Custom Cakes near Milltown, NJ

“I recently bought the Oreo Cookies & Cream Extreme ice cream cake from Cold Stone Creamery in Milltown for my husband’s birthday. He’s a huge fan of ice cream cake—I’m usually not—but this one was an absolute hit! It was so delicious that even I went back for seconds… and so did everyone else.

We brought it to a restaurant to celebrate, and even gave a slice to our waiter. He loved it so much he shared it with the kitchen staff, and they all went crazy over it—asking where we got it from. Safe to say, Cold Stone has some new fans!

Hands down the best $49 I’ve ever spent on a birthday cake. I highly recommend it for any celebration—you won’t regret it!“

“Amazing cakes!! Will definitely order again.“

“Very nice,friendly. Tasty flavors and many choices to choose from.“

“Had a last minute order of over 40+ cupcakes and the team did an amazing job making sure I got what I needed. The cake was SO moist. Would recommend. Ty, ladies!!“

“Urooj made my first visit to Cold Stone a great one. She explained the different ice cream flavors in detail and helped me choose something I’d really enjoy. You can tell she genuinely cares about making customers happy! her smile is very welcoming and kind ! Cold stone is lucky to have her“

“LaBon made my granddaughters first birthday cake that needed to be eggless due to allergies. What a beautiful cake and she loved it! Thank you so much for making her day special!“

“From price quote, to cake pickup, to eating I had a phenomenal experience. I splurged for my 30th birthday for a custom cake. La Bon was affordable for what I wanted which was amazing. Their staff was incredibly sweet, professional, and all around pleasant. And the cake? Oh my God. I couldn't ask for a better outcome. I provided a reference photo and the result was an exact match. Flavor wise? Impeccable. I don't know what it is about these cakes but it was hands down the best cake I've ever had in my life. It was decadent but not too sweet (especially with black frosting, I was pleasantly surprised), perfectly piped frosting, and perfectly light and flavorful strawberries and cream filling. I will 100% be trusting all my future cakes to la bon from now on!“

“Great apple cake and other European treats. Its like going back in time.“

“I ordered for pick up, a whipped cream vanilla cake with strawberry, banana, and vanilla custard filling and it was delicious. No crumbs left. The service, dry. The employee seemed bothered we ordered desserts from the display. I was excited because I love their products but it makes me second guess spending money there if it seems like the employees are bothered by you doing so.“

“OMG..Amelia & Rose Hot Chocolate Bombs are the ultimate treat!! There explode perfectly even in dairy free milk❤️ ..and the packaging is do beautiful.. They were a hit on Christmas 🎄 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Big portions and super fresh ice cream! Service staff rocks!“

“I love it here! The ice cream is always very fresh and the employees are always very kind, cleanly, and efficient. I live nearby so i’m always coming in with my family, and have been helped by an employee named Gabby many times. She is always very friendly and has a great attitude.“

“Beautiful caticorn cake created for my daughters 6th birthday. Delicious cake and icing beautifully decorated - just perfect for the occasion 😊“

“Beautiful custom made cake. Thank you guys for making my daughter’s birthday celebration sweeter with this awesomely made custom cake , which was delicious and really after sooo long time , had a cake with with no ultra processed ingredients.👌👍.“