50 Best Bakeries near Tenafly

“Delicious Caesar salad, chicken pot pie (and chocolate donut). Coffee was really good too.“

“Best mochinuts I’ve had!! Great place, super friendly staff and amazing food and drinks!! I love this place!!“

“I loved my experience today. Merry Christmas! The friendly staff to start. I ordered the French Onion Soup which was absolutely delicious. The bread 🥖 was really great too!! ❤️“

“This place is truly great! The food is delish and the atmosphere is so cozy. The workers Sarah and Kelly were so kind and helpful, made the experience great. They are both so sweet and were working super hard both serving customers and cleaning up, definitely deserve a raise! Love this bakery and everything about it! Make sure you visit and get some cookies“

“Orly at Bread Boutique just catered our brunch backyard wedding. Everything came out delicious and everyone mentioned how good the food was. I recommend the burekas, kale and cranberry salad, and the cookies (especially the macaroons). Orly was easy to reach and we are very happy we went with her company for catering.“

“It was my first time going to Kingston Bakery I walked I was greated with a smile by staff customer service means a lot to me I'm not a meat eater but I ordered 2 veggie patties I was blown away the crust it was so fresh I don't care for spicy but the veggies patty had just enough kick and and the veggies were tasty that was the best patty I have EVER eaten then I order the cinnamon bun not 2 sweet but just enough sweet to it with cinnamon raisins it's was delicious I will definitely go back again 5 stars from me“

“The best macaroons. The crème brûlée and Ferrero rocher were my favs!“

“If you’re ever in the Bronx and you don’t stop at Gino’s Pastry Shop, you’re missing out on a piece of real New York history. This Arthur Avenue staple has been serving up authentic Italian pastries for decades, and it’s exactly what you want from an old-school bakery — no frills, just flavor and tradition. The cannoli? Legendary. They fill them fresh to order, and the shells are crisp, flaky perfection with creamy ricotta that tastes like it was whipped up by someone’s Nonna in the back. The sfogliatelle and lobster tails are equally iconic — sweet, buttery, and loaded with filling. Don’t sleep on the rainbow cookies either — they’re dense, almondy, and always spot-on. The shop itself is cozy, with that classic Italian-American charm. Gino and the crew treat you like family, whether it’s your first time or your fiftieth. Prices are super fair for the quality, and it’s cash-only — so come prepared. Bottom line: Gino’s isn’t just a pastry shop, it’s a Bronx institution. Worth the trip, worth the calories, and worth every bite.“

“Mojo, the best Belgian mousse in New York! Very nice atmosphere over there!“

“Great cupcakes and excellent service!“

“Delicious empanadas, and desserts! More than just cakes, stop in for a delicious treat like I did!!“

“Great people and the best rugelach on the planet.“

“Beautifully decorated and simply delicious custom order cake. Everyone asked where the cake came from. pleasure to work with staff.“

“love this place! the people are very nice and friendly“

“My opinion is 8.7/10. Is it the best Jamaican beef patty I've ever had? No but overall our place that makes handmade Jamaican beef patties with a good overall flavor I recommend it. Best thing definitely has to be the crust I just wish for $3 it was a little bit more meat / seasoning. Check out my in depth video reviews on any of the platforms below. TikTok: TheUrbanLegend4 Instagram: UrbanLegend4 Facebook: Panayoti Kokalis YouTube: Urban Legend“

“Yummy, delicious, flavorful cookies, and friendly staff. We stood in line outside as they were super busy, but so worth it!“

“their mini's are just so good. good enuff that you don't even miss the crust.“

“My friend picked up an assortment of treats for my birthday, everything was so delicious✨Red velvet cupcake and The pistachio thingy were my favorites❣️Have to go soon & try more treats🥰“

“I absolutely love this place.The monster cookie ice cream fire the best.Ice cream.They have the chocolate fountain is so cool.Don't get me started on the customer service.Ohh, my god, they remember you and they make you feel very special.I love this place and you will love it too.Trust me,“

