50 Best American Restaurants near Pennington

“Wildflowers II recently catered an event for me and my family. The quality and amount of food was outstanding! Everything was super delicious and the owner, Jacqui, was super helpful in planning a menu to satisfy everyone pallet from great meat dishes to the penne vodka which was the hit of food selections. I've also eaten at the restaurant and cooks and staff are wonderful. Great place near Pennington Circle and easy to get to as it right off I95. Thank You Jacqui and Staff for everything!!! 🥰🥗🍝🍽“

“Atmosphere/Ambience/Attention to detail: Welcoming & beautiful. Linen tablecloths and napkins are classy. Popovers served at the beginning of one’s meal…Classic & Classy. House Manager monitoring the floor speaks of days gone by…unfortunately. A “Fine Dining” establishment should necessarily have such a person present. Food: Good to Very Good. Service: Exceptional on 5/8/25 (Carey ?). Noise Level: Deafening due to vaulted ceiling and tables being so close together. Lacks privacy. You’re part of your neighbor’s conversation whether you want to be…or not. Overall: By far one of, if not The Best Restaurant in the area. If only they could work on the acoustics. Will try different times in the future. *JQ“

“I am very pleased every time I’ve come here in the last few months. We get seated right away and the food comes out pretty quickly. However, the five stars really goes for the people that work there. They are so friendly which is saying much now a days in the restaurant industry. They have a great attitude, very respectful and just seem to enjoy working together. Keep it Hamilton Applebees team!!!“

“Great breakfast and friendly staff.“

“Quite simply The Blue Bottle has the best cuisine of any restaurant in the area that I live. And there are quite a few good ones. The only problem I have with them most often is getting a reservation on the weekend. I also have a problem managing culinary heat [a physical rather than a gastronomic one] and I wish I could tolerate more of it in some of their creations. I really recommend the place.“

“What a great local restaurant in Lawrenceville NJ. Service, atmosphere and especially the food were outstanding. The scallops risotto and Griggstown Brick Chicken were absolutely delicious. You won’t go wrong giving Acacia a try.“

“Great, relaxed lunch with DELICIOUS sandwiches/home-made bread...and let's talk about the desserts! What a great spot.“

“Best staff and fresh food!“

“I don't want to bash a business especially since my feedback is specific to me being a vegetarian but last night's dinner was a disappointment (the only time I've been disappointed at Bowman's). We typically grab lunch or dinner a few times a year at Bowman's. We stopped for dinner last night and it seemed like there were less vegetarian options than the last time I was there. I ordered a veggie burger substitution for the $20 burger and was charged $24. It seems silly to charge an extra 20% considering the most expensive part of a burger is the actual beef burger. I'll check the menu every so often if there's any new vegetarian entrees but in the meantime, it's going to be a while before we go back to Bowman's which is a bummer because we've always liked it. Go elsewhere if there's a vegetarian in your group.“

“I had my boyfriend’s surprise birthday party here and it was fantastic! The food and staff were both impressive!“

“Had a turkey club sandwich with chips. Enjoyed the food at a reasonable price in vibrant ambience. Will certainly return.“

“First time going there and I loved it. Only thing was Canadian bacon was a little overcooked. Place was clean and cozy. Reminds me of a truck stop which I suggested to a nearby customer. Alana was amazing and patient. Love the prices and the hospitality. I also like the slot machines even though I lost ?. The French toast was filling and plentiful. I will definitely will return. Jersey future customer here .?“

“Had a great lunch there yesterday with the kids. Everyone was so friendly and they were so accommodating to my seven year old with autism. Their kindness will not be forgotten and we’ll be returning not just for the good food but for the warm welcome.“

“Had the 4course thanksgiving dinner here today. Great menu choices at a fair price. The food was delicious, the portions were generous. The service was outstanding , the staff was friendly. We will definitely be back.“

