23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Binghamton

“Best pizza in town!!! Hands down...👌“

“If we hadn’t read about this place we would never ever have tried it. The location is in a sketchy part of town in a run down and mostly abandoned strip mall. Don’t let that stop you because inside those doors is some of the best classic NY style pizza we have ever had and we’ve tried a LOT of them. Worth a trip into Binghamton!“

“Best smash burgers in town, trivia on the patio and inside on Thursdays 7-9pm.“

“Always a treat, great choices“

“Met a close friend for dinner after work. The place was packed but worth the wait! Food was awesome and worth the price!“

“I love it here and don't want to give a bad review but today I ordered my pizza half Philly cheese steak and it had red sauce and only steak on it. No peppers or onions and I was expecting that side of the pizza to have a white base rather than red sauce. It's too snowy and cold out to bring it back to get a replacement. I guess next time I will specify the components of the Philly cheese steak that should have been on there.“

“My family and I sat here and had the American cheese pizza. We didn’t talk to each other the whole time bc of how good it was! Highly recommend. I am going to attach a picture of the pizza we had- it is NOT burnt to a crisp. Due to the American cheese it browns faster. This was made to perfection! I wish we lived closer to the area. Service was great as well.“

“Absolutely great food, super friendly staff. Definitely a go to for us next time we are in town.“

“Excellent food any time of the day or evening!“

“As a pizza enthusiast who has tried some of the most renowned pizza from all over the East Coast, Midwest, to all over Italy, I can give this place the credit it deserves. It's truly good pizza that everyone in my family enjoyed. It blows away anything we tried from "The Pizza Capital of the World" just an hour down the street. This pizza is the real deal and has stood the test of time. We loved the sauce, the cheese, the crust was amazing, and will return to Binghamton just to have it again. Nirchi's pizza is a shining star in the world of pizza. Excellent across the board!“

“I too think it’s false advertising when your menu has one price and your charged a different price when you go to pick up your order , i was told it wasn’t there fault they just work there so disappointed because I love the pizza ! You would think they would want to be honest with there customers“

“This was a neat experience for a new place to tryout. The staff was friendly and attentive. The pizza is a New York style with a crust that has a hint of sweetness to it. The ratio of sauce to cheese was perfect and the garlic knots are homemade. They have both pastas and pizza and the pizza sizes come from small, medium large (all round) to half and full sheets. The prices are reasonable and they take cash and cards. It had a small-town pizzeria feel which is awesome.“

“Yeah, I just returned back in the area and I saw that there was a new pizza place in town! The pizza sauce was delicious and crust was great just needed more cheese! I didn't really want to settle for the two slice special for me and my sister! So, we went with a fresh eight slice round pizza and it the hit the spot! Thank you.“

“Great food great owners and cold beer“

“Love this place. Not everyone gets what they're trying to do here. But that's ok. Those who do appreciate you guys a ton.“

“Stopped in to watch the Syracuse Orange Basketball game. Grabbed a high top table and got immediate service. Drinks came fast and so did the pizza fritz app. The main course was Chicken Parm wings and Hamburger sliders. The sauce on the sliders was amazing. Will return.“

“Nirchis has the best breakfast pizza as well as the best chicken/bacon/ranch. If you like these two pizzas then this is the place to go and their prices are competitive. Also they have great wings, the flavor is amazing. I wish the hot wings were a little bit hotter though! I don't notice a big difference between mild, medium, and hot.

Parking: 166 Water St Binghamton, NY 13901

Kid-friendliness: Yes it's kid friendly!“

“Nips has a plethora of great wing options and won't break the bank, but bring CASH!

Nips is a cash-only bar. They do have an ATM onsite in case you do forget.

We visited Nips on a weekend afternoon for an early dinner. The establishment was not busy. Staff was very quick to take our drink and food orders and the food arrived quick and hot.

Nips truly does have some fantastic wing options. At Nips you are greeted by a plethora of different flavors, probably the most flavor options I have seen at any wing-serving establishment. It is almost guaranteed that you will find a flavor that will suit you, or a flavor that you have not had at any other establishment.“

“great calzones. already tried 3 of them“

“I grew up in Binghamton (late 70s) and would go get bread an doughnuts every Sunday after Mass growing up. Great memories and the Fried Fish subs on Fridays are a MUST try!“

“Really great prices, food, AND service! My fiance and I were in town for SerlingFest in September and were lucky to find Pizza Plus still open (many bars were open, but being from out of town, we didn't know when kitchens were closing). They have a great menu full of pizza, gyros, beef patties, subs, bowls, deserts, etc. Our first night there, we each got a slice of pizza and a Jamaican beef patty and they were delicious. The next night, we were looking to find another place to eat (for variety) but ultimately decided to go to Pizza Plus again because the food was SO good. On top of that, they are the nicest people! I take forever to decide what I want (especially when the menu is full of great food), but they never rushed us and were so appreciative. We plan to come back for SerlingFest 2025 and will absolutely stop by Pizza Plus for late night food.“

“Worst Dane food I ever ordered. Went to order in place and they are hirribkev“

“Grew up here on East side - ate Cortese for many years.
Not impressed with with recent lunch visit - Quality has gone down and prices up.We were served 6 little pieces of stale leftover old garlic bread for $ 10.25
Should have been served freshly made
Lazy Waitress ?
If I knew it was $10.25
I would not have never ordered it.

$9.25 for tossed salad with watered down weak house dressing- that used to be strong n tasty.
Got blue cheese crumble as Waitress stated No Gorganzola was available ? - hard to believe.
Gnocchi $20 marinara - lacked garlic punch and bit overcooked.
Calamari small order undercooked - should be crispy outside tender inside. EITHER the oil temp was low or cook time short.
Breading had no flavor.
Shrimp scampi - watery
LAST but not least $9.50 for a draft beer ??

WAITRESS - nice girl but- New ? -- inexperienced ?
Management should ensure each and every order is of best quality .
Seems that most reviews are positive for dinner, but the lunch staff is not up to par.
Your receiving some poor reviews do to inconsistent quality and server issues.
SADLY-
I advise not to do Saturday lunch here as for whatever reason the quality was not up to their normal standards.
ITEM PRICING QUESTIONABLE“