17 Best American Restaurants near Plumsted

“Tootie’s is a New Egypt icon. We are family here and the staff treats us very well. You’re sure to meet a familiar face there and when you go at night for the fresh and delicious ice cream, you will most certainly see people from all over, lining up the entire sidewalk waiting for the famous treats. We love Tootie’s and are proud to support our local businesses. There isn’t a time when we have never felt like family there. Long live Tootie’s and Tootie’s Ice Cream! (By the way, they’re famous for their Chipwich sandwiches…)“

“Kitschy German food restaurant with all the right stuff Keynote you must have a reservation and you must pay cash they do not take credit cards. This is not easily identified on the website or other Google reviews. Overall unique spot with Hardy digs very easy over order but worth a try for sure.“

“Great small down cafe. All of the options (although limited) are great and definitely worth coming back for. Waitresses are relatively attentive, but there is often quite a lot of traffic in and out. There may be a short wait for seating depending on when you arrive.“

“The food was good and fairly priced. The fries that came with the burgers were a hit with everyone in my party. I got the pumpkin martini out of curiosity and would recommend it to fans of pumpkin spice, but the most noteworthy item I got was the Belgian Waffle beer. Event I was with couldn't get over how much it actually smelled like a waffle, even from six seats away at the bar. It also genuinely tasted like a wake which was very pleasant for the first half, but too sweet for the second half. I would recommend trying it for the experience if you only plan on getting 1 beer, not so much if you plan on drinking more.“

“Went last night and everything we order was amazing. I got a sandwich and the chicken was freshly fried. Also got what looked like a fried calzone filled with chicken and mozzarella then topped with vodka sauce, it was on another level. We also shared the special which was chicken leg that fell off the bone and was season perfectly. Everyone there was super nice, great atmosphere and people! Definitely will be going back.“

“I recently won a gift card at an American Legion fundraiser. #1 community minded. Thank you for supporting our veterans. They also proudly boast a military discount at the Cookstown location across the street from Joint Base.?? They are award winning for a reason. Great ribs ! I was late for sliced brisket ? had to get "chopped " brisket which was like a pulled beef. A little saucey for me but tender. They sell bacon wrapped poppers ?. I do alot of cooking and alot of reviews and this was a great stop and I will recommend them to anyone wanting great BBQ. Great job!“

“Pass this place everyday went in on that reason alone. I got a burger and the bacon chicken ranch cheese steak. The burger was good I cant get down with the pretzel bun it was wet and made the burger hard to eat. The cheese steak overall was the winner my girlfriend and I like it would go back and try the other ones.“

“We enjoyed our Valentine's Day lunch at Tommy's. Inn.recently opened at his new location. I had a chicken quesadilla and a side salad of mixed greens and my sweetie had a bacon burger a fries. Very good and reasonably priced. Thanks Tommy!! We'll be back.“

“I made reservations for my family who came out for my cousins wedding on Saturday. Sunday I called Martucci's to make reservations to take my family there for lunch. I have gone there for before with a big crowd to celebrate other birthdays. My family hasn't been together for many years. My 91 year old Pop, his brother Joe 90, my Aunt Ro 83 and my Aunt Maryann 78 and all of us went to Martucci.I want to give a BIG THANK YOU TO ALL THE MARTUCCI FAMILY. The food is great the girls who waited on us A+ all the way! Thank all of you for making our family reunion that much more special! God bless! ?“

“This is definitely your friendly neighborhood bar/grill. First of all, the service is awesome. Our server was great! She gave awesome recommendations and was very attentive. Even sat down with us a for a few minutes. This place gets busy! But we still were able to get a table pretty quickly. The food was very good that’s as well. They do not skimp on the seasoning which is a good thing! Seems to be a popular place for bikers. I def recommend and will be visiting again soon.“

“Let me tell you, the absolute awesome best Puerto Rican food ever!!! Super filling and the taste have you wanting more. Everything clean. Staff and owner is very friendly, loving , caring and kind. Thank you Cilantro Dining and Catering LLC.“

“Great food and reasonable prices. Came here with family twice in 4 days. Was visiting from Florida. My only beef with this place is, they charged me 4% credit card fee, but no mention of it on menu or posted in the restaurant. Usually places offer a cash option w/o fee. Being originally from NJ i should've stuck to the motto, "Welcome to NJ, bring your wallet".“

“I have been coming there for years, they always go above and beyond to help me and the food has been excellent. Sometimes I get a bagel, sometimes a platter, and even next door I get a healthy acai bowl. The staff is friendly and greets me as I am a regular even though I am only in the area a handful of times per year. My kids love the bagels and ask to make a special trip. It's nice to have fresh food options where these chain places have all this food with tons of preservatives. Highly recommend“

“Food and service here are great. Everyone from base comes here. Not everyone sits and eats but is usually a pick up and go. Food is made fresh from what I can tell. They have an open salad bar option which is cool. It's a nice spot to have a quick bite if you want or enjoy on the go.Parking: During lunch hours, the parking lot can become full very quick. And it's a little tight to navigate. Usually you do find a spot but it's not like you pull right into one.“

“I came here for the first time yesterday. It’s a fun atmosphere with great drinks. I didn’t try the food, next time !Definitely a place to check out! The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu!They have some sort of iTunes jukebox you can pick songs you’d like to hear, very unique!“

“I've been here a few times and they never disappoint. Burgers are the best, as well as other food and the Grolsch on tap hits the spot. Great food, interesting drinks, and the people that fill it make it a spot worth going out of your way for.“

“This place ALWAYS delivers...I'm SO glad that I discovered it as there's such a limited amount of restaurants to chose from in the area...everything is great...bartenders/ waitresses/waiters and perfect cocktails and delicious food!!!“