50 Best American Restaurants near Mountain Lakes

“I had been to Hapgoods many years ago for lunch and I found it very enjoyable. A few months ago we ordered dinner for a school fundraiser and we were pleasantly surprised. Our dinner out at the restaurant was fantastic. Our entrees were delicious and the service was excellent. The ambiance was wonderful. I can't wait to go back!“

“We found this gem when I was looking for someplace different to go. After our first time, we always go here for a special day. This time our anniversary. Food is excellent, always plenty of outstanding servers. The price is a little high, but well worth it.“

“My friend scheduled a "let's reconnect" meet up and he picked Paul's. I hadn't been there for years since we moved out of my Lakes. I remember they had Good good with excellent service but I have driven by hundreds of times and never stopped. Too bad because my Greek salad with chicken was a huge feast. The greens were fresh and crispy, the dressing (served on the side so you can add as much as you want) and the grilled chicken was done to perfection! My friend ate a vegi omelette and pronounced it very good. Overall, this was a great, classic diner experience. I awarded 4 stars since I don't do a 6 star "rave" on one visit but I'll come back and update after a dinner visit Lots of parking. Spotless and neat booth seating for us. A top of the profession very attentive waiter. BTW, I did the Yelp Elite thing, tipped on the card and then personally added a cash tip to the waiter with a compliment to the manager. Recommended for your next dinner meal. It will be mine.“

“We have dined at Chef Fredy's on several occasions. It never disappoints. From Beginning to end, we have always enjoyed our experience. The service is wonderful as is the food and food presentation. In addition, there is always such a welcoming feeling when you dine at Chef Fredy's. This is truly one of my favorite restaurants and we will definitely be back.“

“I don't know how many times I drove by Wood Stack on Rt 46 without paying any attention to it. Then a family party was held there and I was impressed. The food here is just good. Fresh, plenty of it, and served attractively. It has become one of our go-tos. I especially like the lunch menu - the eggplant sandwich and half salad is my regular order. The pizzas are excellent and the entrees generous and full of flavor. My husband's favorite thing is the chocolate chip cookie and milk dessert, served warm on a wooden board. Service is always consistent too. Great place to have here in town.“

“Nice little gem for brunch in the neighborhood few minutes drive from the Home Depot. A cute tiny house with parking all round it. Inside is cozy and the waitresses were super friendly and helpful despite how busy this place is. The food is great. They are not kidding when they said the corn hash was homemade, you know it is definitely not from a can. Everything just blended very well together. The rye bread that it comes with is also excellent (or maybe it's the salted butter they put on it). The Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwich was hot and fresh. My 5 year old would have eaten them whole thing if we did not order the fries. It is so fairly priced. The fries were $3.50, to put in perspective, a large fries from McDonald's costs $3.99. Our bill was about $30 with 2 coffees which they refilled several times. One of the best places for breakfast food, this place is a real deal.“

“Visited the Season 52 while traveling to Morris Plains, NJ for work. Went during happy hour which they have from 3-6pm, and the bar was full but they had high top seating open around the bar. The service was quick and the server was delightful. My food was well made and typically this comes with a risotto but I wanted just protein and veggies. It was seasoned well and cooked well too. I'm never disappointed in my time at Season 52.“

“We went last night with our friends for our Anniversaries, first time there, We were very pleased!!!!! Food was Delicious! Service was Awesome! And the atmosphere was warm & comforting We will be back!!!! Wish we knew about this place a lot sooner. I had the chicken Melanese ,which was absolutely out of this world. My husband had the whiskey burger which he loved. My girlfriend had the veggie burger which she loved, and her husband had the salmon which he enjoyed very much for appetizers. We had the Fried Calamari , which was very very good and very tender and the avocado toast, which was out of this world and I had the best white sangria I’ve had in a darn long time. ?????? it couldn’t have been any better. It was just perfect. Thank you. We will see you again.♥️ and our bill was not very high at all. The prices are good. Everything was perfect, the perfect place to celebrate our anniversaries.“

“Very nice place and an amazing food. The NY strip is really delicious, soft and creamy when you take at medium cook.The atmosphere is OK, but nothing impressive to make you and your family too excited.The staff serves very well with some kind of emphaty, but not happy as you want to be.Its not a chepeast price in Town, so, if you are getting there, there is a lot of types of food on the menu.“

