50 Best Mexican Restaurants near New Milford

“we’ve gone for the past two years to celebrate my friend’s birthday. They never let us down“

“Comida deliciosa y servicio excelente.“

“El concepto es muy padre y bonito. Me sentí en México por un momento. El sabor de la comida excelente. Pero mi mesera me descuidó y nunca me preguntó cómo estaba todo, nunca pasó a preguntar si ocupaba algo. No se ganó la propina, pero ya me la cobraron en la cuenta.“

“My husband and I recently had dinner at Cantina 46, and we were thoroughly impressed. Everything we ordered was delicious. We enjoyed the skirt steak with shrimp, lamb chops, and guacamole, paired with tamarind and guava mojitos. The atmosphere was very pleasant, enhanced by a live singer. I would definitely visit Cantina 46 again.

Parking: Valet parking is available at this location.“

“😍 I Love ❤️ their chicken and steak 🥩 tacos 🌮 and their Melanesa steak 🥩 sandwich 🥪 🥰❤️“

“ABSOLUTELY AMAZING ALL AROUND!!!
Such incredible food and drinks. Staff are friendly and knowledgeable. The Pozole was amazing. We sat at the kitchen bar and watching the chefs execute each dish was absolute food porn. RECOMMEND!!!!!“

“My first time eating here! The horchata is the best I've ever had! I’m now able to differentiate between authentic Horchata and mid horchata thanks to this restaurant! This is a small restaurant but so festive and beautiful! They cooked the food with love. Me and my wife had the Birria Pizza. The meat was cooked well and the pizza stood in tact.“

“When to celebrate a birthday with family. We had great time! We chose the Sunday's brunch menu, trully recomemded it for a large group. Drinks and food were really good. The host did a great job and we got tequila's shots on the house from the manager :)! Everyone loved the new theme of the restaurant. We will come back for sure!“

“I like their food and service.
A group of young men putting the work. The place is nice and clean, their food is very good. Those guys really tried. I used to order online, today I decided to walk in eventhough it took them a lil time to have my order ready once served I was very pleased with the food. 10 out of 10z.

Athmosphere, could be a little better.“

“Great meal - drinks extraordinary. Definitely coming back.“

“Really nice place, good atmosphere, and great food. Honestly the hospitality was absolutely beautiful and the care for customers was on top. Very clean and tidy place as well. Food was amazing, authentic, and of course zabiha halal certified.“

“I love this place. The food is good, as is the service. There's not much in the way of ambiance, but it's clean and gray for quick takeout. Gina is always super sweet!

Parking: There's a large skated parking lot.“

“Excellent places , if you want to have at great time with family or friends , great atmosphere , great food , great drinks , great staff , ty Gretel will highly recommended to everyone #new sherif in town 🙏🏼“

“Delicious, authentic, homemade food.“

“Un lugar muy hermoso 🤩 y encantador ☺️“

“I pass this place often in my travels so I finally decided to give it a try. Initially when I walked in and saw the prices of everything I almost walked out because everything seemed overpriced. But I figured since I was already there I may as well give it a try. And thank God I did The food and service were amazing and made my trip and the money worth it.“

“Nice bright location atmosphere is vibrant all halal food . You must try all the tacos the birria ones are to die for have not tried any of the burritos I'm sure they are great as all their dishes they serve.

Dietary restrictions: All food served is halal“

“Had the pleasure of dining here over the weekend. Lets start with the ambiance, perfectly lit warm and inviting. The service was impeccable from the host to our server everyone knowledgeable, friendly and engaging. Now to the food, arguably some of the best Oaxacan cuisine I have tasted outside of Mexico. The crudo was so fresh and vibrant the short rib memela was one of the best dishes I have had in a very long time. Everything was fresh and tasty. Thanks to everyone who made this meal such an amazing experience. Truly looking forward to my next visit!!!“

“Comida súper autentica, deliciosa, sabrosa y los precios súper accesibles! 100% recomendado“

