18 Best Italian Restaurants in Wayne

“We had my daughters baby shower here yesterday. The food was absolutely amazing! The manager Sam was extremely easy to work with long distance (I live in Pennsylvania). The wait staff were very friendly and attentive . I would highly recommend this place for a private party.“

“I finally got to meet up with “The Mozzarella God” I tell you, you have to try this. It’s mouthwatering just looking at the menu. The sandwiches are nice size to.(BTW they were cut in half and only ate a quarter of each…filled me up) I got the Uncle Paulie Sandwich: Fresh chicken cutlet, fried mozzarella on toasted cheesy garlic bread topped with fresh basil, pecorino cheese and a side of vodka sauce. And The Big Poppa Fresh mozzarella melted sandwich with tomatoes, house made seasoned arugula, prosciutto, chicken cutlet on toasted cheesy garlic bread. Truly amazing. Fast friendly service. Take cash/card/Apple Pay Go to their site and follow them.“

“We had a wonderful Dinner at Novelli Restaurant in Wayne NJ yesterday celebrating my amazing Wife Karen's birthday. Food,service and ambiance was outstanding !“

“Greeted & seated immediately upon arrival even though we were early for our reservation! Excellent & very attentive wait staff! The food was delicious & plentiful! A very bright, lovely restaurant with “Delicious Italian Food”!!!“

“Excellent service, very tasty food well prepared. Have eaten there on many occasions and thoroughly enjoyed every meal.“

“What a wonderful treat. While waiting for the ferry we had the pleasure of visiting Neil’s Peacock Kitchen and Bar. The best wait /bar staff and award winner food. 🥇Crafted cocktails and an education wine list offer pairing with all the superb food. The staff members are engaging and knowledgeable. What a wonderful evening. Small and intimate yet welcoming .“

“This place is TOP SHELF. Went twice this past week and honestly feel there is NO place in the area that comes remotely close to this restaurant! I moved from Bergen County and until now, could not find that rare combination of quality food, CLEAN and attentive , personable staff. The seafood is AMAZING. I’ve heard some comments in reference to the owner….guess what…he’s doing a whole lot of right, maybe you just don’t know the difference.“

“Had a family gathering of 14 people and Positano’s did not disappoint. Service was great, and food was delicious. Amazingly everyone’s meal came out at the same time and everything was hot. Staff was very accommodating. Thank you! (Renee and family)“

“I recently attended a bridal shower at this restaurant, and it was an absolutely wonderful experience from start to finish. The staff was warm, attentive, and a true pleasure to work with. The food was outstanding—beautifully presented and full of flavor. The atmosphere was perfect for the occasion, and everyone had a fantastic time. Highly recommend for any special event or dining!“

“Great food, friendly people“

“I have been ordering from here for years !! The food is always top notch.. I also have had them cater birthdays and other events for me, delivery drivers always arrived and set up the food !! Pizza too , great options a lot of variety to make everyone happy. I have always been given great service over the last 15 years from front end staff to delivery drivers...VC“

“Palazzone 1960 on Route 23 in Wayne, NJ, bakes endless selection of Italian pastries, cookies, & gelatos,
You can dine for lunch from Tuesday - Sunday, with savory choices from their menu, from antipasti, to panini, to pastas, to insalata (salads),
Friendly Staff, Palazzone 1960 is La Dolce Vita
Absolutely Recommend“

“We ordered the general tso’s pizza yesterday for dinner and my family loved it. My son ate the last 2 slices for breakfast this morning. The guy who took my order over the phone was very patient and nice. I personally love their food as I’ve ordered many times from them when I was working in Wayne. We will definitely be ordering from now on because my family loved it. I can’t wait to try the Thai chili pizza with fried calamari. Great job Pizza One !!!!“

“They just catered for my son’s 1st birthday party, couldn’t be more happier it was an amazing party topped with amazing food, can’t thank Brian & staff enough for helping with this special party.“

“If you haven’t been to PrimoHoagies in Wayne, NJ, you’re seriously missing out. From the moment you walk in, the place smells like fresh-baked bread and spices — basically what heaven must smell like. The staff is always friendly, fast, and incredibly efficient, even when it’s busy (which it often is — for good reason!).

Now let’s talk about the food. Every hoagie I’ve tried here has been next-level good. The meats are always sliced fresh, the rolls are soft yet sturdy enough to handle all the delicious fillings, and the toppings are crisp, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. I highly recommend the Italian Diablo if you like a little heat, or the chicken cheesesteak if you’re looking for something hearty. And don’t sleep on their Sharp Italian — it’s a classic for a reason. The manager is super friendly! The staff is amazing!!!

What really sets this location apart is how consistent they are. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or catering for a group, they nail it every single time.

Pro tip: order ahead online if you’re in a rush — it’s super easy and always ready on time.

PrimoHoagies in Wayne is the kind of place that turns a sandwich into an experience. Easily a 10/10!“

“We had a wonderful date night here! The bartender was fantastic—attentive, friendly, and truly made our evening enjoyable. The food was fresh and phenomenal; we loved the burrata pizza, wings, and an amazing selection of wine. We’d absolutely love to come back.

That said, our arrival was a bit off-putting. Despite available seats in the dining area, we were told we couldn’t be seated there since we were a party of two, without any clear explanation. After that, the rest of the staff didn’t seem particularly attentive. Thankfully, the bartender more than made up for it with outstanding service.“

“Hands-down, the best pizza I’ve ever had. Perfect in every way. Simply amazing. I wish we had it in South Florida.“

“Olive Garden never disappoints! The food, drinks, and service are always on point. The red wine was amazing — smooth and full of flavor — and the Italian Rum Punch cocktail was honestly one of my favorites, perfectly balanced and refreshing.

The Alfredo pasta was creamy and delicious, and of course, you can never go wrong with their famous breadsticks and salad. The soups are always warm, flavorful, and comforting — especially the Zuppa Toscana! Everything came out fresh, and the staff made sure we had everything we needed throughout the meal.

Overall, Olive Garden is one of those places that always hits the spot whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout. Great food, great drinks, and such a cozy atmosphere — highly recommend! 🍷🍝🥖“