“Carvers is our go to for breakfast. Staff is extremely friendly. The food always fresh and delicious. And the baked goods are unreal. They bake fresh bread pies and muffins daily. It makes me feel like I went to grandmas for breakfast. Big portions fresh food and mix matched coffee mugs. Oh and they make their own pancake mix that you can purchase to make your own. The best!Kid-friendliness: Great kid options. The chocolate chip pancake’s are always a hit with our kids“

“Hadn't eaten here in a little while. We really enjoyed the food and drink quite a bit! I love eating small plates and getting different tastes. Our favorites were the chicken and waffles, pulled pork sliders, shrimp and chicken specialty tacos and we ordered truffle fries (off menu) that were delicious. My boys don't love vegetables but they even liked the shaved Brussel sprout salad! We will definitely be back.“

“Wow, Knotty Pine is an absolute gem! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a cozy and rustic atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, making sure I had the best experience possible. The drink selection was impressive, with a wide variety of beers and signature cocktails that catered to every taste. The bartenders were true mixology wizards, creating unique and delicious concoctions that left me wanting more. They serve the most mouthwatering chicken wings I've ever tasted! The wings are perfectly crispy on the outside, and juicy and flavorful on the inside. They have a variety of sauces to choose from, ranging from mild to super spicy, so there's something for everyone. The portion sizes are generous, and the wings are always served piping hot. But what really sets pine apart is their attention to detail. The wings are always cooked to perfection, and the flavors are well-balanced and delicious. The staff is friendly and helpful, making the whole experience even better. Whether you're a chicken wing connoisseur or just a fan of good food, Wing Knotty pine is a must-try. Trust me, once you've had their wings, you'll be hooked! Knotty Pine is definitely a go-to spot for a night out with friends or a casual hangout. I can't wait to go back and explore more of what this amazing bar has to offer! Enjoy your chicken wing adventure, my friend!“

“I stopped in here for coffee and just had to try a beignet. They smelled amazing, and the one I got was hot, soft, and not overly sweet, despite the glaze. Good stuff! The shop itself has a good amount of seating, and the employee was nice. I'd try more beignets if I wasn't trying to lose weight, LOL.“

“Unique and delish. My amazing title person stopped by my office and brought there Homemade Potato Donuts called Spudnuts. The dulce de leche with sea salt was my favorite, but it’s super rich. The cinnamon sugar was a close second. You definitely can’t eat the whole donut since they are so large. They were warm and fresh when she brought them in. I have never been here but it’s definitely a fan favorite to most in Morristown. They also have breakfast sandwiches, pizza, burgers, gyro platter and a ton of other comfort foods. I haven’t stopped in, but based on the spundnuts I definitely will stop in soon!“

“My family and I had an amazing brunch experience at Agricola! We were a group of 10 people and were seated promptly. Our server, Elvis, was absolutely fantastic - attentive, friendly, and made great recommendations. The food and drinks were delicious across the board, with everyone in our group loving their orders. Standout dishes included the heavenly cinnamon roll, creamy burrata, flavorful mushroom pizza, indulgent carrot cake pancakes, and perfectly cooked flank steak & eggs. The ambiance was great for a relaxed Saturday brunch, and the portions were generous without sacrificing quality. Highly recommended for groups looking for a memorable brunch experience!“

“If you are an espresso martini lover like myself, you can't miss Stirling Tavern. I can't even count how many espresso martinis I have gotten here over the past couple of years I've visited the adorable Morristown. The bartenders are very consistent with the drink making and I have never had a bad drink here. The ambience in the bar area is very sophisticated and the seating in the front of the bar is the perfect spot. I've also tried some small plates too like the burger bites which I would like to be snacking on right now. The little sliders have goat cheese for a unique twist and really delicious sweet potato fries on the side. I've had both flatbreads too which are a good starter to share with friends and family.“

“Holy crow this place gets busy on a Sunday morning. Lots of kids and very noisy. It's IHOP...All is good nothing is awesome.Parking: It was a rainy day and parking was fine even with them being packed inside.Kid-friendliness: I don't have little ones anymore but there were so many kids its gotta be kid friendly“

“River of Beer does a great job supporting the NJ Craft Beer Brewers. I just wish those same brewers would take their companies offerings more serious and treat it like the incredibly difficult market they are in rather than treat it like a hobby. We have over 200 breweries and just a handful of ones that can compete in flavor with some of the better North East brewers. We need better tasting beer in our backyard.“