“I looked up what foods in the area were top rated and this little restaurant popped up. So I went for a try. Got the steak nachos and WOW. Everything taste fresh and even the chip were crispy fresh and taste homemade. The crema, beans, steak well seasoned, guacamole all paired wonderfully and perfect portions of each. I hate getting nachos with 80% chips, 10% beans and barely any protein. This place knows exactly what they’re doing and I can’t wait to try other stuff on their menu. Also it’s a very small restaurant with limited seating. I took my food to-go and it was well packaged and hot.“

“Super amazing what highly recommend the Ramen was my most favorite place in the churros were amazing with the caramel dip. I feel like other people should go to this place too and I feel like this is just the best restaurant I ever been in New York City.“

“Great atmosphere, friendly service and interesting menu offering plenty of delicious options. We will be back for sure!“

“💥💥💥💥💥 Just discovered a gem! Can’t wait to return. Tucked in on Columbus Av. betw 106/107. Best Mexican food I’ve yet to find in the city. I had the fish tacos! Excellente! Also the best sangria. Our server, Carol, was wonderful. And she gave me a delicious flan desert and everyone sang happy birthday. Thank you Carol and everyone! See you soon!“

“Ordered via uber eats tonight . I've wanted to try for awhile (since I did a delivery for Feed the Frontlines) and I wasn't disappointed! We shared several items and they were all yummy! I will definitely order again.“

“first time here very impressed the food was too perfection will be back with more people“

“Loved this spot! Great food and service!“

“Came in here today at random and got a green smoothie and a chicken pastelito. 10 across the board. Workers here are super friendly, place is clean and smells good and the food is amazing! Love they made my juice natural and the chicken in the pastelito is so good and moist.“

“I love this place! The staff is so friendly and accommodating. Brett the server is the best!! He it's attentive, patient, kind, fast with taking and bringing the orders and he checks to see if the order is satisfactory and if anything else is needed. I appreciate this kind of service especially after a hard day at work. Also, my friends and family members have expressed great gratitude for being treated so well. The food prices can't be beat, the quality and quantity is great, well worth every penny. The friendly and happy atmosphere is very welcoming and enjoyable. I feel at home here. I highly recommend Chevy's in Clifton to everyone I know. Thank you so much for all the hard work and dedication to providing excellent customer service and delicious food!! Love it.“

“So this place opened up less than a year ago.Me and my husband have definitely been here at least 4x ... Let's start with the bartender ( same guy every time) his personality is absolutely amazing.The whole atmosphere is insane.Lee literally like a breath out of the Bronx for a minute... I can't stress their shrimp tacos enough... it is my ultimate favorite but I also had prime rib taco's last time & beyond ?... Me and my husband have date night at least 2x weekly & if you want an intimate atmosphere that's décor is beautifu. l.Music is mexican music which is very fitting but know this "you're gonna spend money" for 2 ppl a shot and a Margarita each then an entree. y appetizer is gonna.
Cost you around $200 and it's worth it every time!!!“

“This place is absolutely one of my favorites. Food is yummy no matter what you order, I recommend the corn soup 😋, tacos, the Sangria is delicious. Friendly staff and the place is very clean and affordable. 5 🌟 from me. Great place for friends, business or family!“

“Me and my daughter, enjoyed this restaurant so much during our Mommy and Me weekend! The atmosphere was laid back and quite relaxing. The service was superb and the food was so good, we had to order food to bring home. I would give this establishment 6 stars if I could. We were both very pleased and we will be dining here again very soon. If you have not been here, you should definitely give them a visit. Peace and Love, Chele from the Block.“

“A lot of thought and time went into designing this beautiful, spacious interior, including textured wall surfaces and designer lighting. Perfect for parties and couples alike, and kid froendly during the day with fancy mocktails. Take pride in hand crafted cocktails with freshly squeezed lime and yes they really look like the photo. Accommodating of allergies. Lots of flavor and great presentation“

“We had a wonderful anniversary celebration with friends at Uno Mas Saturday night. Delicious food, great service, and super friendly vibe!“

“This is the most authentic Mexican food in Bergen County. Every dish Ive tried is excellent.“

“Oh my gosh! I asked the young man who works at the record store up the street, where I could get some great food. He named a few of his favs but the way he spoke of this spot, peaked my curiosity.

