Pizza Restaurants near Cream Ridge

“This restaurant is truely a hidden gem. We got a recommendation and directions from a local couple who eat there weekly. The food was delicious. the dinners came with soup or salad and freshly baked bread and rolls. Two of us opted for soup and our third diner had the salad. To our surprise the soup was not a small cup, but a large bowl. Both the pasta e fagioli and the lentil were homemade and hearty. We enjoyed them both. Two orders of veal parm and one order of chicken parm later we we re stuffed. The portions were generous enough to have leftovers for lunch the next day. The pizzas that were being served while we dined looked crispy and loaded with toppings. We were sorry we did not order one to go. It is BYOB so we had wine which our server, Justine, opened and served. Justine was friendly and very accommodating. She answered any questions about the food and explained the specials of the day. We will definitely eat there again when we are out that way.“

“Always very kind and great customer service when you call. They greet you when you come in and if you’re a regular they remember your name. Authentic Italian food made by the family that owns it. They have very good salad, my favorite it’s made with quality lettuce, roasted peppers, olives, and veggies. Their garlic knots are perfectly cooked and fresh, their sauce is nice and thick and fresh. They put their fries in a paper bag to keep them crispy. You’re getting good quality food and very friendly service if you come here.“

“Stopped here after a day at Great Adventure. Cozy little Italian restaurant in a small strip mall down from Six Flags. The food was really good! Fresh made and tasty. The service was not up to par. Waiter was friendly but very inattentive. The place wasn’t busy either. Heard they have a sister restaurant one town over that is top notch. May try them next time.“

“Amazing Italian food! The Penne Vodka entree is delicious or try the Hollywood (chicken, shrimp, scallops in vodka sauce). The pizza is also great, try the Sicilian Combo with their house salad, enough to feed the whole family. Best Italian food outside of Brooklyn.“

“I was visiting the area and decided to stop here based on the reviews that I read. It did not disappoint. The food was delicious, and the service was excellent. We ordered the calamari and a meatlover's pizza. There was also complimentary bread and dipping oil. The atmosphere was really nice; however, the tables are really close together. I“

“It’s always the little nook in the walls that have the best stuff. I seen this guy on TikTok an year ago and I live like an hour away and I said to myself if I’m ever in the area I’d stop by. Needless to say I got this job with public service so now I have the privilege to drive around to a lot of new areas and I got lucky to be near by. I was craving pizza I looked around, the highest rated place pulled up not expecting it to be Sally Slices places bc I had honestly after all this time forgot about him being in this part of Jersey. I pull up posters and pictures of this guy everywhere and I was so excited. I got the pepperoni one with and without hot honey ( his sister was in this day I didn’t get to meet Sally but she recommended the hot honey I said I’ll try one of them with it) and the first bite was awesome. the crunch on this thing was insane. I had to make a video and share it to my fiancé. I then went 3 more times that week while working in the area and it was consistently the same perfect crunch each time and I only got hot honey after that first time. The hot honey was this added sweetness that I didn’t know I needed on my pizza. I recommend it to a couple of co workers and showed them the video of the crunch and they thought I was lying when I said it’s the crispiest thing you’ll ever bite into. they live in the area and they stopped on their lunches and after work they said it was the best pizza they ever had, probably won’t be ordering from anywhere else they said.“

“Came to NJ for a short trip and wanted some pizza. Friends told me about 3 brothers and they were not wrong. This pizza definitely great. I got the Meat Lovers and it was what I love about NY Style* pizza. The 6 mozzarella sticks I also bought were good.*The BEST style of pizza. You degenerates who like Chicago style are wrong.“

“Second time here and felt the need to write a review. First of all, we were a group of 25 ladies doing our bookclub. We got kicked out of the town library without notice for no reason and were desperate for a place to continue our meeting since people had come from up to 50 minutes away. I called La Piazza and they accommodated us last minute, were so welcoming, and turned our night around. The food was amazing as always too, love their pasta with vodka sauce (added grilled chicken for some protein). I didn't order dessert, but the selection was amazing and everyone who did enjoyed! Lastly, our waitress was so great and welcoming!“

“Indo Chinese veg manchurian and fried rice too much good and fresh test like Mumbai street food service also fantastic . Jayesh bhai is awesome great service I like it .I am from Edison but nobody like your service here .Thanks jayesh I visit very soon at your place and eat more food with my family and friends.Thanks ☺️“

