20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Brownville

“I drive about 20 minutes just to get pizza here because it is so good. I am new to New York and not used to there being nowhere to eat, especially in the winter. Why do people not want to deliver or make money in the winter? The pizza place where I live is terrible and this place is hands down the best so no matter how far, we shall travel. The staff is always welcoming and gets our order right. Thank you for being better than anyone else around you... it is worth the drive...“

“Nonna Dina is a hidden gem. It's the best pizza in the area...I think it's the sauce. Also try the garlic cheese bread and canolllis! Usually get take out but they do have a couple tables for seating. Great prices.They don't deliver but you can order take out using the "Slice" app.“

“Wise Guys will be my new go-to place! I wasn't sure what to expect but was in awe from the atmosphere, hostess, our server-Rachel, extensive menu and the perfectly prepared and beautiful presentation of our appetizers, entrée and desert.We were celebrating my son's 30th birthday as a party of 4, he was over the moon!We will be back soon-celebration or not.I can't reinforce enough the perfection of this Ristorante!“

“Love, love, love this place. As We read in another review, this place is a hidden gem! My husband and I had breakfast here a few mornings ago and wow, the food was delicious, portions were huge, coffee was great and our sweet server was amazing and kind!! Such a wonderful and charming place to go! Looking forward to going again soon!!“

“Our absolute favorite date night spot. My husband always gets salmon and swears up and down he’s never had it done better anywhere else. Trimmed and cooked perfectly every time. I love the carmines cavatelli and their handmade gnocchi. Garlic knots are wonderful too. Service is always top notch.“

“The best damn sub shop in town! Simply put it's one of my favorites. The staff there is very respectable very aware of the customer and they take care of the customer all the time. My favorite is a BLT sub. Tuna melt delicious. Keep up the good work Mr Sub...Parking: it's good parking. one of the few places on the Square where you can park. I know that youcan also park in the back of the square. I love the location of Mr Subs.“

“Was raised in Manhattan and the Bronx. A lot of jokers up here claiming to have "authentic new York pizza". They're all pretending miserable failures who couldn't tell a new York pizza from the monstrous abomination Chicago pretends is pizza. But no, not this place. This place is the real deal. So long as I live here I won't be going anywhere else. Delicious. Perfect. “

“I'll preface with this: not my style of pizza. For round pizza I like napoletena, coal fired NYC, New Haven, etc. This pizza is a totally different product.However, that said, it's pretty tasty. I've tried all of the pizza in Watertown, Carthage and Adams. This may be the best tasting.Pretty heavy on the cheese, but if you like that you'll love this. Nice crunchy cornicione, well cooked and a tasty, light sauce. It's definitely cooked with love.To me this seems suited to children's tastes, so if that's your target audience, I don't think you can go wrong here.“

“Beautiful small town vibe place. Great for date night. Not really kid place. Desserts are amazing! Food is extremely bland and flavorless. You'll get more seasonings in a jar of Alfredo sauce. If I get food I get it to go so I can season it at home. A lot of elderly people eat there. I know they don't really like well seasoned food. So it's a great place to take grandma. Their hours are also elderly hours. Late lunch, early dinner. All my stars are solely for dessert!“

“I took my wife and mother-in-law here on a Thursday, about 1pm. It was not crowded at all, and we were able to get a booth tucked away in an alcove. Our server, Stephanie, was very prompt and nice. We ordered 2 of Pizza Hut's specials: a deep dish bacon & pineapple pizza, and a thin & crispy super supreme pizza. Both were hot out of the oven in less than 15 minutes and were delicious. Pizza Hut serves Pepsi products so you can quench your thirst. We had an enjoyable meal, and our (my) only complaint is that their outdoor signage is too small. I've driven by that entrance to Lowe's in Watertown, and I never knew there was a Pizza Hut hiding in plain sight. The sign on the un-Pizza Hut-looking building says "Wingstreet," and since I don't care for wings much, it never drew me in.“

“I LOVE this bread! The staff is great! If had a complaint it would be it sells out too fast! I'd ramp up production. I have eaten Alteri's Italian bread as long as I can remember. I teethed on it! I got two loaves early this week ...Perfect! I got another two today. My Wife once brought me a plate once with Alteri Bread and Croghan Bologna. "Are the kids O.K?" They're fine. "Where's the car?" The car is fine! She wanted a pool and got it.“

