20 Best Mexican Restaurants in Toms River

1 Margaritas Mexican Restaurant

4.5 Superb 502 Reviews

270 NJ-37, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“thanks to the polite waitress and manager that took care of us last night... have a few too many Doms. They are the best and really hot the spot if you're looking to get a buzz... After our night of getting smashed we got cut off, and manager even gave us a ride to the hotel across the street. so thanks again for taking the time to truly care about your patrons....”

2 Beach Tacos & Tequila

4.9 Superb 91 Reviews

1137 Fischer Boulevard, Toms River

“Great little Mexican spot! Food and drinks are awesome….our waitress Cheryl was amazing! She gave us some great suggestions on drinks and food choices all of which did not disappoint! Such a great job on the decor. All around great experience. We will definitely be back! Ask for Cheryl!!”

3 CHAVELITA'S RESTAURANT AUTHENTIC MEXICAN FOOD

4.7 Superb 80 Reviews

2039 NJ-37, Toms River

“Authentic as it gets. You can taste how fresh everything is, and knowing it’s family-owned makes it even better. The food was incredible — easily the best Mexican I’ve ever had. Can’t wait to go back!”

4 El Familiar

4.5 Superb 269 Reviews

1246 NJ-166, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have been loyal since day one! Nobody beats the food, the service, the family atmosphere. Simply the best 💜”

5 El ranchero Mexican Restaurant

4.3 Superb 143 Reviews

950 Hooper Avenue Unit 2, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Muy rico y muy buena asistencia”

6 La Cazuela de Doña Mary

4.3 Superb 126 Reviews

815 Hooper Avenue, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good food, good service, clean and friendly! Delicious!! Thank you!!”

7 Sofia's Taqueria Toms River

4.2 Good 269 Reviews

11 Kettle Creek Road, Toms River

• Delivery

“Just wanted to say thank you for the excellent food for our recent party. The guests were all commenting how delicious and well prepared the food was. It was also more food than we expected, and was very well packed for transport. We’ve enjoyed the experience of dining at Sofia’s, and now also the catered g experience.”

8 Ortega's Mexican Bakery & Restaurant

4.3 Superb 113 Reviews

1822 Hooper Avenue, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great Food and amazing service!”

9 Taco-Tastic

4.2 Good 171 Reviews

207 Main Street, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great addition to Downtown TR's lineup of eateries. The tacos are fantastic. Mexican fries are amazing. I've also never had a Mexican hotdog before and it's a great addition to the menu. The food is always fresh and delicious!”

10 Bubbakoo's Burritos

4.2 Good 169 Reviews

888 Fischer Boulevard, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I wasn't expecting their type of set up. There's a very small space to stay & eat. You order your food (from multiple food options) from a kiosk & when your order is ready your name is called & they hand you your bagged food. I ordered the bacon cheeseburger Detroit style personal pizza (which was delicious). I also ordered brisket just in case I didn't like the pizza. I didn't have the brisket yet. The pizza was plenty & it was great. If I'm ever passing through the area again I would DEFINITELY stop here. Plenty of food options to choose from.”

11 Tacoholics

4.3 Superb 115 Reviews

1922 Hooper Ave Ste 2-D, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Always fresh always tasty, everything I’ve ever gotten from them is a 10/10. The quality is always great but the quantity is hit or miss especially with the nachos. Maybe it depends on who’s making them that day. Sometimes its a nice big portion fills the container and sometimes it’s just like they threw some chips in the box slapped on a couple topping and you get half of a container while someone with the same has a full box. 5/10 for that. Prices are reasonable.”

12 El Luchador Mexican Grill

4.4 Superb 16 Reviews

911 Charles Drive, Toms River

“The place is bright, sparkling clean, and cheery, but it’s the food and service that will hook you in to coming back to El Luchador. I had hand-made corn tortillas, stuffed with Mexican Chorizo and Eggs, and an Horchata. So delicious!! A refreshing alternative to all the Fakexican taco places out there. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

13 Taco-Tastic

4.0 Good 248 Reviews

793 Fischer Boulevard, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We love the food from here. Tacos are excellent. Ingredients are fresh. I really like how flexible they are in either adding or taking away something on your taco. Compared to surf taco, taco tastic wins on taste, little more money but you can tell Ingredients and cooking ia more authentic. Highly recommend.”

14 Tenampa

4.0 Good 123 Reviews

1341 US-9, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“love going g to this restaurant. Always a good meal and friendly staff.”

15 El Campesino

4.0 Good 92 Reviews

970 NJ-166, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best follow El Campesino🌮✅”

16 Bubbakoo's Burritos

3.9 Good 230 Reviews

1311 NJ-37, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“atmosphere was great, food was good. I miss this service since Moe's left. I wish their cheese sauce was better. homemade better, it was jarred. straight out of a can. I won't order that again but everything else was great.”

17 Mark's Deli

4.4 Superb 85 Reviews

505 Coolidge Avenue, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The el tata torta extra chipotle is the best.”

18 El Poblano

3.3 Good 78 Reviews

1241 Lakewood Rd, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time here and I've been to so many Mexican food restaurants. By far this is the best. I order huevo a la Mexicana and omg it was delicious. My plate could feed 2 people. The beans are awesome. No more driving to lakewood for Mexican food. I'm staying where I live and it's not far from me. I will be back El Poblano. Que Rica comida. ❤”

19 Guadalupana | Mexican Restaurant

3.7 Good 97 Reviews

1012 Cox Cro Road, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I totally love it here. You will too. From the moment you are seated you feel transported to a land of culinary perfection, warm family- run, friendly staff and a clean bright and cheery atmosphere. Seating is quick; nachos and 2 uncredible spicy salsas are brought right away. I love when salsa like this is so good. The soup is out of this world Chilate de Res huge slabs of tender stew beef with squash and fresh green beans in a mildly spicy tangy tomato broth that will blow away the senses. Served with several hot corn tortillas, cilantro and onions on the side. Molcajete Poblano I can barely describe in full detail but just look at the photo - FRESH MASSIVE shrimps, tender spiced beef, grilled chicken, leeks, cactus, tomatoes, peppers, onions & avocado in a blazing hot fancy pot to ensure it all stays hot. This was amazing- and comes with a huge plate of yellow rice & black beans. Enough for two, as was the soup. They play light Mexican ballads and have a nice sound system for a more enjoyable experience. Prices vs value makes your visit not just inexpensive.. its so reasonable for the sheer volume of food they bring you! My favorite thing is they have the Almost-chocolatey Ice-Cold Tiajuana-Bottled Refreshing Coca-Cola that you have to try at least once in your life! Also the staff.. I was offered everything befire i could even ask. Next the incredible flavors. Lastly: Nothing even matches the authentic FaMiLy-Sized- portions!! THEY OFFER CONTAINERS! Whatever i wrote is just the tip of the iceberg.. We will return to try more fantastic menu choices- again and again!!”

20 Surf Taco - Silverton

3.6 Good 174 Reviews

1887 Hooper Ave, Toms River

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Surf Taco has always been a stable for me. Nothing says the beach like their salsa bar!”