“these are incredibly delicious and the staff is so fun and friendly!“

“Used to go the Mount Vernon shop when I was a kid, then after the fire and they moved to the Bronx..followed them down there- EVEN when the current owner bought from the gentile older man from MV... "Paul" has kept up standards. The Coco Breads are THE BOMB - I'd know, I was taught to make them at the bakery my Granny worked in Mo'bay every summer! A MUST HAVE !!!! Go out of your way. Brave the parking situation. DO IT, you will not regret it!“

““Life is tough sometimes. This experience always gives me JOY. The people are amazing and the treats are the best I have ever had.”“

“This has to be the best Burek in town.“

“The owner Erika was a pleasure to work with. Super helpful with choosing the right size cake. Designed the cake better than the picture I sent. The cross and rosary were so realistic it’s hard to believe it’s sugar. Not only was it a gorgeous cake but so fresh and delicious!“

“A sweet little bakery with amazingly delicious desserts.“

“The Pie crust cookies are amazing and I loved the toffee cookie even more!!“

“Such a lovely place! The breakfast was fresh and delicious, and the pastries were amazing. Everyone was so kind and welcoming — you really feel the Turkish hospitality. Great food, great people, and a really cozy atmosphere. Definitely coming back! 🇹🇷✨“

“maravilloso lugar para ir en familia o solo, es un lugar cálido, que irradia paz y la comida es deliciosa!!! Dios los bendiga 🙏🏻🥰“

“Best tres leches in the world so soft & well made that you can really enjoy the flavors! The cake itself is Delicious I been a big fan of this tres leches for many years now & wouldn't change it for no other.“

“Excellent place!!! Everything is top- notch!!! Highly recommended!“

“Everything in Rispoli is delicious! Can't beat their lobster tails! We drive 90min each way every time we have a Rispoli craving and bring their cookies and pastries to our friends in central jersey. Next week we're shipping cookies to Oregon! I have a feeling it will become a regular occurrence. Thanks for never disappointing us!“

“I love Zeppieri's Bakery. The lobster tails are the best and they make seasonal cupcakes and cookies that are out of this world. The bread is the absolute best!!!! The ladies at the counter are kind, even when super busy, polite and knowledgable always cheerful and sweet. I adore this neighborhood gem!“

“Experience was great!“

“Thank you so much for making our engagement cupcake cake! Not only was it beautiful, it was SO delicious!! 😍“

“This place is just amazing! There were 5 of us and we all ordered something different. Everything we got was delicious- we all tried each other's dishes. There's a little bit of everything to satisfy even the pickiest eater. I would just drive her (over a 2 hour drive for me) just to come eat here. I need this place closer to home, lol.“

“Thank you Veriella’s Bakery and Cafe for this awesome cake for my son’s 10th birthday. He was so happy! Can’t thank you enough!“

“How much do I love their bakery? I drove from Orange County, NY to pick up 3 dozen Black and white cookies to bring to a party in Massachussets. That is how yummy this bakery is!!!! The staff is just as sweet as the desserts.“

“Ordered a coconut cloud cake a week ago for my in-laws 35th wedding anniversary. It was the best gluten and dairy free cake I’ve ever had. You wouldn’t even know that it wasn’t a regular cake. I put the order over the phone and it was ready for pick up within 10 minutes. while a little bit pricey it was worth every penny. Will definitely be back.“

“Amazing affordable baked goods.“

“I need to say that Renee and Carrie are amazing! Very amazing service, being able to be answered in French at the boutique was amazing! I drove twice in 2 days to grab cupcakes and cookies… I cannot say what’s my favourite out of the cupcake, the brownies, the cookies etc because everything was decadent and not too sweet. You taste the quality of the ingredients and the love they put while cooking them. The fact that Carrie was answering me while the business is close is a sign that she’s passionate and that she care about her client. They’re on the expensive side compared to other bakery, but once you compare you understand why… You taste the butter in everything! If you like some fluffy, moist, creamy cupcake this is your place… While planning my wedding, I’ve compared a few bakery and non are as good as this one… Thank you for the amazing experience and taste!“

“Erie is amazing. Highly recommend - coffee is absolutely the best - lattes and all different flavors - hot and cold! The banana bread is my favorite but All of the different baked goods are to die for! Never had anything but excellent here. The owners and the baristas and ALL of the staff are friendly and truly provide the BEST service! If I lived in Rutherford I’d be here every day!“

“Excellent quiche and delicious cappuccino“

“Madison Fare: A Gourmet Marketplace That Delights Every Sense

Whenever I’m in NYC I always go to my favorite store Madison Fare. I can’t say enough good things about this vibrant culinary haven. Owned and lovingly curated by Amin Kinana. This gourmet marketplace is a treasure trove of prepared foods, artfully assembled gift baskets, and, believe it or not, some of the most delightful frozen yogurt I’ve ever tasted. All the prepared food is delicious and made by Amin himself who in a previous life was a gourmet chef.