“I’m so happy we finally made it here! After months of reading the positive reviews, my son recommended that we come for dinner! Everything was prepared fresh, portions were plentiful, service was attentive and presentation was appealing. We will definitely be back!! Highly recommend!“

“The food was DELICIOUS, fresh, and reasonably priced. Service was so thoughtful, a tad slow, but for fresh, delicious food, it was no big deal. We were in no rush, and we had an amazing lunch. Very unassuming strip mall location, but lovely inside and we had a fantastic lunch. Highly recommend. You will not be disappointed. I think there is a small service fee for credit cards. I wish we would have gotten dessert. I only got a picture of the salad and after I inhaled my meal. My kids got the chicken souvlaki dinner and I got the shrimp skewers dinner. Also got the mozzarella sticks. I wish I lived closer and could go back and try the rest of the menu!!“

“Went last night and everything we order was amazing. I got a sandwich and the chicken was freshly fried. Also got what looked like a fried calzone filled with chicken and mozzarella then topped with vodka sauce, it was on another level. We also shared the special which was chicken leg that fell off the bone and was season perfectly. Everyone there was super nice, great atmosphere and people! Definitely will be going back.“

“We grabbed a bottle o wine from the liquor store 2 doors down and went to dinner. The place was clean and set nicely with cloth table cloths and cloth napkins. Our waiter Peter was professional, courteous and attentive to our needs. I had the grilled seafood combo which was fantastic (and I'm from Massachusetts so know seafood). We also had the galic breas with cheese which was excellent. The chef presented us two complimentary mini cannollis which were obviously freshly filled and tasty. A 5 star experience after a 7 hour day driving.“

“I’ve tried most of the highest reviewed pizza spots in Jersey (besides Deluca’s) and Dilorenzos is still at the top of my list. Their regular pie is phenomenal but if you like sausage & peppers on your pie, you’re in for a treat. Every so often, we’ll drive over an hour just to go here, well worth the trip!“

“Just hosted my rehearsal dinner here and it was amazing! Marco was fantastic, he made everything so easy to set up. My family LOVED the food and the service was perfect. We even ordered pizza for the whole bridal party the next morning, and they delivered on time and was so delicious. 10/10 would recommend!“

“Great place to get your fix of Tomato pie.This restaurant has been around since 1914 I believe. Great history, and differentiates with "mustard pie" which I assume is great, made with a layer of mustard baked in but my 5 friends were afraid to try. Maybe next time!“

“This place on the outside reminds me of what a hidden gem looks like. Went inside and was greeted by an extremely nice man who was extremely helpful and had a ton of stories. This place in the mood for Mexican is the go too spot around here. Tacos were amazing and everything was fresh.“

“Nicely decorated, good service and delicious food. Decent size portions as well. I enjoyed a chicken and sausage risotto and also tasted the chicken marsalla. Both were very good, but there wasn't much marsalla flavor in the sauce. The prices were slightly on the high side, but not awful. I would have felt better about that if they included a house Salad with the entrée instead of everything Ala carte. BYOB also. Overall, I recommend this restaurant.“

“Mannino’s is the best, My family is so thrilled we came across them. They have the best Grandma pie. Yesterday we ordered a sausage , onion and roasted pepper pie, it was amazing. This is the best pizzeria in the area. I didn’t think anyone here could make a fantastic pie, but they did. This will definitely be our go to place, no others in the area come close. Keep maki g your delicious food“

“Went in to place an order for a family of five. First time visiting this place, and I was greatly surprised of all the options they had to choose from. All of the food was delicious, their wings were flavorful and meaty! The spicy chicken wrap had plenty of goodness wrapped in it! The garlic knots were also delicious!The service was top notch, and the atmosphere for dining in is very family friendly.“

“Delicious food, great atmosphere, huge portions! Jayden and Walter were AMAZING!! The salmon was fantastic and the absolute best chicken franchise. Definitely recommend coming here if you are looking for a good dinner spot with very attentive and friendly staff!“

“such tasty food, they’ve got the kind of fries people dream about. so perfectly crispy, just your ideal pizzeria fries. i also got the chicken franchese dip sandwich and it was unreal. it even tasted just as good reheated the next day. i highly reccomend stopping by and i will be coming back in the “