“Had a mocha, the country omelette, and home fries. The mocha and home fries were some of the best I’ve ever had. The country omelette was also excellent: the eggs were cooked perfectly. I will be coming back and bringing family and friends. A great addition to Princeton’s downtown. Excellent service and ambiance, to boot!“

“Had dinner here tonight. My husband and I agree that it was one of the best dinners we have had in a very long time. Service was amazing. Even the hostess was walking around helping! Also the banana cream pie was unbelievable!!!“

“I truly enjoyed the food.“

“Winberie’s is my favorite restaurant in Princeton. The food and the service is consistently excellent. Whenever I’m in NJ I have at least one meal at Winberie’s. I really appreciate the healthier choices on the menu.“

“Tried Cosmos again for the 3rd time. Was really good. We both had an item that most people don't eat at a so called "pizza" restaurant. Salmon. Have to say it was really good. Good piece, nice size and tasted really good. Will definitely go back.“

“This is the definition of a hidden gem. Located in the Princeton Country Club (public), the food is outstanding and the chef is good at everything he puts on the menu. Service is kind, welcoming, and very accommodating. I didn't have a bite of food that I didn't like. Stand outs were the braised oxtail main, vegetable spring rolls, seafood gumbo with the catfish, shrimp with Alfredo, fried apple pie, BBQ chicken flatbread, A wonderful happy hour from 5-7pm.“

“Outstanding. a real fantastic place in Princeton, NJ city centre. Refined, nice people, fantastic food, outstanding wine list, umbeatable cocktails. simply perfect“

“Great quality, well presented food in an upscale, but unassuming environment. Perfect for lunch with friends, colleagues, or a date night!

As a vegan, the variety of dishes to choose from was a relative rarity and greatly appreciated! I had the sweet potato and bean chilli which was really tasty, well balanced, gorgeously presented, hearty - the perfect dish for autumn. The plant based dishes were so well designed that my colleagues, both of whom eat meat, opted for vegan meals too!

The farm to table concept is fabulous and the quality of ingredients is noticeable on the first bite. Each staff member we had the pleasure of interacting with was lovely, and the service was excellent throughout.

Thank you Agricola team!“

“Eli's restaurant service is truly exceptional and stands out in every possible way. From the moment you step through the door, you are greeted with a warm smile and a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Eli himself takes the time to ensure that every guest is comfortable and satisfied, often stopping by tables to engage in friendly conversation and check on the dining experience. The staff is well-trained, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, always ready to offer recommendations and accommodate special requests with ease. The attention to detail is evident in every aspect, from the beautifully presented dishes to the prompt and courteous service. Whether it's a busy weekend night or a quiet weekday evening, the consistency in service quality never wavers. Eli's dedication to providing an outstanding dining experience is palpable, making each visit memorable and enjoyable. It's not just about the food, which is delicious and expertly prepared, but the overall experience that keeps patrons coming back time and time again.“

“Never knew this place existed. Happened to be parked there to go in 7/11 when I saw this place.
Friendly when you come in.. prices are pretty good. The chicken was fried crispy and moist. Wasn't dry at all. Chicken seasoned to perfection!
And the French Fries was delicious ?
I will definitely revisit and try something else.
Meal order was chicken and fries!!“

“This unassuming cafe is on the lower level of the Carteret Arms apartments. The residence is a place for the elderly and thus the hours are a bit wonky. Provided you want a meal before 6pm, this should be a go-to spot. \n\nEverything is delicious. They lean towards fried foods, but have a great selection of seafood dishes and grilled options. Neighborhood favorites include the island pasta, which is close to divine. \n\nOn this visit we tried the grilled chicken sandwich and the blackened sandwich, both of which hit the spot. Good greens and cabbage, too. The owner makes homemade desserts. There are a variety of soft drinks and it is otherwise BYOB. \n\nThere is a small area for dining if you want to eat in.“

“Seasons52 Princeton food is delicious and varied as its name implies. Service is excellent as is its atmosphere.Managers, hostest,servers and staff are hands on, knowledgable,friendly and accommodating.Highly recommended.“

