10 Best Italian Restaurants in Totowa

“This is one of my Fav. Italian Restaurants. The Food is Delicious. The Hostess’, Servers & Staff are friendly & attentive. Many Friends & Family have been coming here for years. Each visit we enjoy the whole atmosphere!“

“Fabulous food, excellent service, wonderful restaurant !!!“

“EVERYTHING was outstanding. That in a nut shell is putting it mildly!! Four of us went to dinner on a rainy, rainy Thursday night. You would think the restaurant would be empty because of the torrential rain,nope. They had a wonderful dinner crowd. We started with the stuffed or artichoke that was outstanding.Our entrees were Barramundi , two of us had lamb chops and the other Nino‘s pasta. Trying all three dinners I couldn’t tell you which I like the best. Yes, I can. It was my pasta that I haven’t had in years from them. Needless to say the service was outstanding we just miss seeing Amy. Don’t worry we’ll be back. SOON… ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Our meal was DELICIOUS! Scallop appetizer followed by entrees of halibut, bronzino and orata. Wonderful service made for a beautiful evening“

“I love the spinach pockets they make.“

“We have been to Made in Italy many times during all of the ownership changes. We have been for dinner, had graduation parties and gone for dessert only. We were so happy to hear that it was open at night again. My husband recently had knee replacement and was itching to get out. We decided to go for coffee/dessert at Made in Italy. He struggled to get in the car and out when we arrived. It was 8:30 Saturday night when they close at 10. There were over 15 tables open - we asked to be seated for coffee and dessert only to be told they don’t do that. They wouldn’t seat us - they gave us their card and told us to check the menu when we got home- which we did. The second paragraph of the website says - stop by just to have a cup of our gourmet coffee. They had many tables open and preferred to turn us away. Needless to say - we will not be going back.“

“Yum! The slices were so good. Went for one, and got two. I am only holding back from giving 5 star on atmosphere because I can't promote the Graffiti of Tony Soprano with a cigarette burning in the hand. The visual is not cool to me. Takes away from a family touch that it could have been. Also lacking recycling options. Sad to see so many soda bottles getting trashed.“

“real Italian pizza....¡!!!!!!¡!!“

“Your pizza’s are the best around. Just ordered a mushroom and onion with so many toppings. Also we have tried any of your sandwiches which are great. Very good quality and portions. Glad you are in town no wonder everyone comes to your place. Your neighbor“

“I had a great experience here. I ordered three slices, but they ended up running out. Without me even asking, they refunded part of my order for the inconvenience, which I really appreciated. The staff was incredibly kind, professional, and made sure I was taken care of. On top of that, the pizza was delicious. Great customer service and great food. I’ll definitely be coming back!“