48 Best Pizza Restaurants near Peapack

“Delicious food and nice staff. The food is fantastic, from pizza to salads. I love their breaded chicken pizza but recently I have been obsessed with their classic mushroom and onion pizza. This place is a great choice you if are in the Gladstone or even the Basking Ridge area, where they opened another location. Definitely my go-to spot for pizza takeout.

Now for my standard comments. Location is clean and well kept. A classic pizza joint with a handful of tables to sit at.“

“Everything we have ordered from DaNapolis has been excellent...pizza, Chicken Francese, Shrimp Scampi, etc., everything is perfect. By far the best in the area.“

“This is our GO-TO place for catering when we have parties. They are so accommodating, they can make anything on or off the menu, great pricing, and they are truly appreciative for the business! Every single time we order, our guests RAVE about the food. We went out on a limb and ordered a large cheesesteak Stromboli last night and people couldn’t stop eating it. HIGHLY recommend!“

“Haven’t been in 30 years but just as excellent as it was back in high school. Fantastic pizza! Wish I lived closer“

“If you want the best Pizza in NJ this is the place. #1, they are the nicest people. #2 I drive from PA to eat here, use to work in the area, and lived in NJ for 31 years. #3 the pizza is just amazing. #4 everything they make is delicious and amazing. #5 you will not at all be disappointed in your decision to get food from here and you will keep coming back to this amazing place. This is the definition of how a restaurant and business should operate and run. They actually care about their customers here and are just truly great people that make amazing food! I ate here for 6 years while working in the area and like I said I drive from PA to come back. Thank you Sorellas for your delicious food and top notch customer service!“

“best food in Chester hands down! I recommend this place to everybody“

“Thank you Sapori for the amazing food you made for my family Father's Day party! The Baked ziti was so cheesy good, the green salad fresh & crisp, bruschetta was crunchy & lots of topping, & shrimp scampi garlic yum! the service was so friendly! Many Blessings to your family from Ken & JoAnne Betz xo“

“The best of the best!! You won’t be disappointed, and you won’t find better than Mangia Bella 🍕“

“Absolutely amazing experience there, went with my friends and overall everything was amazing. We ordered the garlic knots and there was 6 of us and only 6 garlic knots in the portion, our server who was the kindest ever gave us extra 🥺. Literally had the BEST service there I am not sure what the workers name is but whoever served us today I love you your the best!! He even took photos of us and the music there was so good. I really liked this one song that played and I said it out loud, im not sure if someone heard me but it played again and i was so happy!! Infact i am listening to it right now so thank you for playing that music. Okay so on top of the amazing service the food was astonishing. My friends and I got three pizzas including the pesto white sauce, caprese salad, and vodka sauce and they were all soooo good. Emphasis on the vodka sauce one that was amazing. So the environent was also really nice , I went to the bathroom and it was so clean, smelt good, and even cutely decorated. One another amazing thing is it was SO cheap! $68 for 6 people, thats actually insane. If you are in town please go here they willl NOT dissapoint! Its also a 10 minute walk from the center town of Bernardsville so amazing location to!“

“I recently visited JOES PIZZA and had an absolutely fantastic experience! From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. The staff was friendly and attentive, making us feel right at home. The pizza? Simply amazing. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy inside—exactly what you want in a pizza. I tried their signature EGGPLANT PIZZA, and the combination of fresh ingredients and bold flavors was a delightful surprise. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and everything tasted so fresh. What really stood out was the variety of toppings and unique combinations. There’s something for everyone, whether you’re into classic Margherita or prefer something more adventurous. And don’t even get me started on their homemade sauces—wow! The portions were generous, and the prices were more than reasonable for the quality you get. I’ll definitely be back soon to try more from their menu. If you're in the area and craving delicious pizza,“

