49 Best Pizza Restaurants near Waretown

“If you enjoy a thin well done crispy brick oven baked pizza you’re gonna like Manzano’s.
We have ordered a few times and decided to order 9 pies for a backyard party. We ordered some of their specialty pies as well as a plain pie. The guests at our get-together were highly complimentary on everything. We had a grandma’s pie with pesto and a grandmas pie with fresh Basil and I’m not which was better. Their pie with vodka sauce was great!
The pies were ready coming hot out of the oven and kept in a pizza warmer while they pulled this big order together. Our party guests enjoyed the hot outa the oven pizza!“

“Excellent prices, large portions, always delicious, never disappointed. Highly recommend!“

“Oh my God! My sister ordered delivery for my birthday and it was the BEST chicken francese, omg so delicious. Delivered hot, fresh, friendly and fast. amazing salad, amazing blue cheese dressing PIZZA IS FABULOUS!!! Calzone delicious everything cooked to perfection! This place is ON POINT.“

“Generous, kind family owned businesses. Fabulous food. Imbedded within our community, year after year. To which, you will feel part of OUR COMMUNITY…. Most of all their family love..“

“The Chicken Scarpiello and Chicken Giovanni pasta dishes are absolutely amazing! Today was our first visit. We will be back. Our son recommended this place. We see why. Friendly staff and excellent service.“

“The staff were extremely friendly and welcoming! (: They were very knowledgeable about the LBI area as well. The spinach pizza was fresh, perfectly prepared and delicious! Generous amount of spinach, and the crust was crispy without being too thin or too thick. Pleasantly surprised by the portion of chicken tenders and fries. Great value for the price.The food was served quickly but didn’t feel rushed. We would definitely come back when in the area, and recommend to friends and family. The atmosphere of the pizza shop was very inviting, and has a hometown beach vibe to it. Sunset pizza went above and beyond to satisfy our needs!“

“My 3 year old is autistic and will only eat certain foods which are usually chicken fingers and fries, I recently ordered myself penne in vodka sauce with chicken and to my absolute surprise my son tried a piece of the pasta and ate a whole bowl!! The food is always so flavorful and delicious! Our favorite pizza so far is the Lucy Special! The bread is so light and soft and the meatballs are to die for!! I’ve lived in manahawkin for 3 years and you guys are always our first place to recommend and order from! Their desserts always taste so fresh and those cannolis and cheesecake are to die for!!!! Sincerely, Tackle Ave!“

“I think there is no better place than this!! I love food! 😍💯“

“Kept driving by this place and finally got to try it out last week. As a Chicago native, I can tell you this is what I've been looking for the past 3 years of living here. The crust does not explode in your mouth like a bunch of tiny little splinters, it's softer and doughy. The ingredients and cheese are not skimped out on either, they are fresh ingredients and plentiful at that. The only thing I would change is more sauce, but I can do that myself next order on my own. Leftovers microwaved is a no go but air fried it's just like it came out of the oven all over again. In a Jersey full of Luigi's, pick Marios, you won't be disappointed. I suggest adding the wings into your order as well, best take out wings I've had from a pizza shop, super crispy breading and juicy interior.“

“Pies Place is the best! I have been meaning to leave a review after my son’s birthday party. We ordered a ton of food and had to decrease our order by a lot last minute because of this spring weather. Our party was rained out so we didn’t really need anything. Chris was incredibly sweet and stated although they started making some of our order he would donate what we didn’t need. Not only was the pizza delicious, it was such a nice gesture all around. 10/10 recommend 😋👌🏼☺️“

“Great food. Great friendly service. We go every week during the summer.“

“I recently learned about Pietro's through being a delivery driver with DoorDash and wanted to order food from here. I live in Manahawkin, so I am normally eager to try something new. I ordered a pizza here today, along with Calamari, and the food is not a disappointment. Will come here again in the future.“

“Wow this place is the best in the area. Ask about the loyalty card and don’t take no for an answer 🤫 it’s the real deal.“

“Ashley is a great part to your establishment every knowledgeable of everything you have I seen a sandwich in the glass display sausage peppers onions little sauce on a garlic roll I tried it it was delicious Mr Eligio 🍕“

