Browse menus, reviews and photos of Custom Cakes near Mahwah.
Bakery · $
9 Miller Road, Mahwah
Customers’ favorites
“Stopped in here on a whim.... the owner was lovely. I needed nothing, but got an almond croissant, a chocolate croissant, and a French baguette. everything was off the charts delicious. wonderful experience. I recommend calling ahead.”
Custom Cakes · $
385 Kinderkamack Road, Oradell · 10.98 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The Modern Cakery is incredible! I found them on instagram looking for a bakery that makes detailed children’s birthday cakes. I placed an order for a Rapunzel themed cake, and they were very helpful with any questions I had as well as flexible with changes I made to the design. My daughter was in love with the cake, the quality was amazing, and everyone at her party was asking where we got her cake from. Not only that, the cake tasted amazing and was probably the best tasting cake I’ve ever eaten besides my own wedding cake. I would highly recommend them for any event that needs a cake, and plan to use them again for future birthdays!”
Custom Cakes · $
3 Veterans Parkway, Pearl River · 6.93 miles
Customers’ favorites
“love it! everything”
Bakery · $
1103 Goffle Rd, Hawthorne · 8.3 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I travel all the way from North Bergen to get my pastries. Rose is the best she’s always so kind and so nice. The Owner is amazing. Very nice people. The staff is amazing. Best desserts around.”
Ice Cream Shop · $
822 Franklin Avenue, Franklin Lakes · 5.7 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I had the Baileys Irish Cream flavor. So good. Nice place. Nice owners. Can taste any flavor before you decide what you want.”
Bakery · $
1237 Belmont Avenue, North Haledon · 8.97 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Thanks for my custom cake it looked amazing and was a HUGE Hit!”
Bakery · $
38 East Ridgewood Avenue, Ridgewood · 7.62 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Tried the USR location this morning as it's located around the corner from my office. Front staff was friendly, attentive, and helpful with assisting me to navigate options as a first time visitor. There was no line and I quickly received my to-go order. The ham, egg, and cheese croissant was delicious- fluffy and flaky, not at all greasy, and the perfect cheese pull. Can't wait to return to try desserts and coffee!”
Ice Cream Shop · $$
104-106 Franklin Avenue, Ridgewood · 7.58 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I e cream is great, nice building and atmosphere, rude pretentious staff. I came with a 2 year old, she needed a diaper change, they told me the restrooms were closed to customers and only for staff. I got my little girl her ice cream and a guy who appeared to be a manager told us to get out because they dont allow indoor seating. it's a shame because the ice cream is great and it's a great location”
Bakery · $$
5 Seeger Drive, Nanuet · 7.35 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I was searching around for a cake for a very special Birthday….. I remembered I used Carousel Cakes many years back when I owned my own business and we gave the cakes out for the holidays I spoke to jessica and she was very helpful and her communication with me was appreciated Great price Great experience Great communication Thank Again V”
Ice Cream Shop · $$
441 Broadway, Westwood · 8.83 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Very satisfied about my choice! Was ordered in store, the staff girl was straight forward with my order: showed interest in writing it down carefully, asked me all the questions on how I want my custom special occasion cake and at pickup, weeks later, all was as planned. Everyone loooved the icecream cake! I highly recommend!”
Ice Cream Shop · $
13 Kinderkamack Road, Emerson · 10.11 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Ice cream 🍦 cakes are absolutely delicious 😋”