“Nubia (manager) and her staff are lovely and the flavors/variety are impressive! It’s great to have a place like this on campus - a nice mix of faculty/staff and students use this for lunch. It’s a mix of buffet style with a formal dining room experience (wait staff for drinks and busking the tables). Nubia really makes you feel at home! Go check it out. All for about $10!“

“🍺Great food and beer selection“

“Group of 6 met for lunch. Almost drove by. Could use a better sign. Comfortable small sports bar atmosphere. Very good service and the servings of food were large. You will not leave hungry and will most likely bring some home. First time there and we will definitely return.“

“Wasn’t a fan of the establishment under previous ownership. Went to today for breakfast knowing it was redone with the new owners. WOWZA! So much cleaner! Nothing was sticky or filthy! Pricing seems fair (even with add-ons), and food was tasty. however the bussers (is that what they are still called??) were FABULOUS. The young lady was great to know when I said a child was in the mix she just brought coloring items, and the young man was always making sure to refill coffee or clear dirty dishes. Looking forward to going back to try lunch and enjoying more breakfast noms in the future!“

“Celebrating 3 birthdays at Roots Ocean Prime with 8 people. Everyone loved their entrees (steaks ) which were cooked perfectly. Sides were tasty and enjoyed by everyone. Great wine list. Appreciated the wine recommendation by our server. Our server, Rachel, was excellent. The birthday desserts were the hit of the dinner! Thank you Roots Ocean Prime for making the birthday celebration extra special!“

“We went to dine with this rag tag restaurant and the experience was awful. The waitress had no teeth and asked my son for his? At first we thought “hey maybe they are joking” then all of a sudden. They lady grabbed his front bicuspid. Needless to say - at that point we were concerned. Because we had a long day we were still hungry. So we stuck around. The next thing you know. The toothless individual brought another toothless friend and tried to get my tooth as well. At that point. We know. Time to get out of here. We were cooked. Unlike the food at this gross place.“

“The owners were very accommodating and supportive in arranging a private party at the brewery. The staff were friendly and professional. The beer and food were great. Everyone at the party loved the spot. I was very pleased especially since I booked it sight unseen!“

“This was our first visit to the Brookwood Café. It is absolutely amazing. We spoke to one of the owners and she was so kind enough to let us sample the soup. Food is excellent! So happy we found this little gem.“

“our server Gianna was the best server I’ve ever had. she should get a raise because she’s super nice and funny. she made the experience really good and we want to come again“

“We had the fish and chips tonight. It was light and not greasy like other places. Very enjoyable!“

“This was the first time we have been here. The food was great and the staff was so nice. I highly recommend“

“Great Food. Great Staff. Highly recommended“

“We’ve come for the weekend bands several times recently. Music can sometimes be a little loud but that’s okay! Great food and waitstaff.“

“First time there with my sister and my wife... I will DEFINITELY return to sample something else on the menu... The mussels and linguini in white sauce was PERFECT!!“

“Meatheadz has the absolute best cheesesteak anywhere!! The service is fast and friendly and I've never been disappointed by this amazing establishment!“

“I've been craving barbecue and I already know about Mission BBQ's values, so I'd been looking forward to trying it out for the first time. I got pulled pork and ribs and they were both delicious. The ribs were nice and tender and moist. I appreciate the assortment of BBQ sauces the takeout associate gave me in my bag. I will definitely be back to dine in sometime.“

“This place is awesome and you really have to go there to see their Christmas decorations. It’s like Buddy The Elf showed up one day. Only thing missing is a Lego model of the diner inside the diner itself.“

“beautiful place to play. Course is in great condition and it gets a lot of play. hopefully they do night golf this year.“

“My wife and I have been coming here at least once a week for years. Usually for breakfast (nobody makes a better, more stuffed omelet), but also for wings, burgers, chicken, pasta and more. And we cannot forget about the staff...friendly, attentive and fast service. Skip the chain restaurants and give Orlando's a try!“

“We are ordering the second night in a row. I hope that says it all.“