17 Best Ice Cream Shops near Roxbury

“Absolutely the best ice cream place I’ve ever had in my life…“

“love their flavors. this is high quality artisanal gelato. it's the best in miles, by far.“

“Hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had! I’ve been out of the area for over a year and was just checking to see about getting some shipped to Florida, but it doesn’t seem so! I’m a Grahamsterdam and Chocolate Cake girl. Must try this place if you’re in North Jersey — so, so good!“

“If you’re looking for the best ice cream in Morris County, look no further! Sundaes ice cream is delicious, and there is a flavor for everyone! The owners are super nice and generous, too!“

“Have been a customer for 40 years. Great owner and staff, good food, friendly atmosphere. What else is there to say?“

“Excellent ice cream, but expensive.
They are always busy, they deliver a great product, but just under $6 for a small cone or $8 for a waffle cone is not worth it.
I have a background in business and understand market pricing. Considering that there are always customers, but that the lines are no longer out the door and down the road making service faster maybe it's a good business decision. And I like supporting local Mom and Pop stores, however if I can buy a pint of the best national brands for less than the cost of a single cone then you've limited business to special occasions.“

“PEANUT ALLERGY FAMILY!! Let me start off by saying I love love loved the ice cream here from day 1. The staff is wonderful and super attentive, but last night was above and beyond. I went for dessert with my oldest son and wanted to bring some back for my 8 month old to share with me. We just discovered my 8 month old has a peanut allergy and we aren’t sure what other nuts he might be allergic to yet. I told the staff all of this. The gentleman who made my order went ABOVE AND BEYOND to make sure that ice cream was safe to share with him (of course I know there are no guarantees when you are eating out). I can’t tell you how much that meant to me since allergies like this are new to my family and I. I cannot thank them enough!! They gained a customer for life.“

“Sara of ColdStone ice cream, you were a delight tonight. I’m so sorry my order was insane you made my birthday night a special night. You made everything on a fast manner. My cake batter milkshake thing you made was interesting. Add it to the menu and call it the Chris!! But have a great night enjoy my thank you gesture.“

“Rita's Ice Cream is a delightful treat that truly hits the spot on a hot summer day! The selection of flavors is fantastic, and each one is packed with creamy goodness. I particularly loved their unique Italian ice, which offered a refreshing burst of fruity flavors. The service was friendly and efficient, making the overall experience even better. Whether you're a fan of classic favorites or adventurous tastes, Rita's Ice Cream is a must-visit for any ice cream lover. Highly recommended! ??“

“Loved ordering via the mobile app. My walk in and out time was less than 1 minute. Customer service was great & quick. Will definitely recommend for anyone who’s on the run looking to grab and go. I ordered: Dirty Cake, peanut butter ft. Reese’s Pieces & THE BLUE MONSTER Ft. Chips Ahoy ???“

“Love their custard but they really need to give the customer what they pay for. $5 for a large and they fill it like it's a small. My second issue with this place; consistency is key.“

“This location is so nice and clean and people are friendly and accommodating. I get cakes here for Birthdays and coffee at times. Very pleased. Denise , Long Valley 🥰☕💞🎂“

“Update.....they refunded me for the cake. Great customer service.

Ordered a cake (and me and my daughter had ice cream) a few weeks ago and paid cash. Ice cream server who was working the counter and eating her chipolte salad at the register said I didn't need a receipt. Picked up cake today and had to pay for it again because it wasn't marked 'paid'. Maybe take a 'break' and eat in the back room and pay attention to your customers. Not happy and will not return. Cake is nicely decorated and good but not worth paying double.“

“My favorite place to stop at on the lake for an ice-cream. We usually paddle up to the docks on our SUPs (stand up paddleboard). Grab a cone of real (Jefferson Dairy I believe) ice-cream and then back on the lack for some awesome paddling.
Highly recommended for a quick bite, all kinds of tchotchkes, signs, toys, games and a bunch of other stuff that I believe are locally made. It's a must visit, especially for those that want to revisit simpler times.“

“Their ice cream is always good we enjoy going there.😊“

“Smaller then other locations but still plenty of choices. The location was clean, staff friendly. If you have not been to these types of places beware that its sold by weight. So whatever you load up on your frozen yogurt will be added to the charge. You can get a $3 frozen yogurt or a $10+ it adds up quickly. I personally love the sorbet but the frozen yogurt is great too.“

“Although they're vanilla, it's not as good as the old carvel vanilla, it is still good and the chocolate is just as creamy and good as anywhere. They offer a wide variety of products from hot dogs to huge sundays. Service is always good but may take some time if they have a long line and are very busy most likely in the summer. As someone else noted, they don't seem to honor some of the promotions or deals. The dairy queen central offers, but I really don't care about that. It's just a very good old fashioned treat.That's as good today as it was in the past.“