Bagels Restaurants near Pequannock, NJ

“Great fresh bagels. We had an egg on an everything bagel and blueberry bagel and cream cheese. Definitely going there again“

“Best egg sandwiches around. I just ordered my sandwich this morning again 8/10 and the price went up from 2 weeks ago. Last time i went it was $6.95 which is higher then other places but now too much for me with new price. Charged $8.50. I will not be going anymore but was my favorite“

“If there were more stars, I'd give them. We are from out of state (formerly from Waldwick) and needed to send a brunch catering to a dear family. Bagel Supreme was professional, sweet, considerate and kind. I called on a Sunday afternoon at 1 PM (about an hour before the store closed) and the owner had his wife call "within the hour." She did and spent time with me on the phone getting the right order to fit my request for the family. Then sent multiple texts to confirm everything throughout the evening. Talk about going ABOVE AND BEYOND! They delivered PROMPTLY as promised the next day and they sent us pictures of the platters to ensure that we saw what was delivered. Greeting cards to mark the occasion with our thoughts HAND WRITTEN were attached. The store would NOT take money until the order was delivered even though I offered to pay in advance. I will absolutely use them in the future for long distance gift giving (who doesn't like food as a gift)? And this will be our very first stop when we are back in town. 1,000% recommend!!!“

“This was my first time eating here and they did not disappoint! It’s not often I can go into a deli and there are numerous gluten free options! They were friendly, asked questions to be sensitive to what modifications I may have needed, and the food was delicious too! We will definitely be going back again and again!“

“Carlos has been making bagels for years! Glad to see him start his own business!“

“A great place..Rema, Nart, Willie and Mohammed are wonderful people...Homemade potato salad is delicious...Family owned business who takes care of the community and appreciates those who patronize their business...Thank you for always taking care of me...Willie your the Best....“

“Wayne Hot Bagels supplied breakfast for Teacher Appreciation Week and did a fabulous job! They were friendly, courteous, patient and worked with me to find items that fit within the budget. They even personally delivered for us free of charge. They truly were a pleasure to deal with and I would definitely use them again for future events!“

“Absolutely the best bagel there is. Each one no matter the flavor is a delight. And their food that they put on the bagel is delicious. Get there before 3;30 PM if you want sliced cheese because they close the slicer at 3;30. I know if I get there at 3;32 PM the slicer is off. So I get tuna fish instead and it’s about as good as it gets. The staff is friendly and do a good job. What a place!“

“Great place to stop ! Large variety of bagels, Plus a lot more then just bagels! Always a friendly face to serve you too !“

“They were able to accommodate a very large custom order on short notice, and they were incredibly kind about it! Upon picking it up, they helped carry out everything to my car, which was unexpected and very appreciated. On top of the great service, the bagels were fantastic.“

“Hands downbeat! Best friggen Bagel Spot on the planet. Bang for the buck. Deliciousness done right!“

“Absolutely THE BEST bagels on Earth! A staple of the community, generous and giving, family-run business. One of those places where “everybody knows your name and they’re always glad you came.” Every Monday!“

“Good customer service. Good food quality.“

“I don’t have enough good things to say about this business. I called 5 Brothers from Wisconsin (not knowing anything about delis or restaurants in Lincoln Park, New Jersey—just going by google search) to order a couple trays of food for a memorial service in Lincoln Park which I could not attend. I am so happy my Google search led me to such a professional and helpful business. The two brothers I worked with listened to my situation and understood what I was hoping to provide food-wise, and then they suggested a mixed tray of baked goods and desserts that were perfect. They even sent me photos and a video of the finished trays of goodies after they put them together. And then they delivered. Amazing. Top-notch customer service. I highly recommend this company for food delivery and catering. Good, good people.“

“Review for King Gyro - halal, Little Falls, NJ
If you’re craving bold flavor and late-night satisfaction, King Gyro - halal is a must-visit gem in Little Falls. From the moment you walk in, the staff greets you with genuine warmth and friendly service that makes the experience feel personal and welcoming.

The lamb platter is a standout tender, perfectly spiced, and generously portioned. Pair it with their creamy white sauce and fragrant rice, and you’ve got a meal that punches way above its price point. The chicken tikka platter is equally impressive, with juicy, marinated chunks of chicken that deliver smoky depth and vibrant flavor in every bite. Both dishes offer incredible value without compromising on quality.

