18 Best Greek Restaurants near Bay Shore

“I was craving mezze bad literally all day but didn't want to go to the place near work during my lunch break so I was CRANKY when I got home. Googled when I got home and saw this close by, forced my husband out of the house to drive me before I got so hangry I murdered him. Husband got a quinoa bowl (why anyone eats quinoa is beyond me but he really enjoyed it) piled high, I got falafel, and I got an order of each of the spreads. Absolutely hit the spot--also I make the feta dip (tyrokafteri) at home which I've been making for years and people rave about it (literally, like I'm pretty famous for it in my circles) but somehow this tastes better than mine?!? How dare they make it better than me?!? One day I'll figure out their recipe but until the I guess I'll have to keep buying it to divine their secrets. Falafel was crispy on the outside, tender and not dry on the inside, great portions. I only remembered to review with a picture after I mostly demolished it so sorry if you were hoping for a picture of the whole thing.“

“Love this place! Such a homely feel and the food reminds you of a delicious home cooked meal. I suggest it to anyone and everyone who wants to eat great Cypriot cuisine and support a local restaurant!!“

“Genuinely the best Greek food on Long Island. Moving out here from Queens and being used to the Greek food in Astoria, we were honestly worried we wouldn’t find anything as authentic out here - but Twisted Greek completely changed that.

The food is fresh, flavorful, and truly tastes homemade. Everything we’ve had has been excellent, from the gyros to the souvlaki to the sides, and you can tell they really care about quality. It has that authentic Greek street/comfort-food feel that’s hard to find outside of Astoria and keeps me coming back.

On top of that, the service is amazing. Everyone is friendly, welcoming, and makes you feel genuinely appreciated as a customer. They’re attentive, quick, and always make the experience feel personal, which makes the food even better.

We’re so happy to have found this place and it has quickly become one of our go-to spots. Highly recommend to anyone looking for real, delicious Greek food on Long Island with great service to match.“

“First time here today, what a great place with great people. We were a group of 4 and everything was amazing. Even got to talk with the owner Peter and his wife. Can’t wait to go back.“

“The food is very delicious at this establishment. The onions tomatoes and lettuce were very fresh and the pita was pillowy soft. The meat was well seasoned and everything was tasty! I will definitely be back. Great quince greek yogurt as well!“

“We happened upon this place because we were in the mood for Greek and were close by. Everything was absolutely delicious, some of the best Greek food I've ever had. Service with a smile, and so clean and welcoming inside. We will be back!!“

“I cannot say enough about the incredible food and how unbelievably fresh their fish is. From the moment you get there with their chickpea salad, which is phenomenal and then there’s tzatziki, which is also the best I’ve ever had you off perfectly. There’s never a time I don’t come home with leftovers. The staff is friendly And consistent. Unbelievably nice and I just love it here we eat here quite regularly because it is absolutely the best Greek food I’ve ever had. Tell Nick I want you. Love everyone that works there.“

“Our waiter Saul was very friendly and had great recommended things to try and I tried them all! He had a passion for his workplace and I love that! A must try u all 🤙🤙🤗 visiting from Tampa FL My Sister who lives in Ronkonkomo and my daughter & granddaughters Huntington residents love this restaurant 🤙“

“First time there last night. Delicious food, huge servings, prices great! Best chick pea salad appetizer and Greek salad . Lamb chops big portion and delicious with green beans with peppers and onion vegetable and lemon potato wedges. Highly recommend glad our friends brought us there. Wish I lived closer“

“When I get Greek I always get gyros because I don't have Greek food enough that I'm ever bored of gyros. The sauce on the gyro had a kick to it and was unlike any other place I've ever been to. I wish it was closer to where I was because I would be back more often.“

“This family owned restaurant is worth the time and effort. Nothing fancy except good Greek food. We both eat in and take out The staff is so accommodating and friendly. Many times the owners wife and children are eating there. The grandfather works at the grill when not spending time with his grandkids Again, nothing fancy except for the food, the atmosphere and the people. Please go and enjoy home-cooking while eating out“

“Just ordered the first time and it was delicious! Everything was fresh and the restaurant was nice and clean. The staff were friendly and helped me order. The owner was also very friendly and accommodating.“

“Finally tried Kalamaki and wow — so good. The chicken souvlaki was super juicy and packed with flavor. The pita was warm and fluffy and the tzatziki was perfectly garlicky. Portions are generous and prices are fair. Definitely becoming one of my go-to Greek spots.“

“Pictured is the Da Vinci, a delicious pizza that is also vegetarian friendly for those who need vegetarian options. Food is delicious and all staff, front and back of house, are friendly and professional. Nice view of the town and calm atmosphere. Most of the wait staff hired are in high school or college, making this a good place to go to if you’re looking to support neighborhood kids. The owner is a kind, respected member of the local town who goes above and beyond to give back to the community. 10/10 highly recommend.“

“Coconut shrimp and coconut chicken were DELICIOUS!!! :)“

“Was in the area working and decided to have lunch here. The place has a very large menú to chose from so I was a bit hesitant on that. Usually places with large menus tend to have a hard time keeping items fresh, but no not here at hell's kitchen the food was great flavor and taste are great. I ordered a chicken gyro platter. The gentleman behind the counter insisted I try the empanadas so I did and it was very good. The crust was very crispy and flaky just like a traditional empanada and it was stuffed with spicy chicken. I wish I would have ordered a few more. I recommend stopping by if you are in the area.“

“Staff was amazing. Very attentive. No complaints there! Food was just alright- not bad but nothing special. Short ribs were very boring and had little flavor. Chilean sea bass was decent. Lunch is usually pretty good but I think the dinner menu needs some work.“