From the moment I step inside, I am greeted by an inviting, warm atmosphere that truly captures the eclectic energy of New York City. The store’s offerings are as diverse as they are delectable…whether you’re craving a hearty, chef-inspired prepared meal, looking for the perfect gift basket to celebrate a special occasion, or just in need of a refreshing scoop of frozen yogurt, Madison Fare delivers with flair.

What really sets Madison Fare apart is Amin’s passion and personal touch. His commitment to quality shines through in every product, and you can tell that each item is selected with care. Amin isn’t just running a store; he’s curating an experience, one that celebrates the art of food and the joy of sharing it with others.

If you’re in NYC and in search of a gourmet experience that goes beyond the ordinary, make sure to stop by Madison Fare. It’s more than just a marketplace, it’s a celebration of flavor, community, and the simple pleasure of good food. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this is one culinary destination you won’t want to miss. You can also order online if you don’t have time to go the store and want the perfect gift or snack.“

“Fantastic, good quality gf options! Lovely store front with both amazing gluten free options (scones, cookies, bread, sandwich’s, and other goodies!) and a cafe with coffees, teas, matcha). I always look forward to visiting.“

“I walked into this café because I was drawn to its beautiful aesthetic, and I couldn’t have made a better choice.

The pastries were freshly baked and absolutely delicious, and the whole place is filled with natural light and lovely details. It has such a calm, welcoming vibe that makes you want to stay for a while.

My favs: Dulcey Cafe Cylinder and Paris Brest 🥐

A true hidden gem on the Upper West Side!🤍“

“8/17/25, 7pm

I got their Levain a la mode- you choose any cookie and pair it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. I got the dark chocolate chocolate chip cookie, which was $5.75 and the scoop of vanilla ice cream was $4.75. So in total I paid $10.50 for the cookie and ice cream combo. The cookie was fresh, soft, and gooey and reminded me of a brownie! I wish they have more ice cream flavors in the future :)“

“This cake literally saved my birthday.
I have loved cake since I was young but got recently diagnosed with celiac. For my 25th birthday I really wanted something special. She was able to put wording on my cake and it tasted so gooood holy moly!
This is one if not the best cake I’ve ever had in my life. I will absolutely be back. 10000/10“

“I came here with the intention of just checking it out for a possible baker for my wedding cake. I met with Mena who is absolutely amazing. Her warmth, care and charisma just radiate. She helped my fiancé and I pick wedding cake flavors, made suggestions and gave us samples. Her Bavarian cream is out of this world. We ended up getting a lobster tail when we were leaving. I swear on everything I love that was the best thing I had in a LONG time. It was crisp, yet soft and as big as my hand filled from top to bottom with the Bavarian cream. I see why it’s so highly recommended and I’m upset it took me so long to come! This will now be my bakery of choice. I even watched her and all the staff interact and dish out the same warmth and to every customer that came it. I see why they are a staple in the community and I’m so excited for my new don’t cake. I will update with pics. Oh and most importantly the worked without budget, I felt relief when I left that I don’t have to look anymore. If you’re thinking of coming here don’t, just come. You won’t regret it.“

“Thank you Again Tee. The cake was delicious , I loved the design and coloring. Got 6-7 more orders I’ll be placing very soon. Thanks again sis your the Goat.“

“Iconiq Upper West Side grocery with Jewish roots. Smoked fish, bagels, coffee to die for. Everything is high quality but expensive. Lots of international foods under store label. Ready food is exceptional. Store is narrow, dense and packed. Not your typical bland supermarket. It's more like Deli on steroids. Highly recommended!“