50 Best Bakeries near Pompton Lakes

“Best Crumb Buns and Meltaways.
Great local bakery, has a bit of everything, Love the crumb buns, by 2 dozen and ship to my family living in Florida, they love em. Meltaway Rings are huge and delicious. I buy them all the time, also bring to parties, and gatherings everyone loves em.“

“This is my favorite coffee shop in the world. The atmosphere is so cozy and inviting and the owner Annabelle is SO sweet. The food is delicious and the best latte I have ever had (did I mention she makes all the syrups homemade???!!) I spent almost every day here studying when I was in school and it truly feels like home in there! Such a beautiful community and the best cafe around“

“Love, Love, Love Magpie Bakery! Should have posted this a couple of weeks ago to let everyone know what an absolutely beautiful job they did with the delicious Woodland Creatures 1/2 sheet cake for my daughter’s baby shower! Wow! It was so moist and tasty, received so many compliments from the ladies. And you know we ladies love our cakes! The decorator created an over-the-top adorable woodland creatures design. Even the gluten free cupcakes were tasty and gorgeous. Kudos to the entire staff and owner. Everyone was so helpful and lovely. Would highly recommend this bakery when you want the best! Thank you to everyone there.“

“Thank you for your generous donation to Glen Rock High School! The desserts were delicious! Can’t wait to go back and pick up some more desserts for my family!“

“The kunafe is so good with the ice cream on top of the kunafe you should try it especially with Zubeyir 5 star service“

“This place is absolutely amazing . I drive almost an hour away to get cookies from them . If your in the area or want to take a ride you should stop by and give them a try...“

“The best bagel and breakfast spot in the state! Their food is amazing and so is the service.“

“Great sweets and very friendly knowledgeable staff answering all our questions. Highly recommend and I will return.“

“The best spot after a winter hike in Harriman. Got a fresh baked banana cream pie for the family and a black and white cookie. Such a wonderful assortment of items and staff was very friendly. My favorite was saying hi to the gentle giant Goliath who is the sweetest doggo. Will definitely be back!“

“I ordered a FRESH, delicious Birthday Cake for my mom's 86 birthday party yesterday. This cake was so good with fresh strawberries inside. You get what you pay for and she is local. Highly recommended. 845-533-4039“

“My son’s Lego Birthday Cake was a home run. The cake was delicious and definitely fresh. The cake was moist and the filling was smooth. All of the guests commented how great the cake tasted. The design of the cake exceeded our expectations. Thank You, We Bake Fresh for making my son’s birthday extra special. We will be recommending you to our friends and family.“

“Absolutely the best bagel there is. Each one no matter the flavor is a delight. And their food that they put on the bagel is delicious. Get there before 3;30 PM if you want sliced cheese because they close the slicer at 3;30. I know if I get there at 3;32 PM the slicer is off. So I get tuna fish instead and it’s about as good as it gets. The staff is friendly and do a good job. What a place!“

“Decor is vibrant, colorful, and casual. Lots of places to sit. Staff is always super friendly and very helpful for explaining things. Lots of personal attention if you have questions about the food or any allergy issues. A lot of times, staff have offered to get me things fresh out of the oven. Their pan de queso and pastries are absolutely some of the best I’ve had anywhere. I usually come for a morning coffee and a snack, and have not had a chance to try their short rib soup. But based on how good it looks, it is very high on my list for a lunch meal.“

“Their chocolate silk cake is the best chocolate cake I have ever had from a bakery! It is truly decadent. Every time I bought one it was obvious that it was made fresh.“

“We just received our holiday order of Colombe, Panettone and holiday cookies. Thank you Palazzone family for your help with our selections.