“This HAD to be one of the best pizza I had in a long time. Rumors have it in the pizza world, is you ever wanna try a places best pizza always order a personal pie, that will tell you how they really are. So I ordered a personal Mushroom, Plain and a specialty one. Let me tell you this, IF you like a good crunch pizza..... On every bite.... Good flavor that stands tall..... This is the place to go.... ABSOLUTELY, so far, one of the best around.... This hole in a wall will surprise the s#$& out of you. Next time I will go for a full size pie and tell you how that goes....It will be interesting... I have been in places where I love there personal size and didn't like there full size....and let me add..... It was so good that I ate the personal Mushroom before I got home and I love down the road in Morristown... That's how good this wasI AM TELLING YOU if you like a crunch to your pizza, and you eat the whole slice.... This places personal pie is just for you....The two guys behind the counter was extremely nice... One had to be the owner, a bigger guy great personality and knew his stuff.... And the counter guy was just as nice and eager to help....So I have no dog in this fight.... Did I get lucky, maybe maybe not.... I will go back and order the large and definitely a person for the ride home.... It will be interesting.... But this is a true review.... Thanks to the guys who made the pies....“

“I tried buffalo chicken and chicken parmesan and both slices were flavorful and had the crispy crust. The restaurant had a nice Italian vibe and the service was friendly. Overall, I'd give it 4 out of 5 stars. It's kinda worth it if you're looking for a good pizza restaurant in the area.“

“Came in with a party of 12, food was fantastic and waitresses were attentive and friendly! It was a great dinner.“

“Pizza was amazing and calamari was out of this world“

“Just had the BEST grad party here, with wonderful food, and lovely staff! Will be back soon!“

“Came here on a Saturday afternoon and shared a 12inch roni pie and a cheesteak with a friend. It was delivered to the table after we ordered it at the counter. It was good. Staff is accommodating to additional requests after food is brought to the table, i.e. silverware, condiments, drinks, glasses. Would definitely return solo or with friends, perhaps with a bottle of 🍷 to enhance the experience.“

“As an Italian New Jersey native, I can confidently say Café Figaro serves some of the best pizza in the state. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the staff always treats me like family when I return from college. Having made pizza from scratch at the Jersey Shore for years, I can assure you—you won’t be disappointed.“

“Great food, family friendly dining. Love this local treasure“

“Not only serving delicious creative pizza, but they use ONLY the healthiest cooking oils! Do NOT eat any pizza using Vegetable/ Soybean chemically-altered cooking oil, or any “seed-oils” in general.“

“DELISH! I ordered a full tray of chicken Parm and of baked ziti. My family devoured everything and asked to take a dish home. Very generous servings and delicious. The phone order was soooo nice and the delivery was timely. I would recommend for your next catering need.“

“Best pizza in Morris County - Great staff and great food“

“This pizza 🍕 is thin crust, fresh, and cooked to perfection. The two gentleman who cook are very friendly and manage the place great.“

“Fantastic couple who owns and operates the restaurant. Love the base red sauce flavor, warning though that it’s on the sweeter side.

Great pizza. Wife loves the penne vodka.

They also make Italian desserts for the holidays for takeout sale.“

“Best pizza around ! Friendly staff/Good prices“

“My boyfriend and I visited from out of town. We really enjoyed their pizza. Our favorite was the buffalo chicken and bbq chicken pizza. The men in there were friendly. We'd go back. :)“

“A Hidden Gem for Unique Pizza Lovers
If you're looking for something out of the ordinary in the pizza world, Panatieri's is the place to be. They show their creativity and willingness to experiment with unique flavor combinations.
From the mac and cheese pizza to the various vegetarian options, it's clear that Panatieri's isn't afraid to step outside the box. The quality of the ingredients and the presentation of the pizzas look top-notch.
If you're in the area and looking for a memorable pizza experience, I highly recommend giving Panatieri's a try. Just be prepared to step outside your comfort zone and explore some exciting new flavors!“

“Luna Rossa’s food is absolutely wonderful!“

“Would dine here again, great food, great atmosphere“

“We absolutely love Prima! The staff and pizza are the best!“

“Tried this pizza place as we moved to Bridgewater lately and was quite amazed to see the options available here. It’s like a subway of pizzas. We ordered 3 pizza with all individual toppings choice. The crust is quite thin and tasty. We enjoyed the whole ambience and the sitting area is clean. They have outdoor seating also.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes this place is quite accessible.“

“I never give five stars for anything, as five star would be perfection. Guess what, this is the best Italian food I have had outside of Italy. Produce is obviously fresh and high standard. I'm a bit of a foodie, and I've eaten in some expensive restaurants that don't have food as good as this. I won't go anywhere else.“

