19 Best Sandwich Shops near Randolph

“He toasted my sub even tho I said no toast and I asked for olive oil and vinegar but I only saw vinegar put on it. Maybe if he didn't have that ear peice in he can hear me better place my order. Too bad he won't get a second chance. Edit: turns out the toasted sub with my other choices made the sub tastes good. I recant what I said even tho it's not what I wanted it still tasted good“

“I recently visited Charley’s Cheesesteaks and had their Philly cheesesteak- it was beyond awesome! The steak was tender and perfectly seasoned, paired with melted cheese that elevated the flavor. The bread was fresh and soft, holding everything together without being too heavy. Every bite was a burst of flavor, and you could tell the ingredients were top-notch. The portion size was satisfying. The staff was friendly and efficient, making the whole experience even better. If you're a cheesesteak lover, Charley’s is a must-try! I’ll definitely be coming back to try more from their menu.“

“Fresh, delicious a very friendly atmosphere! Just what we needed in this area. Can’t wait to tell the family!“

“Thank you so much for honoring our Nurses during Nurses week! We appreciate you! The food was delicious 😋“

“Sandwiches are delicious. So many varieties and all scrumptious. Great value for the price!“

“These sandwiches Are creative and delicious. All the different choices make it had to decide but you can’t go wrong with any of them. Place is usually busy but they are now open until 6:30 pm. Prices are fair for the value. The Gossip Girl is my new favorite. Order ahead.“

“I kept seeing the “Let Mike Have His Way” trend all over TikTok, so I walked in and said, “Giant number 13, and go ahead, let Mike have his way with my sub.”

And honestly? Best decision I’ve made all week.

The sandwich I got felt like it was made by someone who really knows what they’re doing. The flavors, the textures, the layering—it all worked together so perfectly. The bread was warm and soft, packed with fresh, flavorful meats, crisp veggies, and just the right amount of juice. I didn’t even know what I was getting into, but every bite had me thinking, “This is exactly how a sub should taste.”

Letting Mike have his way took all the pressure off ordering and turned the whole experience into a fun surprise—and somehow it still ended up being one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had. You can tell there’s real skill behind the counter.“

“My favorite sandwich shop in NJ! Great food and good service!“

“They make my favorite tuna & egg salad and so much more. They also have the best bagels.“

“Best little hometown deli! If you need a quick breakfast sandwich lunch or snack this is the place to stop in while getting your gas tank filled at the BP next door! Can’t beat their prices for the quality and portion of food you receive. They are very friendly when you walk in and always remember you when you return! They’re a small mom and pop deli that should most definitely be patroned. A favorite of ours is the bacon egg and cheese sandwich for breakfast. School kids also love this deli as they all stop in after school for a mid afternoon snack and sometimes morning breakfast. A fantastic on the go breakfast/lunch/snack/coffee/drink to go! Play the lottery here too!“

“I love Mr. Donkey! Friendly service and GREAT food.“

“Best sub sandwiches. Friendly staff!“

“The owners are fantastic and make you feel appreciated as their guests. Food is cooked with love and you can taste it.“

“The three individuals working there today at 1pm were not only professional but a very well oiled machine. Communication with constructive feedback when error occurred while immediately implementing the correction for future orders. They worked together to get mobile orders and in person orders out immediately. There was no wait. They were awesome and definitely deserve recognition and a raise!“

“very good! i found a new hoagie place! conveniently located by shop rite.“

“Big THANK YOU to Jersey Mike’s Subs for supporting healthcare workers!“

“I go in every Wednesday for the primo size deal and every week I’m greeted by shawn and he knows the 2 things i usually order and makes them exactly how i want every time and always has a cheery upbeat attitude and always makes my orders quickly“

“Guys, it’s multiple plays on grilled cheese sandwiches late at night. This isn’t supposed to be classy or fine dining. It’s the cheesy indulgent cheat food you want late at night after the bar. Because I’ve been here often with the bar crowd, you might wait a bit depending on the night, but it’s to be expected with a popular place like this. But give me a Mac and cheese sandwich with tomato soup at the end of the night, and you hit the comfort and nostalgia sweet spot.

Vegetarian options: It’s grilled cheese, so it’s easy enough to side step the meat.“

“I love their vegan bakery and they even sometimes have vegan prepared food like vegan soy chicken or meatballs. They usually have a packaged soup that’s chik’n orzo vegetable, and I enjoy it, but it hasn’t been there recently (nor have the prepared vegan foods). The hot bar is not vegan friendly. They have lots of produce and vegan alternatives such as frozen foods like ice cream and frozen meals. They have a wide selection of vegan cheeses and vegan dairy, lots of vegan supplements and protein powders, and fun new items every week. They have lots of vegan crunchy snacks like Hippeas and Vegan Rob’s. It is definitely expensive, but I don’t think that will stop me from going here.“