top-notch—beautifully crafted, incredibly delicious, and made with such artistry and care. The entire team is so professional, friendly, and an absolute pleasure to work with. When it came to catering my husband’s 40th birthday, there was no question—I knew Rispoli Bakery was the only choice! I was overwhelmed with so many event details and had no idea what kind of cake or dessert selection I wanted. Enter Rose—an absolute lifesaver! She guided me through the entire selection process, offering expert recommendations on flavors, quality, and variety. I sent over an inspiration photo for the cake, and when I saw the final result, I was speechless. Rispoli didn’t just match the photo—they far exceeded it! It was a true masterpiece, and I was so moved that I actually cried when I saw it (lol). The dessert spread was so impressive. Every single guest raved about how incredible everything tasted, constantly asking, “Where are these amazing desserts from?!” Thanks to Rose and the team’s thoughtful recommendations, every choice was a home run. I cannot say enough good things about Rose and the entire Rispoli Bakery family. Their talent, professionalism, and warm, welcoming nature make them a joy to work with. Thank you for making my husband’s birthday so special—you’ve gained a lifelong customer! ♡“

“Wow this lady can bake! I have know her for a few years now but didn't really know about her baking till recently. I thought I would be nice and supportive and buy a cake. BAM! Best cake I ever eat! Now I am trying to think up excuses to buy another.“

“Petal Dust Cakery is first rate from making my vision come to life through cake design to the easy ordering process and friendly assistance. Look at all these cakes below!! Each one was SPECTACULAR! All within the past month too. Amazing work and sooo delicious💖💖💖“

“I purchased a custom cupcake cake for my mom's 65th birthday party and I couldn't be happier with the cake and the whole process of working with David's Custom Cake. They went over every detail with me thoroughly, making sure the inspiration pictures I gave them were tailored to exactly what I wanted. They made payment and pick up very easy and were extremely friendly, caring, and professional. And the bonus- it was DELICIOUS! I recommend getting your cake here for any occasion! Thank you David's Custom Cakes!“

“Tried the USR location this morning as it's located around the corner from my office. Front staff was friendly, attentive, and helpful with assisting me to navigate options as a first time visitor. There was no line and I quickly received my to-go order. The ham, egg, and cheese croissant was delicious- fluffy and flaky, not at all greasy, and the perfect cheese pull. Can't wait to return to try desserts and coffee!“

“I e cream is great, nice building and atmosphere, rude pretentious staff. I came with a 2 year old, she needed a diaper change, they told me the restrooms were closed to customers and only for staff. I got my little girl her ice cream and a guy who appeared to be a manager told us to get out because they dont allow indoor seating. it's a shame because the ice cream is great and it's a great location“

“Ice cream 🍦 cakes are absolutely delicious 😋“

“An easy in & out bakery. No frills just amazing cakes, pies, & cupcakes. They are very accommodating... I just wish they were closer to my home! I drove 50 minutes for cakes for an office party. Well worth it, though! I've yet to be disappointed.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options available“

“This coldstone has been around for years! I recently moved back to the area and already visite twice. Everything is fresh and they are very generous with the toppings. I need to remember to sign up for the loyality program. An added bonus they are open till 10pm!“