“Excellent food! Friendly atmosphere as well?“

“Frank’s is the best pizza place around! Their food is always so fresh and the waitstaff is great. Would highly recommend to anyone in the area!“

“My husband is on a salt-free diet. They cook his food special for him without salt! Have loved this restaurant for many years.“

“Nick and family are amazing. I've been getting pizza, pasta, salad, and sides from Roman's pizza for years now. Always ALWAYS GOOD food, always delivered on time with a smile, always super tasty. Their pizza and pasta is really great but pro tip, their salad is always super fresh!! Also try their wings, ugh so good. Thank you guys, will continue to order from you for years and years. You are the best!“

“Really great slice. I started visiting Chester 25 years ago as a young kid. The thinner than average crust at Bella's stood out to me even then, but still feels true to NJ Style pizza which I strictly classify and golden brown and crispy crust/bottom which achieves those wonderful golden brown micro bubbles. I'm normally skeptical of pizza joints which use a mesh tray to cook, however this place is quite the exception. The mesh tray might be their secret to that really awesome bake on their crust.“

“amazing food and the best customer service ever! outstanding plates.“

“i love the pizza and pasta“

“I can’t say one bad thing about this restaurant - the food, the service, even the greeting at the front door was all great. As soon as my friends and I walked in we felt comfortable. We shared eggplant rollatini and bruschetta to start, and each had pasta dishes (chicken parm & lasagna) for our main entrees. We each brought half our dinners home so we could share a dessert :) which was also wonderful (fresh baked chocolate chip cookie in a cast iron pan with ice cream). We WILL be back. This place is a gem!“

“They are usually on point with the service they provide and the pizza they make. I called and ordered a well done plain pie ahead of time for pick up.. when I arrived, it quickly became apparent that they forgot about me.. meanwhile, they have an entire fresh pie that just came out of the oven, and instead of offering me the pie, they cut it up for two slices for a different customer and made me wait 20+ minutes to make what they forgot! I will say that I frequent this shop and will continue to do so but I hope you take this criticism and make adjustments if that should ever happen again. Your pizza Is cromulent“

“A family-owned pizzeria. Love the place. People are warm and accommodating. Place is clean and organized. Ample space between table. Accepts credit/debit. Has an indoor and outdoor dining. Food is delicious, recommended. High chairs available. Pizza by slice available. See images for some reference.“

“Excellent food and service. Our staff holiday luncheon has been held there for years. The staff gets a choice - and their choice every years is to continue to go there!“

“We were there for my daughters birthday this past Saturday. My wife and my daughter's boyfriend had the seared salmon which they loved. My daughter had the chicken parm, which she said was good. Her only "complaint" was that the sauce was a bit too sweet for her taste, but the portion was good and the chicken was cooked well. My son enjoyed his pepperoni pizza. He's not very adventerous. I had the Capellini Napoletani. It was very good. The capellini was cooked perfectly for my taste as was the shrimp, clams and calamari. Very tender. The sauce was great. This is our go-to for great food and is my wife's favorite. She is returning with coworkers for lunch on Tuesday. Service is top notch. Keep up the good work. We'll definately be returning.“

“Fabulous food. Honestly don’t think there are many restaurants who can beat the food quality. If you haven’t tried it, you should.“

“Food was amazing … Fast and delicious“

“Was there for the first time last night, what a wonderful experience! The service was great, Franchesca was very friendly and attentive and the food was absolutely delicious. One of the best Italian food I’ve ever had. If you are looking for great food and service, definitely visit this place!“

“Amazing experience. Variety and total meal solutions. Love the overall selection and service.“

“Stopped in by accident and discovered a goldmine. Driving home to Connecticut, I exited 287 to take a break from rush hour. Nothing like a Buffalo pizza to calm the nerves. I was greeted by a friendly host. I requested a seat at a high top in the bar area , so I could people watch and glance at the game on one of the many tvs. I had a great server , his name was Todd. He explained the menu and walked me through the various pizza selections. He not only knew the menu , he was excited discussing the food. I ordered a Buffalo Pie, it was unbelievable. I wish I saved room for dessert , because the choices seemed so delicious. Next time I’m going through town I will definitely come back“