40 Best Pizza Restaurants near Harvey Cedars

“Super nice employees, out of all the pizza on LBI this takes the cake. This pizza tastes and is on par with NYC styles. I’m from Long Island and honestly just as good! They have Dr Pepper and also tons of nice sauces like Valentina and tajin which are the best toppings for pizza if you love spice like me. Give this man your business, I will be back every time I’m on LBI! Such a great vibe, true beach town feel place without sacrificing quality or being fake. Nice view outside of the restaurant of the bay. Unlike the other pizza places on LBI this place has slices! Every other place gave me a face if I ask if they did buffalo slices! Go check this place out tasty and classic slices!“

“Had a exceptional experience with Foodies. Peggy is a pro and so creative with her food. She has such a expansive menu full of delicious options. Our cocktail party was impeccable!! The service was beyond amazing! They were so friendly and warm and really made the day extra special for us.“

“Black Eyed Susans is one of our absolute favorite restaurants on LBI, and it keeps us coming back every time we’re on the island.

One of the best things to come out of COVID was the addition of the outdoor patio. We love sitting outside, especially on a beautiful summer evening. The atmosphere is relaxed, welcoming, and perfectly captures the spirit of LBI.

The service is always exceptional. The staff is friendly, attentive, and consistently makes us feel like valued guests.

If you’re a wine lover, don’t miss Wine Wednesdays. Half-price bottles make an already great wine list even better. The selection is excellent, the pricing is fair, and it adds tremendous value to an already outstanding dining experience.

I also have to give a shoutout to their mini martinis. I have no idea why more restaurants don’t offer them. They’re the perfect size, let you try different cocktails throughout the meal, and make for a fun dining experience.

As for the food, I’ve tried just about everything on the menu and have never had a bad dish. The sourdough bread is fantastic, and my wife, who considers herself a true french fry connoisseur, swears they are the best french fries in the United States.

When you combine the quality of the food, the outstanding service, the wine program, the mini martinis, and the atmosphere, Black Eyed Susans delivers an incredible experience at a very fair price. It’s a place we look forward to visiting every time we’re back on LBI.“

“Queen City Crust is wonderful. It's hard to find good pizza on LBI, so I'm glad they are here. It is Detroit style pizza, which is similar to Sicilian. I highly recommend it!“

“OMGOSH!!! Was leaving Pinkey’s next store when the aroma of deliciousness passed my way. It actually lured me into the pizzeria. Ordered one pizza…so so good. The crust was done to the right crispness, the dollops of sauce rich in flavor, the mozzarella fresh and you can taste the very good olive oil that was drizzled on top!! My first time-definitely not my last!“

“I think there is no better place than this!! I love food! 😍💯“

“Great food. Great friendly service. We go every week during the summer.“

“I got to say for sorrows is good real good quick delivery times they're honest if they say a certain time they're there but you got to be careful because when it shows up it is real hot real hot and really good food excellent“

“Wow! I love veal. The last time I had veal this good was at a small place in Brooklyn with about 8 tables. That was about 45 yrs ago. I was like 10 years old. Some people call it milk fed, others call it abuse. Whatever you call it, if you love veal, this is the place to go. AMAZING!!!“

“Oh, just wonderful. Every time. Delicious Italian food. I got the penne alle vodka stuffed rigatoni this time and it was 10/10. I'm very picky, too, with my pasta! A nice low-stakes night out...quiet but lively little restaurant. Good takeout too if you need it.“

“Great pizza and nice staff 🥰“

“THIS is what pizza is supposed to taste like!!!“

“I visited Manzano’s for the first time . Everything was great . Stuffed calamari, stuffed mushrooms for appetizers . For my main course I tried the chicken cordon blue over fettuccini Alfredo . Unbelievable. Such big portions, I had to take half of it home. Most importantly, the service was great . Everyone is treated like family .“

“My fiance, Jack, and I have loved Andies food for years but only recently did he and I realize just how dedicated they are to their customers...going just above & beyond.

Their burgers, wings, calzones quesadillas, and side dishes are FANTASTIC but the owners & their attitudes towards the customers surpass even the deliciousness of the food!

Thank You:.. Barb Hartman and Jack Stickle,( FOREVER customers - Fall/ 2024.)

2026:Did a bit of oversharing in my 2026 Review update but Jack loved ur food for years!

Anyway....The owners of this establishment are lovely ppl who take pride in their business & I hope EVERYONE finds & APPRECIATES this place. And if you go for a burger, GO VERY HUNGRY.“

“My favorite pizza in town! Owner Chris is a great guy and hardest working guy I know!“

“First time ordering Lorenzo’s. We ordered 6 Philly cheesesteaks and 2 Trio pies. DELICIOUS!
The closest we’ve ever gotten to Philadelphia. Spot on. Pies were so crispy. So glad that we have a new restaurant to add to our LBI repertoire.“

“Pies on 9 South catered our wedding this past weekend…. 10/10 recommend! The food was absolutely amazing! Almost a week later, we’re still hearing from guests about how delicious everything was. Brandi was so easy to work with—kind, attentive, and her portion recommendations were spot on. The entire experience was smooth from start to finish. We’ll definitely be ordering from them again for any occasion we cater in the future!“

