29 Best Pizza Restaurants near Plumsted

“We came up from North Carolina to visit family and couldn’t wait to get some real New Jersey pizza — Anthony’s in New Egypt absolutely hit the spot. The pizza was amazing: crispy crust, perfect cheese, and that classic NJ flavor we’ve been missing. Great place, friendly staff, and awesome food. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!“

“Food was excellent! I’m a foodie, and have had seafood Alfredo at many places. This was by far De Best!!“

“Love the pizza here. It reminds me of home. Brooklyn, NY. Would recommend 10 out of 10. Try the buffalo chicken with breaded chicken, that’s my favorite.“

“The food here never fails to impress. It’s fresh, tasty, and expertly made. The staff are friendly, attentive, and work really hard to make your dining experience ( inside or takeout/delivery) an enjoyable one. We visit a couple of times a week!!“

“Went with friends after Six Flags closed for the night, and even as they were an hour from closing, the staff welcomed us in so warmly and the service was incredibly speedy! Portions were huge and affordable. If you’re going to Six Flags, or ever in the area, give this place a visit!“

“The owner is awesome and the guy in the back making sandwiches is truly gifted. I worked around the corner for a couple weeks and didn’t go anywhere else for lunch, absolutely phenomenal. Pizza, sandwiches, burgers, whatever you get is good. Family man as well, could sit down and talk to him for a half hour if I had the time. And he made me espresso after I got to know him. 10/10“

“mangias Jackson is the very best in food!!! Great service on top of their delicious food . Our families #1 stop when we don’t want to cook . Their buffalo chicken pie is the best , and the wraps are always fresh so stop in or call you will not be disappointed !!“

“The salads are BIG and there are severals options to choose from. My favorite it the House salad and Yordanas salad. The bruschetta is always fresh and delicious. Chicken Saltimbuco is my dh favorite. Also a great place to buy catered meals!“

“That’s the pizza once you can get it out of the box.“

“Nice pizza😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋 🍕“

“Honestly love this location. They are always fast and my order is always correct. The staff are friendly and helpful. My only wish is they delivered to me seeing as I'm in town but there radius is a bit small for that. Other then that definitely one of the best locations I have been to.“

“Just had an amazing chicken Parm sub with vodka sauce.“

“This place is amazing! Excellent service, everybody was extremely kind. The food was delicious. We tried their cheese pizza, a Buffalo chicken cheesesteak, and an Italian grinder. Everything was delicious, hot, and fresh! I cannot recommend them enough!“

“Great food and service. Reasonable prices clean place to eat. Definitely coming back.“

“That’s the pizza once you can get it out of the box.“

“great family owned business with good food and interesting weekend specials“

“Hands down Gio’s deserves a five out of five stars. It is how a local family owned business should be run. They care about their regular customers, but everyone gets five star service and quality. The first time I ordered from them, I compared all the prices of all local Italian Pizzerias, For my son‘s birthday party (I’m a single mom). Their prices couldn’t be beat. Since I’ve tried their food, The quality and consistency of quality prove to be top-notch. I’ve lived in New Egypt for over 30yrs and seen places Come and go. I hope Gio’s isn’t one of them.“

“had the veggie pizza it was delicious“

“First time customer... ordered pizza to pick up. Really good pizza. Crust was perfect, sauce was flavorful but not overwhelming, and cheese was plentiful and real. While not the absolute best pizza I have ever had, it certainly ranks up there on my top 10 list . Highly recommended.“

“Great pizzeria. The food is good, the owner is accommodating and the people who work there are great. Great place to grab a slice for lunch or to sit down and have dinner.“

“Best Italian food around“

“Friendly staff, large portions! Excellent food! I enjoyed the food and will b back!!“

“Don't let this place fool you. It may not look like much from the outside. The pizza is excellent. Have even had a number of family events there over the years and it was great every time. Was there tonight and will certainly be back. They put their $ into the quality of the food rather than the ambiance. Place is clean and the owner and staff are friendly. Rates 10 Stars if possible. Reminds me of Pizza places I would frequent with my friends back in the early 70s“

“We ordered a tray of Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce for Christmas Eve dinner. It was absolutely amazing. We finished off with cannolis which were huge and so delicious! Romeo is the best, whatever you want, he will do!“

“Great service with from friendly staff members. The food was hot, fresh, and delicious.“

“Pizza is good , chicken franchise not ☹️“

“This place was interesting. I went there for food, and realized it's in a top golf. The food was not as expensive as I expected, and it was also better than I expected. The atmosphere was really weird tho. It felt like I was in a new car dealership with LED lights and a smell of rubber.

With that said, I still give it an 8/10. The staff were very friendly, the food was great, it was pretty cheap, I had a good time. Just be ready to be surrounded by top golf dad's ?“

“delicious food at a great price point“

“Usually I don't review, but hands down had one of the best Steak Stromboli last night. so delicious! Was very generous & tasty. Great jobs guys! Keep up that consistency & I will always come back. Definitely a must try, if you love Steak Stombolis.“