“Seemed like a crazy Friday night when I walked in but they were very helpful when I was trying to order last minute pies. Just got finished with dinner with the family and the pizza was amazinggggg! We got a grandma square pie and a regular cheese round pizza, the crust is so good. Thank you for being so kind and accommodating! I go here once in a while but I just felt the need to write a review finally tonight because it’s always been a great experience and seeing how hard they were working tonight really made me appreciate everything!“
“Frank the owner came to greet us, very nice. Tabitha and Alexa were very sweet and knowledgeable about the menu. Had the calamari and Roman style baby Artichoke as apps. Entrees were veal and Papadella with spicy Italian sausage and broccoli Rabe. Oh and the salted caramel cheesecake is to die for!!!! Will definitely return!!!“
“I had the gnocchi and it was absolutely AMAZING! Not only that, but I saw that they had cheesecake so I tried a slice and can I just say, I was in HEAVEN! I am not usually a dessert kind of person, but this cheesecake might have changed my opinion on dessert, forever. If you have the chance to stop by and try their cheesecake, I highly recommend it. It was so tasty!!!! 20/10“
“Came here for weekday lunch and was not disappointed! The place is relatively small but food and service were excellent which is what matters most. I ordered a couple of Sicilian slices and garlic knots. The crust was nice and crispy and the garlic knots were hot and delicious. Everything came out quick and staff was friendly, definitely recommend checking out!“
“A perfect location to host our daughter’s baptism dinner. My husband and I kept it immediate family. I was able to drop off the few little decorations the night before as they had no problem setting up for me. Nick was so accommodating with my one family member having dietary restrictions. I purposely went there starving and left there stuffed. Food is absolutely delicious, and cooked fresh. Nicola’s is always our go to dinner spots and we were so thrilled and happy that we got to celebrate our daughter’s special day with them.“
“Best Pizzeria in North Jersey. It’s not just the pizza that’s fantastic. Everything is. You can tell the owner uses quality ingredients and doesn’t cut corners like many places these days do. Staff is friendly. Atmosphere is great. You’ll never leave disappointed!“
“Wish I took a photo before eating half the pie but I couldn’t help it ? Best pizza in the area!! Owner was so incredibly nice and really took pride in his pizza. We asked for a grandmas pie (not on the menu) and he went out of his way to perfect it for us. If you haven’t tried it yet, MAKE SURE YOU DO!“
“Delicious food and pleasant atmosphere. I really enjoyed the appetizers and main entree, it was flavorful and cooked to perfection. The service was friendly and caring. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and I’m looking forward to returning soon.“