It doesn't get any more authentic than the Italian specialties available at Palazzone 1960. Everything from the zeppole di San Giuseppe to the holiday panettone, delicious coffees and the Giancarlo Palazzone is truly a master at his craft. Those visiting should be aware that the cafe is closed on Mondays, and that everyday is good for amaretti cookies. Looking forward to my next visit or order.“

“Thanks for my custom cake it looked amazing and was a HUGE Hit!“

“Thank you all Nouri brothers and family always great and kind people and delicious Middle Eastern food 🥰❤️ God bless you all“

“Isaura’s gf baked breads are delicious and have a great crust. I’ve tried several of their cookies which are also pretty tasty!“

“Had the opportunity to go in last week and holy carp, I cannot wait to go back. If you get any cookie dough, I suggest eating it raw at room temperature. The cinnamon toast crunch glam cookie was incredible. The owner was also in while I was there and she was lovely. All around gold star for this place.“

“This place is both a bakery and an Iranian grocery store. They bake fresh sangak bread, which I get from here regularly.
I also buy fresh herbs, pickles, and most of my Iranian products from this store. Everything is very fresh and they carry good-quality brands.
The owner is kind and professional. I highly recommend this place.“

“I drive past hot bagel every day for the past couple of years and never knew it was there. Stopped in on Tuesday, got an everything bagel with olive cream cheese, and by far the best bagel I’ve ever had. Today I stopped and got a ham, egg and cheese, and again best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had. You now have a very happy new customer.“

“I needed a last-minute lifeline and called to see if they could have a cake ready in 30 minutes. Mamma came through and whipped one up for me on the spot. It was decorated nicely, cost $40, and was exactly what I needed. She was super friendly and made the whole process quick and easy. In and out with no stress. Highly recommend this bakery, especially for last-minute birthday saves.“

“The pita is still warm from the oven. Beautiful soft pillows of perfection. The hummus is freshly made here and delicious too. Get a package of both and just start eating. Worth a trip to Paterson. The staff is always so kind and pleasant too.“

“Amerika’da kahvaltı yaptıığım tatlı yediğim en güzel mekanlardan bir tanesi kesinlikle tavsiye ediyorum. Türkiye’deki lezzetleri buraya taşımışlar resmen. Ve ayrıca kendinizi evinizdeymiş gibi hissedebileceğiniz tek mekan ?“

“Every item I purchase at this bakery is sensational. I have bought cookies for little ones and adults, cakes for friends and family and everyone loves them. The staff is friendly and very helpful when deciding sizes of cakes and selections for various functions . You will always be satisfied as this bakery does it right! Debra Eckert -Casha“

“If you have not tried Nothing Bundt Cakes yet you have to. Have heard about them for months and finally tried today...OMG...worth it!!! Find the location nearest you and give taste...you will love!!! They even give instructions on the website for when to eat after purchase and how to store extra if not finished that day.“

“Beautiful custom cookies for an engagement party! Everyone loved them and SO DELICIOUS! Definitely ordering cookies for the bridal shower next year!! 5 stars!“

“taskin bakery best of the best furkan very friendly good service everything so fresh and testing delicious“

“Tried Half Baked for the first time last weekend. Friendly staff and AMAZING cookies! Much better and BIGGER than “you know who”. My Daughter absolutely loved every one we tried. We bought a four pack and were sad we didn’t try the guava one. We will be back next weekend looking forward to the new selection!“

“Súper pan!! Fresco, Empanadas, pasteles, buñuelos, pan coco y café rico☕“

“Huge shout out to Il Dolce for doing my granddaughters Christening cake. It was outstanding. So delicious My favorite Bakery“

“💯 x siento recomendado hace unos días compré una torta d vainilla y estaba súper rica“

“Love this place the food the service the atmosphere!“

“Kat made the most amazing birthday cake for my daughter! It looked stunning, tasted even better, and was the highlight of the whole party. She’s so easy to work with, and the whole process was seamless and stress-free. Moist, flavorful, and beautifully decorated—everyone was raving about it. Highly recommend Kat for any special occasion!“

“thank you mr cupcake for providing our mini GF cake and cupcakes. the order was easily placed in Brick. the order was comfirmed closer to our date. the order was delivered to our venue on time. our guests loved the variety of flavors. ♡♡♡“

“Baladna Bakery is really amazing! My children love their pies, especially the cheese pies. They are tasty, easy to eat, and perfect to take to school, it is very healthy and an excellent choice.