“I got to say for sorrows is good real good quick delivery times they're honest if they say a certain time they're there but you got to be careful because when it shows up it is real hot real hot and really good food excellent“

“Great thin crust pie & amazing cheese calzone. I asked for extra mozzarella in calzone & it was perfect! Sauce very good. Our first time & will now try their famous Grandma Pie. Definitely our new go to! Thanks guys!“

“Great pizza and nice staff 🥰“

“My worker reconnected this place to me today, he knows the owner well... was my first time there. Food was absolutely amazing, and the owner was a sweetheart, such a doll.... 😊“

“People always sleep on this pizza joint.....Been going to this joint for decades....The pizza is different from all the competitors once you try it you'll understand what I mean "TASTY AND FRESH".....The Sauce Is Like No Other....Bayville Original !! Highly Recommend 💯“

“I have been going to Marchioni’s for years! Actually the first restaurant I fell in love with from moving from California way back in the day. The chicken Marsala was always my go to favorite and now it’s my sons! My husband loves the homemade stuffed shells and now I’m in love with the salmon piccata and the pizza is always perfect! Yum, now I am thinking about it that’s going to be dinner tonight! The owners are amazing and so is the staff, one thing that stands out is the customer service, I recently came to pick up my order and the driver noticed I forgot my bag with salads and brought it to my house without me prompting it ( didn’t even know it was missing yet- and then it hit me to leave this long way overdue review) He made it to my house before I did! I really love love love Marchionis for the food but also for the amazing people making it all happen! Thankful to have them in our community! Andiamo Mangia!“

“We ordered dinner last night, and it was great as usual!! Our food arrived quickly, and it was hot and delicious! We love Ray’s wings (hot and honey are our favorite) and pizza! My family has been ordering from Ray’s for over 5 years, and I don’t think we have ever had a bad meal… everything is consistently good! Ordering is easy and delivery is fast!!“

“Amazing catering for our son’s birthday from start to finish. The team was helpful and reassuring when ordering. Their delivery guy was on time and personable. And we had lots of compliments on food. Thank you Linda’s team!“

“Was dying to try the Detroit pie after seeing the photos in the print ad/menu, and it was delicious! The guy who took my order was so sweet, too, offering great feedback and explanations of the items. Delivery was quick for a Friday night, too.
Now, onto the star of the review: the pizza! The Detroit was delicious - the sauce, cheese and dough were all really good. Price was a bit high but really good pizza and would definitely order again!“

“The worst pizza ? ever had!!!“

“We love this place! The employees are so appreciative, the food has been consistently deliciously, the prices are great and the delivery is quick. What more can you ask for?“

“A+++ Overall excellent experience!! Best pizza I've ever had near any beach! Family owned business and highly accommodating! Custom Made to Order right on the box and absolutely true! Requested a grandma pie made with cheese on bottom, sauce on top (how we're used to back home). Great atmosphere, delicious pizza! This is the place to go! Will be here again our next time down LBI (Surf City)“

“loyal customer for years but the order takers need to pay more attention to the orders over the phone.“

“Everything was delicious. Priced great. Nice atmosphere. Great waitress“

“My favorite pizza in town! Owner Chris is a great guy and hardest working guy I know!“

“Had a exceptional experience with Foodies. Peggy is a pro and so creative with her food. She has such a expansive menu full of delicious options. Our cocktail party was impeccable!! The service was beyond amazing! They were so friendly and warm and really made the day extra special for us.“

“Great Service and Staff. I recently celebrated my graduation party there and the food was amazing. I highly recommend them.“

“This Giant Zeppole filled with Cannoli cream and topped with Nutella was Absolutely Amazing! I shed a tear of Happiness after taking my first bite.“

“Ok so went there for work but fell in love ❤️ A country nitch at the Jersey Shore ⚓️🇮🇹A oldie but goodie !! Food is fantastic!! Some Italian🇮🇹 some seafood 🦀and some all time all American ⚓️🇺🇸Don’t forget the 🍕 Pizza Inside bar outside bar indoor seating and outdoor seating Grounds are beautiful filled with 🌹 Roses and lounge chairs and statues If you haven’t tried this u must !! Laid back and chill and all the employees are awesome ! Special thanks to Kevin“

