3.7
Good
143 Reviews
23 Waverly Place, Madison · 6.59 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Taylor Ham and Cheese Bagel Sandwich
- Bagel with Cream Cheese
- Pastrami Egg and Cheese
- Half Dozen Bagels
“Had a great experience with Madison Bagel Cafe. This is exactly what you want from a local bagel spot—fresh, high-quality bagels with that perfect texture and flavor. I got the sausage, egg, and cheese bagel, and it was excellent—simple, classic, and done right. You can tell everything is made with care, and the consistency really stands out. The staff are friendly and efficient, and everything feels very well-run. The owner was also a pleasure to talk to, which added to the whole experience. The art on the wall adds a nice touch to the atmosphere and gives the place extra character. It has that classic neighborhood feel with lots of regulars coming in, which says a lot. If you’re looking for one of the best bagel spots in Madison NJ or the surrounding area, this is definitely worth checking out”