14 Best American Restaurants near Plumsted

“I remember when Tootsie had the diner in Cookstown next to the Getty station....was always great food with a fabulous smile on her face!“

“Amazing dinner with my boyfriend. Potato pancakes were phenomenal! Schnitzel platter and gravy’s on point.“

“I love this place, but they should of get rid of the carpet. I haven’t been there for yeas due to the smell of mold. But it’s a such lovely place and the food is excellent“

“The food here never fails to impress. It’s fresh, tasty, and expertly made. The staff are friendly, attentive, and work really hard to make your dining experience ( inside or takeout/delivery) an enjoyable one. We visit a couple of times a week!!“

“So glad we stopped in! Woodys was exactly what we needed after a long day of driving. Walked in and felt like home. Our server Chelsea was such a puddin’ start to finish. The hot turkey sandwich and waffle sundae put me into a perfect food coma. Best stop on our trip. Much luck to you!“

“Don't know why an online order should have a convenience fee?“

“Ellie's Speedway's All Star Bagel Shop & Charleston Coffee House is the best place in all of Central NJ. I've been a loyal customer for 2 years & not only do they make the greatest breakfast sandwiches we've ever had, but they have an amazing staff. Their sandwiches & cold brew beat any other shop around by far. They load you up on bacon & always have the freshest bagels you've ever tasted. The staff is the sweetest & will always remember you, and the atmosphere is always homey. Can't speak highly enough!“

“We absolutely love this place! The service is always top-notch, and you can tell they truly care about their guests. The food is delicious, the cocktails are amazing, and the beer selection is always tasty. Halil, his son and the staff are some of the friendliest, hardest-working people you’ll ever meet — they make every visit feel welcoming. Highly recommend!“

“Interesting setup. Not a ton of seating, but honestly, it works for the bar vibe. The front section doubles as a full-on liquor store, which is kinda wild but also convenient.

Food was solid, I highly ecommend the cheese curds. The menu’s huge, and our food came out way faster than I expected. Cool little spot if you’re grabbing drinks and want something quick to eat.“

“Really great facility lots of turf fields a good snack stand just excellent all around.“

“Our food was not good tonight May 13, 2025... sliced filet mignon was tough, couldn't even chew it, told the server and someone named Jacob came and asked if we wanted something else..there were 4 of us, they were all eating so I said no.. they didn't even take my meal off the check... disgraceful, food is way overpriced,, we will never eat here again“

“Just had an amazing chicken Parm sub with vodka sauce.“

“We were just driving through the area on our way home. We stopped because we were starving. It’s a hidden gem. From the outside it’s an unassuming little place. But when we stepped inside, everything changed. We were greeted instantly by big smiles. Told we could sit wherever we wished. The atmosphere caused you to instantly feel relaxed. All three days of us ordered something different and we all loved our choices. From the “hot dog and beans”, “pulled pork”, “pork ribs”, “stuffed jalapeño burger”, and don’t forget the dessert… well needless to say, we left happy and stuffed. I’ve honestly not had BBQ that good since I was in Texas!! We are already talking about going back again. With the 50 minute drive!!“

“Last night 6 of us who have been to Plumstead many times went for dinner, Food was great as always (prime rib, stuffed shrimp, champagne chicken, chicken stir-fry excellent,) On this visit however our server was not very pleasant. It started with asking for separate checks which she said she couldn't do. One guest asked for cole slaw instead of salad and she said no subs, but on previous visits we could sub. Another server came over and was very pleasant complimenting one of our party on their Christmas sweater, the manager offered to take a picture of our group. Our server reached across other diners to serve food or drink instead of walking around to put in front of them. Probably should have said something to the manager upon leaving. We know her name but will only say it starts with a P.“