6 Best Ice Cream Shops near Plumsted

“Tootie’s is a New Egypt icon. We are family here and the staff treats us very well. You’re sure to meet a familiar face there and when you go at night for the fresh and delicious ice cream, you will most certainly see people from all over, lining up the entire sidewalk waiting for the famous treats. We love Tootie’s and are proud to support our local businesses. There isn’t a time when we have never felt like family there. Long live Tootie’s and Tootie’s Ice Cream! (By the way, they’re famous for their Chipwich sandwiches…)“

“We love coming here. Always friendly service and fresh. The only reason I'm removing a star is because on our last visit the employee was wearing gloves and took out money and made change. She did not change her gloves and proceeded to go package up cinnamon buns, a big no-no in food safety. She was young and maybe doesn't understand how gloves work. I'm just hoping by leaving this review that maybe the manager/owner can go over food safety with all the employees.“

“Rebecca and her mom, Tammy Sue, are super friendly ladies. All their items are very fresh daily and delicious. I love their bagels fresh each day from Staten Island. The crumb cake is out of this world. Give this place a try. You won't be disappointed.“

“My pop and I stop thru on my way home from work daily (except the past week or two when he went on an Alaskan cruise) and we typically get a cone each. I'm known for both by sarcastic personality and straight forward nature, and extremely outspoken. I get these traits from him. I think he ruffled a few feathers one of the first times we went in bc it seems one woman tends to short him with the amount of custard on his cone. No big deal, I know, but I think he's getting fed up, and if he speaks up, he will make her cry. Other than that, I dig the place. Just the other day I went solo and got a Blizzard (the new caramel fudge one) and the young girl was sure to flip it before giving it to me.“

“Hey! It’s Rita’s! All of their items are great and the service is usually pretty darn good. There’s not a lot of space outside for sitting and the parking lot is pretty small, but it’s location doesn’t exactly permit alot of space. Nice place.“

“We just moved to this area and I was looking for a good breakfast and lunch one day while moving. This place is a hidden gem!!! The food was honestly, amazing. The staff was soooo friendly. Can't wait to go back for their ice cream . We had bagels and an appitizers sampler, the food was fresh, cooked perfectly, fast and absolutely delicious. Big fan!“