50 Best Italian Restaurants near Williamstown

“My family got the Milano Pizza and was the absolute the best! Not only did my family find our pizzeria, I have found my pizza that we love!“

“delicious authentic Italian gravy! I mean Sauce lol. Found your product at the shoprite in millville went home to try and it is so good!“

“Top of the line restaurant at average pricing. BYOB is nice also. Five star on quality of food, service and it’s Italian flare.“

“The service is exceptional,The sauce is a thick,rich,tasty sauce.The place is CLEAN.The portions were more than adequate. The complementary garlic bread is delicious.Dinners come with soup and salad.We used to go elsewhere for Italian food,no more.Cotardo's is our place to go now“

“Went here last night with 16 people and everything was amazing from service to main course, the main reason why I am writing this review is because my seafood Fra Diavolo was absolutely amazing I will go back and order this again and again and again what a great place I highly recommend this place“

“The service is good but the busers are aggressive when one person is still eating you might want to tell your Hispanic buser not to come and interrupt the meal to clear plates away when the dining room is nearly empty that's why we don't come on Christmas Eve they damn near throw us out“

“Great food Bette than Olive Garden food wise but slow service“

“My favorite place for food, people and atmosphere. Highly recommend. My favorite is chicken capri, finger steaks and awesome salad with cheese“

“great food great customer service great atmosphere good pricing considering great food“

“We had a delicious dinner on Mother’s Day. Our server, Melissa, was a delight. We have passed this restaurant many times with the intention of trying it out. So glad we finally did!!“

“Food is fantastic, along with service. Smells so good as soon as you walk in the door. Owners really care.“

“Order well done crust, extra sauce, light cheese, and it was prepared perfectly! Sauce is exceptional and crust was flavorful and crispy. Best pizza near me (gloucester county).“

“Gentlemen handed me a menu while outside in my development. figured I would give it a try. Wings and eggplant sub where outstanding! Will he back.“

“Most amazing food & excellent service!!!“

“We order from Dominic’s all the time. This past weekend we used them to cater our Halloween party and everything was amazing as always! They have the best Sicilian 😋 They always make you feel like family too ♥️“

“Hi, this is Fabricio. I found your business on Google Maps and noticed you don’t have a website yet. I build simple, professional websites for small businesses so customers can find and contact them easily. Would you like more information?“

“We finally went to Jake’s on Greentree. We could not be more happier than to have visited this restaurant after family have been giving them great reviews. They did not disappoint! My husband and I went for lunch and could have not been more happier with their delicious food, friendly staff, cleanliness. The decor is adorable~old school Italian. We were excited to find out they delivered to Pitman. The food being so good, we decided to have dinner delivered and they did not disappoint! This hidden gem with homemade Italian food is now our go too.“

“We ordered a half pan of chicken parm for Christmas Eve dinner. It said it serves 5. They lied. So much food! Of course it’s delicious so we’ll happily eat it for days. Just be warned that catering portions are very large. Also they have the best vodka sauce I’ve had.“

“The food here is phenomenal and the staff is Wonderful I get the Shrimp Fra Diablo My friend gets the Manicotti Both dishes are delicious The pizza and bread as well as the oil dipping is amazing. You will not be disappointed“

“We had an event at Tullia’s and everything was amazing! From the moment I first called the customer service experience was fantastic! I was able to drop everything off the night before. The Tullia’s staff did an amazing job setting up our event.. Everything I dropped off was set up perfectly ( Beer, Wine, cake, custom menus, party favors , picture boards) and ready when we arrived. The food was fantastic. The service was perfect and you can’t beat BYOB. Big shout out to Enza! They get five stars plus from me ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Food was very good! Waitress, bartender and everyone in there was so nice! Will definitely go back!“

“This was our second time here. I had the Keylime gelato and my husband had the pistachio cheesecake gelato. Always so delicious! Thank you guys for having the best gelato around!!“

“It was our 1st time there today and the woman who owns it was so friendly. We got vegetable soup, chicken cutlets, eggplant parmesan and a side of string beans and everything was delicious. All the food was homemade and you could taste the care she took in making everything. We can't wait for our next visit!“

“The food is always amazing and they’re always friendly. Reading the comments I’ve noticed a few of the negative ones make no sense and I wouldn’t pay it any mind. One lady gave one star and her comment she was talking about a hostess, bar and bartender. This pizza place has none of that lol. They don’t even sell alcohol! Another guy gives one star because the delivery driver said something to confuse him haha. but still they have a good rating for a reason.“

“The owner is a very nice person. The atmosphere was good and so was the food! I was craving a couple slices all day of pizza and the owner made sure I got my craving satisfied with their honey siracha chicken pizza. Definitely coming back!“

“Had a funeral lunch here. The banquet manager made the transaction super smooth. I flew in from out of town and didn't have the right card for the down payment. She didn't mind waiting for my wife the next day to pay. The food was perfect for such an event. Living in both Philly and Jersey in the past a lot of funerals end up in oregon dinner which isn't that great. So this felt a little more upscale. Staff was friendly. They say us in the back and it felt more private so we could talk and laugh freely. Plenty of parking. I would say a good choice if your funeral does a burial at gates of heaven because it's so close and less confusing to the funeral attendees.