I walked down there and walked inside. Right away, I knew I was in for a treat. The decor - Nacho Libre is all over the walls, as tastefully done as could be. The ambiance was great you could sit further inside or closer to the windows for a more outdoor feel. The customer service was friendly and kind. I felt welcomed and appreciated, right away and throughout my meal which was mexican street corn and chicken enchilada. Delicious, delicious. Take yourself and some family/friends. Enjoy! Thank you everybody at Taqueria Nacho Libre! Very well done.“

“I needed a quick lunch, so I tried this place. I had a chorizo taco and a tinga de pollo quesadilla. The taco was awesome! The sausage was cut into tiny cubes and grilled, not soaked in oil and grease like some places. And the tinga was excellent, not dry, and had that great tangy flavor I love. Everything was fresh, and the prices were very reasonable. If I'm in the neighborhood again, I'll definitely go back.“

“Highly recommend the birria tacos 🌮“

“The reviews I read to this restaurant really fooled me. The food served here did not taste fresh. Don't get me started on their drinks, more like ice. If you love spending money on bad food and iced drinks then this is the place for you. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone“

“Excellent food. Three of us tried a new appetizer for the first time... Corn on the cob and rolled in queso... It was delicious! Then we ate quesadillas, nachos and taco... All delightful and recommended. Try this place, you'll love it!“

“Food and service is AMAZING! You NEED to try this place out! Will be coming back more often to try out every item on the menu 😋“

“The serving staff was courteous and considerate.I came with my elderly mom. They made accommodations for her as soon as she walked in, even giving her a straw for her drink. The background music was delightful, Julio to Santana. And the food yumyum. The tacos were inexpensive yet mouth watering. I had pulled pork. My mom had pulled beef which she could chew easily so U know it was buttery good .The bartenders are delightful.I give 5 stars across the board. Did I mention the easy location and backyard garden!The photos were taken mid-meal I went during happy hour.“

“Waoooooo!!!!
We ordered a combo of tacos and a combo of birria mulitas, the food was super delicious, we loved it.
The person who served us was very friendly, the place was clean, there were two tables under a tent where we could eat.
The wait time was short considering that there were several people who had already ordered before us.
Very good size of the taquitos and mulitas in relation to their cost.
Recommended 100%“

“Genuinely the best Mexican food I’ve had in Westchester, maybe even New York. And that’s saying something from native Californians! Tortillas and ingredients were very fresh and authentic. Prices were beyond reasonable. We’ll definitely be regular customers!“

“excelente lugar para compartir en familia chicharrón el payaso mago 732 621 9305“

“Food is super fresh and the owner is so nice and you can tell he takes pride in his food. Never had baliada before Mi Sabor and definitely a fan!“

“Absolutely love this place great Mexican food and very decent prices the restaurant is always so cold but the loook inside the restaurant is pretty cool lots of decorations is a small place never have had a problem with service here however parking is very very difficult and I mostly take take out because of parking issues“

“Every time we dine at El Kallejon we are delighted with exquisite botanas from Mexico. The cocktails are great and the desserts too. The ambience is very cozy and decorated with art and colors from different places of Mexico. You can enjoy dinner with your friends and family. My son enjoys eating shrimp tacos, chilaquiles and churros. I enjoyed as well every signature dish and every artisan craft cocktail from El Kallejon. Also, El Kallejon hosts every year a Day of the Death Event where you can celebrate this tradition with music and folk dance. El Kallejon is a piece of Mexico in East Harlem. Nestor, chef, and owner is friendly and humorous. He describes his passion for his culture, food, music and traditions. Visit el Kallejon in East Harlem.“

“Food was excellent. Everything that I had was great. Flounder, was fantastic. Great place to eat good service fantastic atmosphere.“

“💖Always a delight to eat in a Cozy restaurant with fresh homemade food.“

“It was a great food , drinks and very friendly people . We’re very happy to met everybody .“