🕑 And the best part? They’re open until 2am, making it the perfect spot for a late-night bite that doesn’t feel like a compromise. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, King Gyro delivers on taste, service, and affordability. Highly recommended for anyone who loves halal comfort food done right.“

“Best gluten free bagel I’ve ever had. Not the dry, pre-made kind that most bagel places serve. Nick was very pleasant and helpful. Atmosphere was perfect for me and my daughter to sit and enjoy breakfast. They even have a small play area for kids. Will be back.“

“Great Friendly Staff & Owner The Is Always Smiling And Pleasant. The Bagels Are Always Made Fresh Daily And If You Get There Early Hot. The Breakfast Sandwiches Are Always Great On A Bagel, Roll or Crossant. The Coffee Is Always Fresh. Keep Up The Great Work!!!“

“Zeid and his team were great. Everything was made fresh and quick. The store is very clean. The egg bagel with cream cheese was perfect and the right amount of CC. I got a SBEC and it was delicious full of flavor. The portion def filled me up. The daisy muffins were ok. They were a little too greasy to my liking. But all in all would def come back“

“We moved to Tennessee 8 years ago & long for good bagels which are hard to come by where we live. We found Howard’s Bagels while visiting for the birth of our second granddaughter. We explained, we were looking to take some good bagels back with us. The young lady(sorry I never asked your name) was so nice & accommodated us with a free sample of a pumpernickel bagel. We were over the moon & found heaven in a bagel! Fresh, tasty, delicious New Jersey bagels! We ordered 2 dozen to take home to Tennessee, which by the way you actually get 15 bagels for a dozen(must be some kind of new math, lol). Guessing the online bagels we’ve been getting will be on hold for quite a while, these bagel are worth the side trip if you are ever within 20 miles(for us 600 miles), do yourself a favor get some & the crumb cake they have is also delicious! Peace!“

“Enjoy food and friendly place“

“Great place for breakfast! Hungry Man sandwich was delicious and fit for someone hungry. Omelette platter is big and tasty. Will come back next time in town!“

“My favorite bagel place!!! I've tried others but this is the best. Only suggested improvement is to slice the Taylor ham thinner and add more veggies to the veggie cc but the best bagels.Updated review, September 2023, I have recently went to two different bagel stores in the area and by no way shape or form. Do they compete with this place. One in Kinnelon and one in Butler. Just an update, still by far my favorite.Some staff are friendlier than others, but I've worked in a bagel store and I know how grueling it can be, I never hold it against them because they are always busy and it is a very short interaction.I highly highly recommend this bagel store!“

“Great breakfast bagels, flagels, bialys, and more! Every morning made fresh, savory, and delicious. Food is consistent. Customer service is on point. A family run shop. They treat you with love and respect. Like you’re walking into grandma’s kitchen. Great sense of humor. Best part (besides the great food) is that if you call like 10 min ahead, they’ll have it ready for you when you come in. No wait time! As a Montville resident, I will always be back!“

“This is one of my favorite food places. The bakery goods are fantastic. Bagels are made on premises and if you get lucky, you can get them fresh out of the oven.

Though not high end dining, this restaurant checks the boxes. Food is excellent. Staff is friendly and helpful. It is not fair to rate the atmosphere on the same plane as the other two. It’s not fancy but quite functional. Especially since it’s usually utilized as a take out place. Most of the time, I’m passing through. I phone in my order and pick it up shortly after. BTW, the tuna and chicken salads are to die for. Maybe the best I’ve ever had. The egg salad is no slouch either.“

“They are the best because they’re the only bagel shop that actually LISTENS to your order. Toasted dark bagel? Done. Extra crispy bacon? Done. Add little butter? Done.

Any other place you go to, they would miss one of the above.