“What can I say. Have been a customer for many years nothing has changed but the year and date. Still the same Steak goodness Wedge Salads and French Onion Soup. Service is so on the money nothing less than perfect. The ambience is unique and original giving the feel of an old time classic place.“

“Absolutely amazing. If you are in the area, you need to go. The atmosphere is comforting and the service is wonderful. Their specials never disappoint and are super creative. They are great for pies during Thanksgiving, but you must go during St. Patrick's Day. Their specials for St. Patties are the best around. They have amazing breakfast and awesome cakes and pies for desert. Best breakfast around hands down.“

“Food was excellent, I had the special halibut over mashed potatoes with a lemon caper sauce. Large thick piece which was very soft and flaky literally melting in my mouth. Sauce was perfectly balanced and plentiful. Finished with coffee and desert, topped off with a complimentary shot of zambucca.It was quite loud which is the only thing I can criticize with the dinner. Cost was fairly high but considering the quality of our meals, it was a fair price.“

“Stopped in this morning at Pop's Place on Route 48 E. In Rockaway Township after hearing quite a few rave reviews. Cozy, old school style looking little roadside, classic style NJ eatery serving up a selection of Sabrett specialty hot dogs , sandwiches , burgers , grilled chicken boxes, spuds and rings, in addition to a mouth watering selection of your traditional New Jersey breakfast choices. Super fast and friendly service and immaculately clean, it was a family friendly joint to just sit, relax, and stuff your face with a variety of your favorite menu items, be it for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. I went with Pop's Breakfast Bomb. Taylor Ham (6 slices, beautifully charred), Sausage Patty, 2 Eggs, several slices of American Cheese, on a toasted Brioche Bun. WOW! This sandwich was as good as it sounds. Each bite was an explosion of flavor, and ample enough for two people. TeamTaylorNJ, if you haven't stopped by as of yet. Give it a try. Great stop, great food, nice people. Good luck and continued success. 03/30/2024“

“My whole family may have found their new favorite restaurant. You won’t find any food pics in this review because even my picky 10 year old finished her entire meal ! All our dishes were delicious. The restaurant is amazingly clean and decorated so nicely. Service was outstanding - I can’t emphasize how nice everyone there was. Must try location!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian options are not hard to findParking: There is no difficulty in finding parkingKid-friendliness: My picky ten year old was able to eat her entire meal!“

“Overall, solid choice and worth a visit if you're in the area. Typical bar scene with large television screens broadcasting a variety of major sports games, so it does tend to get rather loud inside. But also decently family friendly assuming you're ok with the large tv's around. Decent selection of drinks, and the happy hour specials are well worth the bang for your buck. I personally enjoy the LIT (Long Island), but the House Margarita Special is probably a better deal. Food is pretty much what you'd expect to find at a bar. Large menu so chances are you'll be able to find something that works for everyone. I'm a huge fan of the mozzarella sticks which was the star of the show for me. It is nice that they let you add onto sides for an extra charge. I've tried several of the entrees but nothing stands out. Overall quality is average across the board. Have not ventured into the dessert options here but they looked good for what it's worth, I'll have to give them a shot one time. My experience with service here has been mixed. On my most recent visit, they did very well apart from taking a long time to bring refills/check, but given how busy it gets on weekends it was understandable. However, I have had other times where my order has been messed up without an apology and were visibly upset that I asked for it to be fixed. Personally I prefer here over Tommy's but some may disagree.“

“Ordered grilled chicken avocado in a spinach wrap, and a side of avocado mango. The green mango was crunchy, lightly covered in avocado— a new taste for me I really liked. The wrap was wet enough (I hate dry wraps), the dressing a very subtle vinaigrette, I think; very subtle, meaning it was made with great care. The chicken — the whole sandwich was utterly delicious. I have never enjoyed turkey bacon so much. Friendly service, nice atmosphere. A thoroughly enjoyable lunch. I’ll come back, and I recommend it.“

“The food is great tastes amazing! I'm truly amazed at how catering and caring the owner and staff are. I love this place and come here all the time for good burger fries hotdogs and and chicken tenders and of course the Dover Dairy maid is right never door the ice cream is fantastic the service is great. The ambiance is definitely good old fashioned American food is family friendly you can eat out side they just opened today for the start of the season. So excited to go back again.“