They have different food and booze packages and felt pretty reasonably priced for what you got.“

“I told the server I had a dairy allergy and he was great, even brought me my own basket of unbuttered bread.
I learned during a past visit that they probably put parmesan in the breading so I got grilled chicken and pasta with marinara sauce. It was delicious.
It's very reassuring to know I can go here with my family and enjoy a safe meal with them.“

“First timers tonight and the veal parmigiana was superb kudos to the chief keep it up and we’ll be back. Clean and friendly 👍“

“Thank you to your wonderful staff for making my family birthday luncheon so special. We came dressed for Christmas and were greeted by Buddy the elf and heard Santa behind the door. Our children loved it all and even got pics with them both. The drinks and food were awesome and we were able to bring some home for more enjoyment. Our server was excellent and very attentive. This was my first time but it definitely will not be my last.“

“Great food, friendly service!“

“Great food. Great environment.. the staff has always been pleasant. Consistent quality… you won’t be disappointed.“

“Best hoagie I've had in a long time ,will always order there“

“Good meals. Deliveries are hit or miss depending on time of day.“

“Hands down the best pizza in south jersey. And we eat all over. Glad it’s in the next town but we would drive two hours for this pizza. Owners and staff are so friendly and it’s really starting to look nice inside.“

“Everything was excellent the two guys had amazing energy“

“I ordered a Too Good Too Go surprise bag (my first time) and got way more than I anticipated! Sever different types of slices of pizza and zeppoles. I grabbed tiramisu since it’s my husbands favorite (he said it was the best he had in a long time!) the owner was very nice and gracious!“

“We recently moved to the williamstown area and had a hard time finding a pizza place until we came across Tuscan Pizza. They are fantastic and amazing customer service. We asked for paper plates the one time, the driver left without them but received a call from Tuscan apologized for this and said they sent another driver by to deliver the plates. They literally arrived minutes late almost the exact same time as the pizza. This is just a small sample of their service. Top notch and amazing pizza!“

“Just ordered first time since moving here… they are fantastic! Fresh food, delicious, like you’re in your mom’s kitchen! The roast pork and broccoli rabe, omg!!! I called to tell them how awesome it was! Very nice young man delivered and even nicer manager, Nicky. We will make them our go to place and please try them, you will be very satisfied ! Outstanding food and service!“

“Food and service was definitely five stars all the way.“

“Was in the area for my son's soccer match and we stopped here by chance before the game for some sandos and glad we did. Ordered the Amore and the Downtown. They were wonderful. Excellent seeded roll that was crisp on the outside soft on the inside. They did not skimp on the fresh ingredients, and everything was prepared fresh and fast.“

“The seafood buffet was incredible. The lobster and various crab offering were nicely seasoned along with the shrimp offering. Great lobster Mac and cheese.“

“Excellent food and always great service whether I eat there or take out.“

“had the turkey meatball wrap with brown rice.....yup ill sure get it again“

“the best in the business 🍕“

“Great food and an even better experience last night! Everything arrived fresh, hot, and exactly as ordered. Our delivery driver, Nick, was friendly, professional, and right on time. He made the whole experience smooth and enjoyable. Highly recommend!“

“We come here 2-3 times a week for lunch. Food is always amazing and the service is top notch. Highly recommended!!“

“I typically order the Detroit style pizza, which is always fantastic from the sauce to the crust to the caramelized cheese edge- never disappoints! But, I have to throw the limelight of this review onto their cheesesteaks. All I can say is, “WOW!” I ordered the cheesesteak on their homemade, sesame seeded sub roll with cooper sharp, fried onions, and banana peppers. The meat, cheese, and veggies were spectacular (all in more than generous proportions), but that roll stole the show!!! I am a huge bread snob, and I cannot get over how great the bread is (flavorful dough, airy inside, crust baked perfectly, and enough seeds to happily feed a small village). I gotta give this family a ton of credit- they have carbs, among other things of course, figured out!!! Also, you should follow them on your favorite social media platform- the family is hilarious.“

“Seafood buffet is excellent, great deals on pizza and sandwiches and the owner and staff are the nicest people.“

“We order from Sals 1-2 times every week and have tried pretty much everything on the menu. Our favorites are the cheesesteak, chicken parm sandwich, chicken Cesar salad and buffalo chicken pizza. The wings are very good too- Especially if you get the garlic buffalo sauce. They seem to have the most reasonable prices around too. Everyone that works there is friendly and the food is made quickly. I highly recommend Sals!“