14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Batavia

Cinquino's Pizza Pizza • $
314 Ellicott St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs
Garlic Bread w Cheese
Chicken Parmigiana
Garlic Cheese Bread
Kids Spaghetti
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Pizza
French Fries
Chicken Wing
Chicken Wings

“I ordered a chicken finger sub last night. No lie, it was the best sub I’ve ever had. Great job“

4.5 Superb61 Reviews
Main Street Pizza Company Pizza • $
206 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Fried Mozzarella Wedges
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Veal Parm with Spaghetti
Create-Your-Own Calzone
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Dry Rub Chicken Wings
Build Your Own Pizza
The Main Street
Deep Dish Pizza
Boneless Wings

“Great food & great service!“

4.3 Superb93 Reviews
Pizza 151 Pizza • $
8351 Lewiston Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese Sticks Pizza Soft Pretzels
Pepperoni with Regular Crust Gluten Free Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza with Traditional Sauce
Cup and Char Pepperoni Hot Honey Sauce
Cheese Steak and Garlic Honey Wings
Box of Boneless Wings
Loaded French Fries
Chicken Finger Sub
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza

“Best Pizza in Batavia! Friendly service and great food!“

4.1 Good85 Reviews
Ficarella's Pizzeria Pizza • $
21 Liberty St #3238, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

White Pizza with Ricotta and Broccoli
Sicilian Pepperoni Pizza
Half Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Fish and Chips
Cheeseburger
Meatball Sub
Chicken Wings
Fried Dough
Pan Pizza

“We love Ficarella's. I can't recall any time we've had an issue because we keep going back. We got dinner from them 2 times this week and both times our order was 100% correct. Their online ordering is super simple and allows you to make almost any modification you want. They also have a drive up window if you can't/don't want to go inside.“

4 Good72 Reviews
Matty's Pizza Pizza • $
109 Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Supreme
Pizza

“Best Pizza around hands down. We've had every slice from every joint around Genesee County. If you haven't tried Mattys, do yourself a favor and order one from them. You won't be disappointed.“

3.9 Good8 Reviews
Batavia's Original Pizzeria Pizza • $
500 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Onion Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Italian Wedding Soup
Italian Meat Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Boneless Wings
Pepperoni Slice
Chicken Wings

“One of my favorite spots to eat with friends in Batavia! Great wings! Pizza is excellent! Love their slices! Try the chicken wing dip 😋

Kid-friendliness: Yes kid-friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp near parking lot.“

3.9 Good119 Reviews
Jerry Arena's Pizzeria Pizza • $$
8360 Lewiston Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Single Order Wings
Double Order Wings
Chicken Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Mozzarella Stix
Antipasto Salad
Fried Mushrooms
Chicken Finger
Garlic Bread
Large Pizza

“It's a plain atmosphere with good conversation amongst locals and the interior looks the exact same as it always has. The sauce was delicious, the cheese was stretchy and melty. The crust had a nice crunch yet soft at the same time. The customer service was professional and helpful. My partner asked for extra cheese. If you want to eat the pizza from a Goofy movie, order with extra cheese, it looks the exact same! It's not really a necessity tho. I definitely recommend!“

3.7 Good24 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
6 Court St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Custom Medium 2-Topping 12 Pizza
Stuffed Cheesy Bread
Parmesan Bread Bites
Pepperoni Pizza
Mushroom Pizza
Chicken Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Bread Twists
Tater Tots

“Staff was super friendly and smiling! Greeted me as soon as I walked in the door! We ordered the stuffed crust pizza and it was delicious! With other pizza places that have stuffed crust, the pizza is usually so thin and floppy but not Dominos! It was perfect!“

3.6 Good46 Reviews
Roman's Italian • $
59 Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Artichoke Fritters
Pizza of the Month
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Francese
Grilled Chicken
Stuffed Shells
French Onion
Utica Greens

“I liked everything about this place. The food was awesome and the atmosphere was super cool. On our way from Niagara we found this cool place and had a pit stop for lunch. Kids enjoyed the lunch. We had sphegatti, Alfredo, Lobster soup and Pizza which was customized to our liking as we don't like Beef. Thanks a ton to the person who serviced us. He really was too cool from the time he met us until our billing. He even gave us a chocolate tower cake billed on house. The cake was full of chocolate and delicious. If I have anyone visiting to NY on this way I would surely recommend this place for anyone who wish to have a nice Italian Food“

4.1 Good86 Reviews
J Dub's Pizzas and Subs Pizza • $
10594 Alexander Rd, Alexander - 7.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sour Cream & Taco Sauce on the Side
Chicken Fingers w Fries
Garlic Bread w Cheese
Cheeseburger Meatball
Mac and Cheese Bites
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Mozzarella Sticks
Assorted Salami
Grilled Chicken
Chicken Parm

“Thank you for a delicious fish fry, it was big, crispy, nice and flaky-it was still hot when I got home - fantastic!! The fries weren’t gooy they were good and crispy, Cole slaw and Mac salad were a very nice surprise tasted amazing- thank you again- delicious!!“

4.9 Superb25 Reviews
Shell's Post Pizza Takeaway • $
6173 Main St, Stafford - 5.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Pizza and Steak Pizza
Specialty Pizza Slices
Italian Sausage Sub
Cheese & Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Cheese Pizza
Assorted Sub
Hodge Podge
Curly Fries

“great chicken fingers with fries. The best fingers! Definitely will order again. Fries were also exceptional, good and hot. Thanks. 💕“

4.6 Superb31 Reviews
Jim's Saloon Pizza • $
2677 Main St, East Pembroke - 5.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“Wings are killer!!! Great hidden gem“

4.9 Superb10 Reviews
Santino's Pizza Pizza • $
2 Main St, Oakfield - 6.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Extra Cheese and Mushrooms
Wings or Boneless
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Wings

“Love coming here. Really home town feel, lots of sports memorabilia on the walls, super friendly service and food is ALWAYS on point!“

4.3 Superb42 Reviews
Fullerino's Pizza • $
6321 Townline Rd, Byron - 8.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza with Sweet Sauce Made into a Pumpkin for Halloween
Cheeseburger Full Platter with Meatsauce
Sweet Sauce Pizza
Chicken Finger
Chicken Wings
Sheet Pizza 1
Curly Fries
Pizza Logs
Calzone
Wraps

“I’ve eaten at many pizza places over the years, but ordered pizza and wings from Fullerinos today, and the pizza was the absolute best I’ve had to this date. They really made my day with the excellent care they took making this food for us. Thanks to the staff for such a great job!“

4 Good12 Reviews

Batavia’s related cuisines

You May Also Like