“Incredible pizza with classics, newer styles and creative ideas. The Brooklyn Finest is a must!“

“Excellent prices, large portions, always delicious, never disappointed. Highly recommend!“

“The most delicious pizza on Long Beach Island!!! In addition to great food, it's an incredible family run business with the most genuine, caring and hard working staff ever. You just don't come across businesses like this anymore - Slice of Heaven is truly extra special.“

“We ordered dinner last night, and it was great as usual!! Our food arrived quickly, and it was hot and delicious! We love Ray’s wings (hot and honey are our favorite) and pizza! My family has been ordering from Ray’s for over 5 years, and I don’t think we have ever had a bad meal… everything is consistently good! Ordering is easy and delivery is fast!!“

“We love this place! The employees are so appreciative, the food has been consistently deliciously, the prices are great and the delivery is quick. What more can you ask for?“

“Oh my God! My sister ordered delivery for my birthday and it was the BEST chicken francese, omg so delicious. Delivered hot, fresh, friendly and fast. amazing salad, amazing blue cheese dressing PIZZA IS FABULOUS!!! Calzone delicious everything cooked to perfection! This place is ON POINT.“

“Wanted to shout out the Joeys delivery guy who went above and beyond last night. We had a scheduled delivery time for 7 pizzas for a kids beach bday party but an accident on Long Beach Blvd was holding up traffic for a long time with no end in sight. He walked those pizzas 6-8 blocks to us instead, no questions or complaints. Super professional. Lots of respect and a major thank you!“

“My wife said she though the California wrap was delicious. She has never said that before about take out food. My chicken tacos and the kids food, pizza and a hamburger was great. I thought it was a bit expensive, but not worried about that if they keep the quality as it was. Everyone ate everything. Fresh and not greasy. Good job.“

“loyal customer for years but the order takers need to pay more attention to the orders over the phone.“

“Amazing! The names of places you go sticks in your head and the good ones are never forgotten! The food, people, atmosphere etc.. simply delicious“

“As new Barnegat residents, we stumbled upon this gem while exploring our local businesses. The mussels marinar did not disappoint! My fiancé ordered the soft shell crab franchese, and was also very pleased. The bartender, Trish, was friendly, attentive, and made an amazing espresso martini. We will definitely be East Bay Italian Grille regulars.“

“This Giant Zeppole filled with Cannoli cream and topped with Nutella was Absolutely Amazing! I shed a tear of Happiness after taking my first bite.“

“I Enjoy The Merchant Market So Much“

“Great food - both the pizza and dinners. Salads are great too - a lot in them including hard boil eggs, roasted peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, green & black olives, onions, and of course lettuce - delicious! We highly recommend it!“

“Our waitress Kristen was AMAZING! So sweet and prompt! The food is always off the charts delicious! But the hostess, Wilma, was awful! She was Rude from the moment we walked in! Claimed she didn’t have our reservation (which we made 3 days in advance) they DID make room for us, but she didn’t treat her staff well, and we witnessed her putting them down and arguing with them! Not a good roll model at all! All in all good Italian food though!“

“We went there the other night and I have to say I was impressed with the place.There are plenty of tvs if you like to watch sports and a big open area with tables if you just want to dine.The bartender was friendly and so wwere the customers that were sitting at the bar.The food was really good and we can't wait to go back .I'm going to try the Italian hot dog and my girlfriend wants to try the pizza.You owe it to yourself to try this place out.“

“We stopped in here after our last evening of training at OCBJJ and the staff was super friendly. The owner made our pizza and was very hospitable. I would rank the pizza we had in my top 5 pizzas of my life. Was huge, and very delicious. If local or visiting you need to do yourself a favor and stop in for the best pizza in Jersey!“

“I'm 61 and buy Dominos maybe 4 or 5 times a year. Recently moved to this area and ordered here once before and pizza was ok. Ordered a pie here today and it was probably the best pie I've ever gotten from a Dominos anywhere. Great job all around by the workers at this site.“

“Went there last night for dinner. Had the pickled vegetable, the romaine salad and the clam pizza. This was more than enough for 2 people. Everything was good and it’s nice to have another year round option in Barnegat Light“

“WOW! Truly what a great time at the Marlin!! The food was fantastic and the staff was even better!!!! The bar back, Evan, was such a nice person and worked super hard. The kitchen expo Mike was extremely helpful and answered our questions with the ut-most confidence. What a great establishment!!!! We will be back!!“

“Had an amazing experience. Food and drink were delicious with a beautiful atmosphere. Very family friendly.“

“Absolutely Amazing!! We just had the most beautiful event at Bird and Betty’s! The staff was remarkable! They were attentive to our every need. The process of having this party from beginning to end was seamless with the help of Brie, the coordinator and her staff. The food and drinks exceeded our expectations!! The attention to details were on point! Thank you Bird and Betty’s for making our future bride’s dreams come true!! 🤍“

“Hidden gem! 💎 great food !! Must try the Brooklyn square with vodka sauce Everything I have ordered from here has been absolutely fresh and delicious“