“Quiet and cozy atmosphere even with their usual full house. I've ordered from here countless times over the years and I have never been disappointed. Browns Mills can be hit or miss with pizza so I drive a little out of my way and it's well worthe it. They have a lot of specialty pizza's to choose from and they are all fantastic. We've had a few of their specials that aren't always on the menu like chicken cordon Bleu and it was delicious! That Sauce was definitely made fresh from scratch and was made traditionally which most restaurants can't execute. Impressive. Very Clean and the prices are fair. Anything you order from here, you will love for sure!“

“We love Gloria at the bar, she is so personable and sweet!We love the wings & steak & pizza here. The food is amazing! We go often on weekdays and even weekends. The service is great, the inside has wine barrels that are such a neat feature to the looks.“

“Update to my previous post 2 months ago... they figured things out since they opened up! My experience from one who loves pizza & tries new places out every chance I get. Their rolls for hot subs are thin and soft, not dense. Calzones are very good! & calamari was lightly breaded & very good!Great job!!“

“Have recently become a forever fan of Manninos 3 on Rt. 33 in Hamilton Square NJ.I received a catering order from there a few weeks ago and was so pleasantly surprised...not only was the young delivery man courteous and respectful , but the trays of food were delicious !We had a tray of each of the eggplant Azzurri Rollatini with spinach, cheese and roasted peppers in a vodka sauce and another large tray of their AC Milan penne vodka, breaded chicken, mozzarella in a delicious creamy vodka sauce. Along with a bag full of their very appealing knotted breads..Both entrees were outstanding and plentiful.Since then we have been there with friends and family 5 more times and have also ordered several catering items being delivered to friends , all of which have been thoroughly enjoyed .We've had their delicious and unique specialty salads, their personal pizzas, and a few other chicken, eggplant and pasta dishes ...all were very good...So if you're looking for great food, with great service give yourselves a treat and stop by Manninos 3 in Hamilton Square NJ. You won't be disappointed !Rumolo and the staff are all very pleasant, hard working and very acommodating.“

“This place has really good pizza. On my way back to Boston I was craving pizza and say this spot in the map and decided to try it. The customer service was really good, I got one plain cheese slice and one bacon ranch and man oh man were they delicious. Thanks guys.“

“Excellent customer service! We ordered delivery for the first time and I did not realize that there was something in my dish that I am not able to eat (it was not listed o. The menu). I called the restaurant and they remade the dish for me and had it re-delivered very quickly. The person I spoke to on the phone was great and driver was very nice as well.“

“Sabrina's Pizza & Catering is a must-visit for anyone who loves delicious Italian food. Located in the heart of East Windsor. this restaurant has a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for a relaxed dinner with family and friends. I recently had the pleasure of dining at Sabrina's and was blown away by the quality of their food. Their garlic knots with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce is finger-licking good.To start, we ordered the garlic knots, which were soft, chewy, and covered in just the right amount of garlic butter. For our main course, we tried the classic Margherita pizza, which was simply divine. The crust was crispy, the tomato sauce was perfectly seasoned, and the mozzarella cheese was melted to perfection. We also tried the chicken Alfredo pasta, which was creamy and flavorful, with perfectly cooked chicken and al dente pasta.In addition to their delicious food, Sabrina's also offers excellent customer service. Our server was attentive, friendly, and helpful in making recommendations. The prices were also reasonable for the high-quality food and service that we received.Overall, I highly recommend Sabrina's Pizza & Catering to anyone who loves authentic Italian food. The atmosphere is cozy, the food is delicious, and the service is excellent. Whether you're looking for a casual night out or a special occasion, Sabrina's is the perfect spot.“

“Food and service here are great. Everyone from base comes here. Not everyone sits and eats but is usually a pick up and go. Food is made fresh from what I can tell. They have an open salad bar option which is cool. It's a nice spot to have a quick bite if you want or enjoy on the go.Parking: During lunch hours, the parking lot can become full very quick. And it's a little tight to navigate. Usually you do find a spot but it's not like you pull right into one.“

“They have awesome customer service skills and will customize orders to make it however you ask. Their food is consistently good and they are always kind! They also support the local schools and fundraisers! Thank you very much Red Star Staff!“

“Went here and got a cheese pizza to assess their basic pizza quality compared to other local pizzerias. The pizza was quite satisfying, due to its nicely salted and appropriately greasy cheese. Crust had good texture, but could have presented more flavor. Service is quick, ambiance is comfortable albeit outdated. Overall would definitely recommend.“