Everything is fresh, and the staff is very kind. I highly recommend Baladna Bakery to anyone who wants delicious Middle Eastern food!“

“muy buen vizcocho me gusto mucho“

“Much more than a bakery. The bakery is the star of the show, but they also have a lot other Italian goods you can shop amongst the shelves. They have a bakery section for bread and they also have some gelato and it looks like they're preparing to have a few other sections as well.

It was packed when we went but they have a pretty decent parking lot and most people were in line for baked goods. We got a bunch of things and all of them were delicious. The cannolis were delicious and sweet and I want to go back for more. The lace cookies were also great and they even have really good brownies.

They packed our stuff up in nice bags and boxes and we brought it home to share with family and it was a hit.

Constructive criticism: the two younger employees who were running the bakery counter seemed a little overwhelmed and mildly grumpy. Maybe they just needed a little more assistance or it had been a long day but I'm just putting it out there that it could use a little bit of improvement.“

“Just recently raised my review from 3 to 4 stars. The cookies and mini pastries are spectacular. Will have to work my way through the cakes next. Might up it to five stars. The macarons were a bit less crisp than my wife would have liked, but I blame that on the humidity and transport (I took too long enjoying the sunshine, nothing against the bakery), otherwise they were wonderful.“

“thank you mr cupcake for providing our mini GF cake and cupcakes. the order was easily placed in Brick. the order was comfirmed closer to our date. the order was delivered to our venue on time. our guests loved the variety of flavors. ♡♡♡“

“Todo muy rico....volveremos...el turron peruano riquisimo.“

“Palazome Bakery on Main Street is an absolute must-visit!

All the pastries and cakes are simply too good to miss. Ms. Nicoletta is always a delight to see—her kindness and welcoming nature keep me coming back time and again. I’ve been visiting this bakery for over four years, and it’s become a must-stop spot every time I’m home.“

“Excelente servicios y un personal capacitado. Lo recomiendo 1000 x 1000!“

“This place is fantastic. Insane variety of infused foods. They even have slushy machines. Eli was super informative and helpful. Prices are already incredibly reasonable for the dosages, but check the sales bin at the front for half off deals“

“This is one of my favorite food places. The bakery goods are fantastic. Bagels are made on premises and if you get lucky, you can get them fresh out of the oven.

Though not high end dining, this restaurant checks the boxes. Food is excellent. Staff is friendly and helpful. It is not fair to rate the atmosphere on the same plane as the other two. It’s not fancy but quite functional. Especially since it’s usually utilized as a take out place. Most of the time, I’m passing through. I phone in my order and pick it up shortly after. BTW, the tuna and chicken salads are to die for. Maybe the best I’ve ever had. The egg salad is no slouch either.“

“pozole y quesadillas tacos bistek“

“OMG, Dominic is the Best so kind & helpful! His Gluten free line is amazing and different. From the Chic Pea Pasta that our daugther loves to the Rice Pasta to the Gluten free breadcrumbs yummy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The cookies & desserts are to die for! The bread is so tasty nothing like in the store. Our daugther was diagnosed with Celiac disease in Jan. We where besides ourselves trying ot find a fresh line of Pasta and bread products that she would not only love but accept. Bravo to Sogni Dolci for making the best Gluten free Products! Five stars from the FINN Family! BRAVO!!!!!!!“

“Best Sweet Potato Pie on the planet. I have eaten them all and this one out of Paterson NJ is the best by far. My family has been buying them for the past 25 years. And it's the same as it tasted 25 years ago. They now have a banana pudding that's out of this world. Can't wait to taste whatever else they develop“

“If you’re looking for the most delicious pastries, you have to try Mo & Jay's baked goods! I just had the most amazing cookies, and they were hands down the best I’ve ever had—perfectly baked, so flavorful, and absolutely addictive. If you haven’t tried her pastries yet, you’re seriously missing out! Highly recommend!“

“I love this bagel place. My family (my dad especially) has ordered here for years, since I was a child! I continue to go. Such a convenient location. The employees are so lovely! It gets busy, but it’s ok. I love the flavored coffee!!!! It’s great.“