“Diamond in the rough! I had a cheeseburger figuring it was a safe first shot at a new place. Best burger I’ve had in I don’t know how long. Good size double patty. Each patty would have been a good size burger on its own. Not like the places that basically take one decent size burger and split it in two to say it is a double.Good bun too. They branded it with a “D”… nice touch.Would definitely recommend and a definitely going back.Great job DooWoop EATS!“

“We went to the Creamery/Cafe for a late lunch at 1 O'clock today.Although their Eritrean menu says available by reservation 5 to 8 pm. we were able to order from the dinner menu.Service was prompt and very friendly.The Eritrean food was novel and delicious.Many, varied, interesting items to choose from.A pleasant contrast and relief from the usual hamburger, steak, pizza, sushi, etc. choices at most other restaurants in the Morristown area.“

“The food was also really good but oh my god wait until you try the coffee!! I got an iced espresso without sugar or milk and it was so good! I’ve had many of their other drinks and smoothies as well! They just knock it out of the park with their food, their smoothies, their juices, and the coffee.“

“Let me start off by saying I grew up in Philadelphia and ate cheesesteaks regularly ever since I was quite young. I know these folks here are known for their “best of NJ” Taylor Ham ;not pork roll ( almost forgot where I was) and cheese. I’ve had it here before and I do believe it is incredible and stands up to the claims. However… the cheesesteak they make here may not be getting enough love. You should consider it and understand that it could put up a fight with some of the best in Philly. 10/10. Would order again, and again … and again. Also, the guys here are great to chat with.“

“We come from Morristown for this gem! Drive over probably weekly with our 3 young children and are always impressed. Family friendly environment in dining room and they are all friendly and accommodating. Great kids menu and fantastic food/beer menu. It’s our favorite spot! Consistently good!“

“Been meaning to review Table 42 many times before. I have the honestly say, the food, the staff and environment are delicious, super friendly and very accomadating. The atmosphere was relaxing and the live musician was the perfect background. I've had apps, entrees and their thin crust pizza and would recommend every dish on the menu. Highly recommend this Dover NJ gem. Enjoy!Parking: Parking located behind restaurant“

“Food was outstanding per usual! Service was a bit choppy though. Busboy/back waiter was a bit strange in that he asked a few times if we were done with our meal despite us all having forks and knife's in our hands clearly still eating. And the time we were finished, he'd ask, we said yes, and then he walked away? Also, reservation notes were not met. I noted that my father was in a wheelchair and when we got to the table we had to ask for a chair to be removed. On top of that, asked for a high chair to be at the table in the notes for my niece and that wasn't there either. As someone who manages a restaurant in NYC, Oceana Restaurant - I'm the bar manager, I understand that sometimes there are off nights. I'm chalking it up to that, and we will be back for the great food.“

“I've always loved Fuddrucker's burgers but the location nearest to me closed and I come to this one every once in a while. Food is consistent but atmosphere is mediocre.Dietary restrictions: Wish there were more keto/gluten free options other than a burger without the bun.“

“The location is very easy to find and there is ample parking. The staff is very warm and welcoming and knowledgeable of the menu. There are plenty of places to sit and we didn’t have to wait to be seated. We had the huevos rancheros and the French toast, which were both amazing. They serve a local coffee called Lake born coffee, which was really good by itself and also as a cappuccino. I’ll be back to the rest of the menu!“

“I ordered Take Out two nights in a row. The first night, an order of fries was missing. The manager brought them out in under a minute. The second night the order was perfect. The Take Out containers are great. This location has convenient Take Out parking with a dedicated Take Out entrance. Really nice. Great staff.“

“I've driven by a million times and have always been curious. What a pleasant and delicious suprise it was when i finally visited this fine establishment. The owner and staff were very attentive in making everything just right(eventhough we walked in 15 minutes before closing). I had the Rubén and my wife had the chicken salad and a soup- all made perfectly and soup was "grandmother approved"!!! Highly recommend!!!“

“Had a great time here with friends. Good food, fantastic service, and a nice table to chat away the night. Didn't get to take any pictures, but it's basically a pub style with plenty of tables right on the main street in Pompton Lakes. We hadn't been in this area for a LONG time. We went around the corner and there was St Mary's church where we got married 41 years ago last week!!!“