And their bagels are delicious. Not too fluffy, not too thick.“

“fresh bagels and sandwiches. friendly workers. the best ♥️“

“Amazing bagels, breakfast, sandwiches and service! Highly recommended!!!😀“

“Great customer service, everyone is very friendly!“

“The best bagels and customer service around!“

“The best bagel and breakfast spot in the state! Their food is amazing and so is the service.“

“Great sándwiches and good coffee. Everything has great taste. Love it!“

“Best Ham, Egg & Cheese in Montclair and the friendliest staff to boot!“

“I love a good bagel sandwich. A well done Taylor ham and cheese on a toasted everything bagel is my go to. This place makes a great sandwich. I love being able to text my order and get a response when it will be done. I've been ordering from this place for over a year and the food is always ready when they say it will be. In and out in minutes. Great place, nice people, good food.“

“Best bagels ever anywhere“

“This has to be THE BEST. THEEEEEE best bagel shop I've ever been to in my life. Fresh bagels come out regularly, ingredients and fresh, food is flavorful, and great portion sizes! Everything you need :) breakfast sandwiches and lunch paninis are always my favorite here!“

“I've only ever gotten whole bagels here but WOW they're perfect. Slight crunch to the outside, pillowy inside. They're even amazing plain untoasted with butter and obviously great toasted and all the way dressed up as a sandwich.“

“Great food and staff. I go there often and I have never gotten anything that wasn't delicious. The bagels are amazing. Unfortunately I am now gluten free but their gluten free bagels are very good. The salads and the fries are really good too. The prices aren't crazy and the portions are decent. The staff is always friendly and willing to accommodate any special requests that I may have. This is definitely my favorite bagel shop.“

“I used to come here all the time in college, circa '98, '99. I haven't been there in quite a few years, but decided to stop with my son the other day. I ordered a Taylor Ham and cheese on a toasted plain bagel and he had a plain bagel with cream cheese. It was the best I've had in years!! Now my son is asking me everyday to take a ride up there. Glad to see the quality remains the same! We'll be back........frequently! The Howard Stern on an Everything Bagel was my go to in college. I'm sure it's still amazing.“

“Manhattan Bagel
Manhattan Bagel is a casual spot famous for its fresh bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast options. Their bagels are typically soft on the inside with a slight chewiness, and they offer a wide variety of spreads, from classic cream cheese to flavored options. Breakfast sandwiches, paninis, and coffee are also popular with regulars. The service is generally friendly and efficient, making it a convenient choice for a quick meal or grab-and-go breakfast. Overall, it’s a reliable place for bagel lovers looking for fresh, tasty, and satisfying options.“

“Coffee is the best lunch sandwich are delicious servers are great One of my best places to eat“

“Hi, my name is jack. I stop EVERY WORK DAY MORNING at this wonderful eatery. First, the lady behind the counter is not only a VERY NICE person but a very organized. Every morning I come in and my everything bagel with Taylor ham cheese and tomatoes is already done in the bag waiting for me. I'm in and out in less than 3 minutes every time I go. I HIGHLY RECOMEND THIS PLACE TO ANYONE THAT WANTS A GOOD SANDWICH OR JUST A CUP OF COFFEE BECAUSE THESE DAYS NICE AND PROFESSIONAL ARE HARD TO FIND. THANK YOU FAIRFIELD HOT BAGEL FOR STARTING MY DAY OFF RIGHT.“

“I have been going here over 6 years already and everyone is amazing especially my Thomas … always makes my day going in there … i never had any problems there and the food is always fresh … keep up the good work guys !!!“

“Great staff in Allendale. Food was delicious“

“Absolutely delish. The special was priced perfect. Chicken salad on rye toast. Pickles were crisp and perfect. Drink and chips included.“

“Best bagels ever anywhere“

“Customer service was great and more importantly the bagel was delicious. I’ll soon find out about other stuff from the menu.“

“I mean seriously, some of the people in these reviews go out of their way to hurt local businesses over such petty stuff. I wonder if you treat your own family that way when a meal is cooked for you at home. If you’re looking for the best bagels in Clifton, this is the spot, especially in the mornings when the bagels are super fresh. My whole family loves the strawberry cream cheese, it’s sweet but so good.“

“Great spot for fresh bagels, they have a simple variety and have several cream cheeses, not as many as I'm used to seeing in traditional bagel places. Bakers dozen gives you a free bagel! Staff is friendly and quick with the service. 12 bagels and 1 pound of scallion cream cheese is $27 here for quick reference.“