“We love coming to schianos!! And my girls love love love Joe and Liv!! And there baby pan pizza!! ♥️“

“Incredible pizza with classics, newer styles and creative ideas. The Brooklyn Finest is a must!“

“As new Barnegat residents, we stumbled upon this gem while exploring our local businesses. The mussels marinar did not disappoint! My fiancé ordered the soft shell crab franchese, and was also very pleased. The bartender, Trish, was friendly, attentive, and made an amazing espresso martini. We will definitely be East Bay Italian Grille regulars.“

“We have been going to Black Eyed Susan's since their prior location across the street when it was BYOB and I can't believe it's actually gotten better in terms of menu and the cocktail menu is amazing too. With the addition of Marigold this summer they've reached the next level. We hope to rent it out next year for a private event. Could not recommend it enough if you're on Long Beach Island (or even if you have to drive the bridge)“

“I had my party catered by Schiano’s this past weekend. The food was delicious. The staff were very accommodating and helpful in deciding the menu. Everyone also loved the freshly made bread that was included in our order. Thank you!“

“Our current "post covid" go to restaurant esp since Carlos (and family) took over. Unfortunately, we have not been able to eat in since we are seniors with a couple of medical issues. Even so we are quite impressed with service & food entrées thus far. Salads are good and plenty of (olive oil) bread that is "fresh" unlike a couple of others in the area. We shall try eating in as soon as the flu/Covid/RSV, etc issues lead into a safer season. Recommend the Seafood a la Brother, Calamari and the Chicken Cacciatore.“

“Order a couple of pies and a chicken parm sandwich! Floor was amazing! Solid pizza! Thin crust, nice crisp and the sauce and cheese were flavorful! Thankful to have this place in my neighborhood!“

“Great food! Great service. Warm and cozy. I asked for chocolate martinis, they were perfect.“

“Special dinner sent to injured cousin unable to drive. Through his sister I found out your restaurant is his favorite Italian delivery restaurant. Since he can’t get out, I’m hoping this will be a pleasant and delicious surprise dinner tonight😋
Thanks for your assistance in making this surprise possible for him. He’s obviously not been feeling so good lately! Hope this cheers him up and makes his dinner GREAT 👍 Thanks again and please call or text me if you have any questions.
Regards, Patricia Intveld“

“Our waitress Kristen was AMAZING! So sweet and prompt! The food is always off the charts delicious! But the hostess, Wilma, was awful! She was Rude from the moment we walked in! Claimed she didn’t have our reservation (which we made 3 days in advance) they DID make room for us, but she didn’t treat her staff well, and we witnessed her putting them down and arguing with them! Not a good roll model at all! All in all good Italian food though!“

“We went there the other night and I have to say I was impressed with the place.There are plenty of tvs if you like to watch sports and a big open area with tables if you just want to dine.The bartender was friendly and so wwere the customers that were sitting at the bar.The food was really good and we can't wait to go back .I'm going to try the Italian hot dog and my girlfriend wants to try the pizza.You owe it to yourself to try this place out.“

“Great food - both the pizza and dinners. Salads are great too - a lot in them including hard boil eggs, roasted peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, green & black olives, onions, and of course lettuce - delicious! We highly recommend it!“

“We stopped in here after our last evening of training at OCBJJ and the staff was super friendly. The owner made our pizza and was very hospitable. I would rank the pizza we had in my top 5 pizzas of my life. Was huge, and very delicious. If local or visiting you need to do yourself a favor and stop in for the best pizza in Jersey!“

“Went there last night for dinner. Had the pickled vegetable, the romaine salad and the clam pizza. This was more than enough for 2 people. Everything was good and it’s nice to have another year round option in Barnegat Light“

“I'm 61 and buy Dominos maybe 4 or 5 times a year. Recently moved to this area and ordered here once before and pizza was ok. Ordered a pie here today and it was probably the best pie I've ever gotten from a Dominos anywhere. Great job all around by the workers at this site.“

“Great place. TV’s along the bar. Great outdoor seating ( weather permitting)“