The Pie Store
$$ • Bakery, BritishAbout The Pie Store
Customers' Favorites
Double Crust Raspberry-Blackberry-Apple Pie
Steak Ale & Mushroom Pie
Extra-Sharp Cheddar Scones
Chicken Madras Soccer Pie
Steak Ale & Mushroom Pie
Double Crust Apple Pie
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Turkey & Stuffing Pie
Chocolate Cream Pie
Bourbon Pumpkin Pie
The Pie Store Reviews
207 ratings
Share your opinion about The Pie Store
This is a true gem love this shop. Everything here is so delicious.
We're at The Pie Store to pick up a Chicken Tikka Masala pie and some scones. This is an absolute must-try for everyone.
One of Redds favorites.
We're at The Pie Store to pick up a Chicken Tikka Masala pie and some scones. This is an absolute must-try for everyone.
One of Redds favorites.
The British food is excellent and very authentic. It’s definitely a treat though, on the pricey side, so more of a special occasion or Christmas purchase rather than an everyday one.
Such a great little shop with amazing people! My husband and I made a pit stop at the shop for our Anniversary because he knows how much I love this place (haven’t been there for many years), and they were super sweet to us. The food is as good as it was 13 years ago!
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 3PM |
The Pie Store is a beloved destination for pie enthusiasts, offering a variety of sweet and savory options, including the popular Stake and Ale, key lime pie, and mince pie. This charming store also carries a selection of British goods and chocolates. While some customers have noted that the prices can be steep and the wait can be long, the excellent service and high-quality pies make it well worth a visit. The staff is courteous and accommodating, going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. The food is as good as it was years ago, with fresh, perfectly baked pies like the chicken pot pie and apple pie. The whole place has a pleasant vibe, though it's a pickup counter with friendly service, not a cozy sit-down spot. With its unique atmosphere and delicious treats, The Pie Store is a gem in the heart of Montclair.