“HIDDEN GEM. We were a party of 4 and came from 45 minutes away. The place is a bit smaller, but that didn’t take away from the amazing experience we all had. The waiter, who has worked there for over 17 years, was exceptional. He was friendly and funny and we all had an excellent time with him. The food was perfect. Everything we ordered came out perfect. It was all hot and it was all very delicious. I would highly recommend the pancakes. We will for sure be back again and again.“

“Looks like a very regular Chinese takeout at first glance, but that’s where it stops. Food here is so good. Not the greasy, soggy basic, Chinese takeout you’d expect. Food tastes super fresh and the prices are very reasonable. I’ll definitely be back!“

“The Smoke Rise inn is the neighborhood's best kept secret This charming building has as much history as it does ambiance It is believed to be a private establishment due to it being behind the Smoke rise community gates but it is open to the public When you walk into the bar area you can't help feeling like you are walking into the tv show cheers Everyone does know your name or will by the time you leave The staff and the usual patrons are extremely friendly and love meeting new folks The bar room is charming with stone and wood walls and a cozy fireplace on the upper seating area There is dining in the gazebo room which is equally as lovely and a bit quieter The food is delicious and the drinks are quite generous The Inn can also accommodate weddings in their ballroom or private parties So if you haven't checked out this fabulous eatery come drop in but make sure you make a reservation on the weekend“

“My dad and I stopped at this bar randomly in NJ. We are not local to the area, but we were grabbing food on the way out, of our day trip.It was spontaneous and a nice find! It was festive for the holiday - the Santa seat covers were a nice touch. The bathroom had sticky notes all over it — which I thought was cool/different — positive vibes! Our waitress was nice and pretty. Food was delicious!Simple menu and good prices.“

“We catered our son's first birthday party with American BBQ and we received SO many compliments about how delicious the food was! The delivery/setup was prompt and super quick! I had numerous email exchanges with Roberta going back and forth with ideas and she was absolutely wonderful to work with! Highly recommend!!“

“Last year: Good food, great service, and a comfortable atmosphere. Great find!A year later, I was in the area and went back. It was once again really good.If you are looking for a comfortable atmosphere and food that is straightforward, hearty and good, then I highly recomend Charlotte's Web.“

“I’ve been to a lot of pubs on the east coast, but this one is special. Authentic pieces of Ireland inside and the atmosphere puts you setting in a pub in Dublin.Great place and staff. Food was fresh and served proper. We had the Rusty Irishman drink “ like an old fashioned” and came back a second day to enjoy another round. Great place to rest up and enjoy the east coast before headed into the city. I would recommend a stop and rest over.“

“The Second Half On Main exceeded my expectations in every way. From the delicious food to the incredibly friendly staff, every aspect of my experience was delightful. The portions were generous, and the prices were surprisingly affordable considering the quality of the food. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a satisfying meal in a welcoming atmosphere.“

“Stopped in this establishment. After I looked up dive bar.(That's what I like). the place didn't disappoint. I meet a few locals (all friendly) started talking sports and felt right at home.. Then owner came out with some kabasi with sour krout also some great hot mustard.. awesome !!!!.. if you are looking to just chill this might be a place for you..“

“This is a decent spot. We dined here with another couple on a busy Saturday night. It's a small space but well designed with mostly attentive service. For me, the standouts were the appetizers. We shared the chicken lollipops and pork belly. The chicken was so crispy and flavorful! We tried the arctic char and short ribs as entrees. Both were good but I wouldn't say exceptional or standout. I did thoroughly enjoy the grits that came with the short ribs. We also all split the earl grey tea tiramisu. It sounded interesting and innovative but missed the spot for us! It really did not feel like a tiramisu. I think I would have been more into it if it was called something else! It was tasty but unexpected given the name.“

“Ya know... I'm not here for the pizza. Sure, I'm definitely here for the wings challenge and you can see that I'm not one to lose a food challenge (:, but I can also tell you those were some of the most delicious wings I've ever ingested. Nice and smoky. Slow burn. So well done. I got myself a falafel platter to go and... waiting for the newspaper to interview the FIRST EVER WINGS CONTEST WINNER I ended up dining in. Homemade rice and falafel. Quality. Such friendly people, such fun. Plenty of room here. So I'm gonna go with this is a win for Middle Eastern in Boonton... and if they ever want to make a pizza with this hot sauce........“

“The food is just so amazing. My family and I go here for breakfast even though it’s out of our way. The service and staff is the best. Get there early or risk waiting, because everyone who go there once knows that Sweet Basil is the best.“