“Finding a place to get lunch for under $10 is not easy these days, but you can get that here. I got the half sub special with a drink and a small bag of chips. I really enjoyed sub roll which was not too hard but not too soft. Service was fast! I had just finished getting my drink and the sub was ready. A nice portion of meat which whatever else you would like. With a number of places to sit you don't feel over crowded. This is a nice locally owned place to catch lunch or bring home pizza and subs for the family.“

“My favorite dishes weren’t as delicious as they usually are. Still good but pizza was undercooked and bruschetta (their version is my absolute favorite) not as tasty. Service was outstanding as always. It’s still my favorite restaurant in Sackets and I’ll definitely return because 90% of the time, it’s 5 stars. No one can be ‘A game’ every day, especially in winter.“

“Always first rate. Watertown's only true NY state pie. Crust is thin & crispy with just the right amount of salty. Their salads are fresh and bountiful. Most importantly, the service is great & the staff very friendly.Update: sadly, this location is closing this week.“

“We went here for the first time for their Halloween event and we had a blast. The dj was on point, the drinks weren't expensive and the overall vibe was so friendly and inviting. We danced the night away along with the rest of the crowd. It was so packed but in a good way you can tell everyone was having a good time and that this place definitely has regulars. I will definitely be returning! FYI ladies don't where heels if you wanna dance and if you have to sand them down the floor is slippery!“

“Comfort food. Especially if you’re from here. Get the small cheese pizza with blue cheese as dipping sauce. Extra crispy Rhett red flavor wings with extra sauce. The great thing is it’s still locally family owned. Everything else is great too ❤️“

“I don't mind the original papatinos in watertown but never has been my first pick, however being down camping in sackets harbor where papatinos II is located, we went ahead and ordered pizza and wings from there one night during camping and it was an entirely different experience, cook, seems recipes maybe even because it was phenomenal!! I thought maybe we just got lucky, nope. They are amazing EVERY SINGLE TIME, so much so, that we make the drive to sackets from watertown every single time we order pizza and wings, and for my family, that's at least 3 times a week! We ask for all flats, extra saucy and just a little crisper cooked maybe an xtra minute only for our wings and usually just a simple cheese or cheese and pepperoni pizza, however we are a family of restaurant owners, a cook and server that both work at a fancy brick oven Italian restaurant, we know our stuff, we love food, and I take happiness in letting people know where the GREAT eats are and papatinos II is THE BEST PIZZA AND WING PLACE AROUND HERE PERIOD. watertown sackets harbor all surrounding areas! Trust me I am a pizza addict and loveeeee my flat wings! I've tried every spot around!“

“Over priced, over rated, and the service was mid. The only think I can say is that the food was good.. but it took at least 15 mins for a waitress to take out order. I understand it was a busy night but come on my wife and I like to try new places all the time and we had heard good things about this place.Overall the experience was ok. I got the chicken wings which were a very nice big size and my wife got the tenders which were huge! Probably the only reason I would go back is for the bar or the chicken tenenders haha. Maybe on a not so busy night though like a Monday or WednesdayParking: Parking lot was mostly full and not free of snowKid-friendliness: I don't have kids but I saw the host playing and joking with what I'm guessing was a regular guest or maybe a friend of the family“

“Wow, Tony's Pizzeria really lives up to the hype! I've tried pizzas across New York, but nothing compares to what I had at Tony's. The crust was perfectly crispy, and the sauce? Amazing! It's clear they use fresh ingredients, and it makes all the difference. The atmosphere is just as inviting, making you feel right at home. Can't wait to go back and try every pizza on the menu. If you're in Watertown and craving authentic Italian pizza, Tony's is the place to be!“

“Great Italian food... the pizza one of a kind with a savory cheesy fresh taste. Bernardo.... a great Italian chef down to earth, made me feel at home also let me try a special dish just for the sake of it ya know. It was actually great I love gilled peppers ?️ and man he can chef up some fresh food. I will return soon. The staff was very warm and highly respectful great establishment I recommend for some good food✊???Vegetarian options: They have vegetarian optionsKid-friendliness: Nice spots out back when the weather's good that seat up to 4 people you also can dine in great stop for you and the kids if you want some good food“